Universality of Ising spin correlations on critical doubly-periodic graphs

Rémy Mahfouf A · 2025

Read Universality of Ising spin correlations on critical doubly-periodic graphs by Rémy Mahfouf A (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-25019.txt.

Introduction

Remy Mahfouf, the sole author, proves that spin links in the Ising model act the same at the brink on a wide class of grids. The grids repeat in two ways, like a tile floor. At the brink point, past work on the plain square grid showed the links take a smooth shape in the large view.

Mahfouf shows the same smooth limit holds on the tile grids, with no need for the exact solve tricks of the square case. Tools from discrete math and chance cluster ways fill the gap. The brink rule for such grids was known from past work, as was their smooth frame. This proof caps the shared shape tale for tile grids.

Catalog record

CREATORRémy Mahfouf A
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE122 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-25019

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Universality of Ising spin correlations on critical doubly-periodic graphs Thanks: A Université de Genève. Thanks: E-mail: [email protected] Rémy Mahfouf A Abstract . We establish conformal invariance of Ising spin correlations on critical doubly periodic graphs, showing that their scaling limit coincides with that of the critical square lattice, as originally proved in [ 13 ] . To overcome the absence of integrability and quantitative full plane constructions in the periodic setting, we combine discrete analytic tools with random cluster methods. This result completes the universality picture for periodic lattices, whose criticality condition was identified in [ 23 ] and whose conformal structure and interface convergence were obtained in [ 8 ] . 1. Introduction 1.1. General context The Ising model, introduced by Ising and Lenz [ 41 ] , remains one of the most studied models in probability and statistical mechanics, especially in the planar nearest-neighbour case without external field (see, e.g., the monographs [ 33 , 53 , 57 ] and references therein). We adopt a convention dual to the standard setup, assigning \pm 1 spins to the set G^{\circ} of faces of a planar graph G . When G is finite and connected, one specifies to each edge e\in E(G) , which separates two faces v^{\circ}_{\pm}(e)\in G^{\circ} , a positive coupling constant J_{e} . This ferromagnetic model favours configurations in which neighbouring spins align. For a fixed inverse temperature \beta>0 , one defines a probabilistic model on spin configurations \sigma\in\{\pm 1\}^{G^{\circ}} , with partition function given by \mathcal{Z}(G)\ :=\ \sum_{\sigma:G^{\circ}\to\{\pm 1\}}\exp\Bigl[\beta\sum_{e\in E(G)}J_{e}\sigma_{v^{\circ}_{-}(e)}\sigma_{v^{\circ}_{+}(e)}\Bigr]. (1.1) In the homogeneous Ising model on the square lattice, a phase transition occurs between the paramagnetic and ferromagnetic phases as the inverse temperature varies. At the critical temperature- the Curie point observed in early magnetic experiments [ 24 ] - the model exhibits remarkable features, revealing deep links between statistical mechanics, complex analysis, and algebra. Following Smirnov’s introduction of discrete fermionic observables on the square lattice [ 65 , 63 ] , a series of works established the conformal invariance (or covariance) of the critical model [ 63 , 13 , 16 , 39 , 42 ] , as predicted by Conformal Field Theory (see, e.g., [ 2 , 68 ] ). In essence, these results show that, on bounded domains, the critical Ising model admits a continuous scaling limit as the mesh size tends to zero, and that limits on conformally equivalent domains are related by the corresponding conformal map. This programme was later extended to critical isoradial graphs for correlation functions [ 17 ] , while the convergence of interfaces [ 3 , 22 ] follows from essentially the same arguments as in the square-lattice case. Further studies on isoradial graphs investigated near-critical models with Baxter’s Z-invariant weights [ 6 , 7 , 1 ] , approaching criticality [ 58 , 59 , 17 ] and confirming long-standing predictions linking the model to the massive Dirac equation [ 52 , 61 ] . Extending this framework beyond the isoradial case introduces significant challenges, due to the lack of a natural discrete conformal structure for analysing Ising fermions. The notion of s -embeddings, introduced in [ 9 , 8 ] , provides such a structure, with critical doubly-periodic graphs as a fundamental new example. The criticality condition for these graphs, obtained by Cimasoni and Duminil-Copin [ 23 ] via a connection to the dimer model, is expressed algebraically in terms of edge weights on the fundamental domain. In [ 8 ] , it was shown that every critical Ising model on a doubly-periodic graph admits (up to rotation, scaling, and complex conjugation) a unique associated s -embedding. This enabled the construction of a discrete complex analysis framework, allowing Chelkak in that same article to prove the convergence of FK-Ising interfaces to SLE (16/3) , as in the square-lattice case. Studying the critical Ising model on doubly-periodic graphs falls within Kadanoff’s universality framework, asserting that microscopic details of the model should have little impact on its large-scale behaviour, which depends only on a few global parameters. However, while the convergence of FK interfaces is now established for such graphs, the behaviour of correlation functions remains unresolved. The powerful integrable techniques used on isoradial graphs, which rely on constructing full-plane fermionic observables with prescribed singularities and asymptotics, do not extend to critical doubly-periodic lattices. In this work, we establish the universality of Ising spin correlations on critical doubly-periodic graphs using soft discrete complex analysis methods combined with random-cluster techniques. 1.2. The critical Ising model on doubly-periodic graphs When working on isoradial lattices, the notion of a critical model often appears naturally by choosing combinatorial weights that admit a geometric interpretation (see, e.g., [ 21 ] for the FK-Ising model, [ 37 , 36 ] for percolation, [ 6 , 7 , 5 ] for dimers, and [ 20 ] for random walks and discrete harmonic functions). These critical weights turn out to be invariant under the star-triangle transformation of the associated model. On isoradial grids there exist two notions of star-triangle deformation. On the one hand, there is a combinatorial star-triangle transformation of the model’s weights, which performed in a suitable way, does not change the probability measure of events far from the local modification. On the other hand, there exists an exchange of train tracks in isoradial lattices, corresponding to some purely geometric moves on isoradial lattices. The geometric formulae used to define critical isoradial weights make those two frameworks match. It is known that general doubly-periodic lattices equipped with the Ising model cannot admit an isoradial embedding [ 45 ] . Therefore, trying to find a geometric criticality condition on the weights starting from a given isoradial picture does not work for the generic periodic case. Nevertheless, a way forward was found in two different articles using the exact bosonisation [ 27 ] of the Ising model as a dimer model. When the doubly-periodic graph has a \mathbb{Z}^{2} combinatorial structure, a connection to the dimer context was first established by Li [ 48 ] and later generalised in [ 23 ] to all doubly periodic graphs. To be more precise, let us introduce some additional notation. Consider a weighted planar graph (G,x) embedded in the plane up to homeomorphism preserving the cyclic ordering of edges. Denote its vertices by G^{\bullet} and its faces by G^{\circ} . The bipartite graph \Lambda(G):=G^{\bullet}\cup G^{\circ} has edges connecting each vertex to the faces it belongs to. Each quad z_{e}=(v^{\bullet}_{0}v^{\circ}_{0}v^{\bullet}_{1}v^{\circ}_{1}) of \Lambda(G) corresponds to an edge e of G , linking v^{\bullet}_{0} and v^{\bullet}_{1} and separating the faces v^{\circ}_{0} and v^{\circ}_{1} . We denote by e^{\star} the dual edge linking v^{\circ}_{0} and v^{\circ}_{1} in the graph G^{\circ} , with (e^{\star})^{\star}=e . Under this identification, one can parametrise the coupling constant x(e) using the abstract angle as \theta_{z(e)}\ :=\ 2\arctan x(e)\ \in\ (0,\tfrac{\pi}{2}),\quad x(e):=\exp[-2\beta J_{e}]. (1.2) It turns out that in the periodic case, the criticality condition can be written as a purely algebraic statement on the weights x(e) over the fundamental domain. Let (\mathcal{G},x) be a planar, non-degenerate, locally finite, doubly-periodic weighted graph. Denote by \Gamma its fundamental domain, naturally embedded in the torus (with no specification on that torus embedding). Let \mathcal{E}(\Gamma) be the set of even subgraphs

Read the complete text