Bidirectional yet asymmetric causality between urban systems and traffic dynamics in 30 cities worldwide Journal: Journal of L a T e X Templates
Yatao Zhang, Ye Hong, Song Gao, Martin Raubal · 2025
Read Bidirectional yet asymmetric causality between urban systems and traffic dynamics in 30 cities worldwide Journal: Journal of L a T e X Templates by Yatao Zhang, Ye Hong, Song Gao, Martin Raubal (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-25155.txt.
Introduction
Yatao Zhang, Ye Hong, Song Gao, and Martin Raubal map how town systems and traffic shape each other, in both ways, across thirty towns on six land masses. How towns grow and how folks move are tied in loops, yet cause in both ways at once is hard to pull from mere links. Their frame joins two tools to get at it.
One tool weights town reads by space and time; the other traces how one run can foretell the other when crossed. Town form and use swayed traffic more than town make up did, though make up linked more tight. In most towns, the town to traffic sway beat the back sway. Long run back sway still showed.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Yatao Zhang, Ye Hong, Song Gao, Martin Raubal |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 67 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-25155
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Bidirectional yet asymmetric causality between urban systems and traffic dynamics in 30 cities worldwide Journal: Journal of L a T e X Templates Yatao Zhang, Ye Hong, Song Gao, Martin Raubal Abstract Understanding how urban systems and traffic dynamics co-evolve is crucial for advancing sustainable and resilient cities. However, their bidirectional causal relationships remain underexplored due to challenges of simultaneously inferring spatial heterogeneity, temporal variation, and feedback mechanisms. To address this gap, we propose a novel spatio-temporal causality framework that bridges correlation and causation by integrating spatio-temporal weighted regression with a newly developed spatio-temporal convergent cross-mapping approach. Characterizing cities through urban structure, form, and function, the framework uncovers bidirectional causal patterns between urban systems and traffic dynamics across 30 cities on six continents. Our findings reveal asymmetric bidirectional causality, with urban systems exerting stronger influences on traffic dynamics than the reverse in most cities. Urban form and function shape mobility more profoundly than structure, even though structure often exhibits higher correlations, as observed in cities such as Singapore, New Delhi, London, Chicago, and Moscow. This does not preclude the reversed causal direction, whereby long-established mobility patterns can also reshape the built environment over time. Finally, we identify three distinct causal archetypes: tightly coupled, pattern-heterogeneous, and workday-attenuated, which map pathways from causal diagnosis to intervention. This typology supports city-to-city learning and lays a foundation for context-sensitive strategies in sustainable urban and transport planning. Cities function as complex systems where human mobility and the built environment continuously interact [ Xu et al. 2021 , Pappalardo et al. 2023 , Cao et al. 2024 , Dong et al. 2024 ] . These interactions manifest in diverse ways within urban traffic systems. For example, transit-integrated urban design in Singapore facilitates individual movement through extensive public transport networks, whereas London’s historic and fragmented road layout amplifies congestion-prone traffic patterns. Accordingly, traffic dynamics serve as a tangible indicator of these interactions, reflecting not only how urban systems shape movement patterns but also how human mobility reciprocally influences the built environment [ Zhang and Raubal 2022 , Xu et al. 2023 , Liu and Yuan 2024 ] . Understanding these bidirectional influences is crucial for designing adaptive transportation policies and promoting sustainable urban development. Given the complexity and multifaceted nature of cities, comprehensively characterizing urban systems is an important prerequisite for investigating these bidirectional influences [ Batty 2012 , Dong et al. 2024 ] . Here, we characterize cities through three interconnected components: urban structure, form, and function, collectively forming the “triple helix” of urban systems. Urban structure establishes the physical backbone of a city, primarily through its road networks [ Lämmer et al. 2006 , Xie and Levinson 2007 ] . Building on this structural foundation, urban form determines the spatial layout and configuration of the city, while urban function embeds the distribution of land uses and socioeconomic activities across these spatial arrangements [ Crooks et al. 2015 , Boeing 2021 , Arribas-Bel and Fleischmann 2022 ] . Although closely related, they capture different facets of urban systems that influence traffic dynamics through distinct mechanisms [ Cao et al. 2024 , Miotti et al. 2023 , Wang and Debbage 2021 ] . For example, road network topology constrains route choice, whereas district form and function drive the demand for travel orientations and destinations. Together, these three components govern how urban systems interact with human mobility, shaping the spatial and temporal patterns of traffic dynamics. Existing studies have primarily examined associations among these components, applying such insights to develop analytical models for urban dynamics, traffic forecasting, and public transit systems [ Xu et al. 2023 , Xu et al. 2021 , Zhang et al. 2023 , Gan et al. 2020 ] . However, the bidirectional feedbacks that govern these interactions and the potential asymmetries in their strength remain underexplored, despite being central to their dynamic and reciprocal nature. For example, while efficient road planning can mitigate traffic congestion, persistent congestion can also reshape urban systems, as seen in cities that expand metro networks in response to traffic pressure [ Yu et al. 2023 ] . Without accounting for this feedback, developed models may lead to an underestimation of long-term shifts in mobility and infrastructure demands. Understanding these feedback mechanisms requires moving beyond statistical associations toward causal modeling that addresses both spatial dependency and temporal variation [ Rohrer 2018 , Deng et al. 2021 ] . Causal inference has proven effective in capturing interactions among diverse elements of urban and traffic systems, ranging from linking individual mobility to health outcomes [ Zhang et al. 2021 ] , to diagnosing congestion in road networks [ Mao et al. 2025 ] , and disentangling complex urban processes [ Gan et al. 2025 ] . Among these, convergent cross mapping (CCM) has emerged as a robust tool for detecting nonlinear and bidirectional causal relationships in urban contexts [ Wang et al. 2024 , Mao et al. 2025 ] . However, most existing studies focus on investigating causal inference in time-series data to establish temporal causality within the built environment. In contrast, spatial causality modeling remains relatively underexplored, largely due to challenges in modeling spatial dependencies that underlie geographical processes [ Akbari et al. 2023 ] . A feasible solution is to adapt causal inference models to the spatial domain by integrating spatial dependencies in urban space, as exemplified by the geographical convergent cross mapping (GCCM) framework [ Gao et al. 2023 ] . However, GCCM fails to incorporate temporal changes that are fundamental to urban systems. As features characterizing urban structure, form, and function evolve gradually, movement patterns fluctuate much more rapidly, producing pronounced temporal variations in urban dynamics [ Cao et al. 2024 ] . In addition, causal mechanisms are inherently spatially heterogeneous, varying substantially across cities [ Dong et al. 2024 , Cattaneo et al. 2024 , Zhang et al. 2024 ] . This spatial adaptability of causality complicates the bidirectional interactions between urban systems and traffic dynamics, which highlights the need for an integrated spatio-temporal framework to enhance context-aware understanding of urban dynamics and foster city-to-city learning networks for knowledge exchange. To address these challenges, we propose a spatio-temporal causality framework that bridges correlation and causation by identifying bidirectional causal relationships between urban systems and traffic dynamics. At its core is a novel method we developed, spatio-temporal convergent cross mapping (STCCM), which extends CCM and GCCM by jointly embedding spatial dependence and temporal variation into the state-space reconstruction. The framework combines STCCM with spatio-temporal weighted regression (STWR) (see Methods). In detail, STWR first quantifies spatially heterogeneous and temporally non-stationary associations between urban systems and traffic dynamics, yielding composite indicators that summarize multi-factor effects on urban structure, form, and function, respectively. Then, STCCM uses these indicators to infer nonlinear, bidirectional, and potentially asymmetric causal pathways during congestion periods, which represent mobility-infrastructure mismatches and thus render causal patterns more detectable and policy-relevant. This integrated pipeline generates comparable causal fingerprints across space and time, converting heterogeneous associations into directional evidence of causality. To ensure broad representativeness, we apply this framework to 30 cities with diverse urban contexts, selected based on data availability, traffic congestion levels, and global distribution (see Methods). These cities encompass major metropolitan capitals in developed countries and economic