Bayesian probabilistic projections of proportions with limited data: An application to subnational contraceptive method supply shares.
Hannah Comiskey · 2025
Read Bayesian probabilistic projections of proportions with limited data: An application to subnational contraceptive method supply shares. by Hannah Comiskey (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-25153.txt.
Introduction
Hannah Comiskey, Niamh Cahill, Leontine Alkema, David Fraizer, and Worapree Maneesoonthorn project shares of birth control supply by zone when local data are thin. Where women get their birth control, from state or shop sources, shapes fair and green care plans. Land wide reads hide how shares shift from zone to zone.
As states push care calls down to zones, zone reads are now a must, yet they are logged on no set beat. The team's Bayes plan draws hid traits from a known health poll to fill the gap. It gives zone shares with odds based bands, not just point reads. That lets zone staff plan with doubt in view.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Hannah Comiskey |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 52 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-25153
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Bayesian probabilistic projections of proportions with limited data: An application to subnational contraceptive method supply shares. Hannah Comiskey Abstract Abstract Engaging the private sector in contraceptive method supply is critical for creating equitable, sustainable, and accessible healthcare systems. To achieve this, it is essential to understand where women obtain their modern contraceptives. While national-level estimates provide valuable insights into overall trends in contraceptive supply, they often obscure variation within and across subnational regions. Addressing localized needs has become increasingly important as countries adopt decentralized models for family planning services. Decentralization has also underscored the need for reliable subnational estimates of key family planning indicators. The absence of regularly collected subnational data has hindered effective monitoring and decision-making. To bridge this gap, we propose a novel approach that leverages latent attributes in Demographic and Health Survey (DHS) data to produce Bayesian probabilistic projections of contraceptive method supply shares (the proportions of modern contraceptive methods supplied by public and private sectors) with limited data. Our modeling framework is built on Bayesian hierarchical models. Using penalized splines to track public and private supply shares over time, we leverage the spatial nature of the data and incorporate a correlation structure between recent supply share observations at national and subnational levels. This framework contributes to the domain of subnational estimation of proportions in data-sparse settings, outperforming comparable and previous approaches. As decentralization continues to reshape family planning services, producing reliable subnational estimates of key indicators is increasingly vital for researchers and policymakers. Introduction FP2030 is a global partnership committed to empowering women and girls through investments in rights-based family planning [ 1 ] . This approach emphasizes accessibility and availability of contraceptives [ 2 ] . Traditionally, the public sector has led family planning efforts [ 3 ] , but declining donor funding has spurred interest in private sector engagement [ 4 , 5 , 6 ] . Leveraging private sector contributions enhances equitable, accessible, and sustainable reproductive healthcare [ 7 , 8 ] . Recent initiatives, such as WHO’s 2024 online training for pharmacists, aim to expand contraceptive access in low- and middle-income countries [ 9 ] . Pharmacies play a crucial role, particularly in providing short-term methods like oral contraceptives and condoms [ 10 ] . Unmarried women and teenagers disproportionately rely on the private sector due to privacy concerns [ 11 ] . Therefore, understanding contraceptive access patterns is essential for equity [ 8 , 11 ] . National estimates of family planning indicators aid global reporting but overlook local trends and fail to assess if target levels for indicators are being ubiquitously attained across the nation. Furthermore, a decentralized approach to family planning management improves sector performance [ 12 , 13 ] . Subnational estimates are widely used in demography for tracking contraceptive prevalence, unmet need, and under-5 mortality [ 14 , 15 , 16 ] , yet gaps remain in monitoring contraceptive supply sources. Small area estimation (SAE) involves estimating characteristics of sub-populations, where there may be few or no samples available, by ’borrowing strength’ from related populations to improve accuracy [ 17 ] . Using SAE approaches to model demographic and health outcomes is a well-established practice. In 1979, the foundational Fay-Herriot modelling approach described a two-stage hierarchical area-level model that allowed for the weighted estimates of area-level characteristics [ 18 ] . Building on this, in 1991 Basag, York, and Mollie (BYM) described an approach that uses both spatially structured variation and independent unstructured variation to capture underlying disease prevalence [ 19 ] . Since these models, the area of SAE has exploded with progress in many different directions including generalised linear mixed models, Bayesian hierarchical models, and conditional autoregressive (CAR) models [ 20 ] [ 21 ] [ 22 ] [ 23 ] . Previous works considered the distribution of contraceptive method supply shares at the national level using a Bayesian hierarchical penalized spline model, and explored its application to subnational data. [ 24 ] [ 25 ] . Bayesian hierarchical models are also very useful in SAE. They allow for the pooling of information across larger populations to inform smaller sub-population estimates, where data is more sparse. Therefore, Bayesian hierarchical models will be used again in this instance to inform and estimate subnational method supply shares. The Comiskey et al. (2024) approach also estimates and incorporates cross-method correlations to inform the rates of change in spline coefficients. However, at the subnational level, capturing cross-method correlations within the rates of change between spline coefficients becomes difficult due to the heterogeneity of subnational data. Instead, we present an approach that captures the cross-method correlations for the most recently observed survey levels of public sector supply shares. Lastly, the Comiskey et al. (2024) approach uses a three-tiered hierarchical grouping structure, reflecting the geographical nature of the method supply share data, when estimating key model parameters. However, we found that a simplified two-tiered hierarchical estimation process performed just as well while also reducing model complexity. Overall, we have adapted the national-level modelling approach of Comiskey et al. (2024) to subnational regions where the sampling density is lower (i.e., fewer women sampled per estimate) and consequently the uncertainty associated with the survey observations is higher than what is observed as the national level. While this updated approach also uses Bayesian hierarchical estimation techniques for key parameters, we employ simplified geographic grouping structure. In addition, the updated approach provides key insights into the latent cross-method correlations that exist between the most recently observed levels of contraceptive method supply shares. Finally, the flexibility of this updated modelling approach captures the nature of an otherwise complex time- and spatially-varying dataset. At the time of writing, these subnational estimates, complete with uncertainty measures, represent a significant advancement in monitoring contraceptive supply shares. They provide an insight into subnational spatial and temporal supply-share trends for researchers, with the potential to improve access and equity in family planning services. The outline of this paper is as follows. We begin with the definitions used throughout this paper and the data utilised in this approach. In the Methods section we describe the hierarchical penalised spline model. In Results, we consider the output of this model, which we then compare with various approaches listed in the Supplementary Materials, via an extensive model comparision study. We conclude the paper with a discussion. The Supplementary Materials contain more technical details and additional supporting information. Definitions and data sources Definitions Modern contraceptive methods are defined as “a product or medical procedure that interferes with reproduction from acts of sexual intercourse” [ 26 ] . During this investigation, we consider five main modern methods of contraception. These are female sterilization, oral contraceptive pills (OC pills), implants (including Implanon, Jadelle and Sino-implant), intra-uterine devices (IUD, including Copper- T 380-A IUD and LNGIUS), and injectables (including Depo Provera (DMPA), Noristerat (NET-En), Lunelle, Sayana Press and other injectables). Contraceptive method supply shares are defined as ”the percent distribution of the types of service-delivery points cited by users as the source of their current contraceptive method (if more than one source, then the most recent one)” [ 27 ] . This paper considers a public/private sector breakdown for each of the five contraceptive methods listed. Contraceptives supplied by