Intermediate subgroups of braid groups
are not bi-orderable · 2025
Read Intermediate subgroups of braid groups by are not bi-orderable (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-24947.txt.
Introduction
R M de A Cruz, the sole author, settles an order puzzle for braid groups on flat shapes. Braids track how strands swap in a disk or on a surface, and a group is two way ordered if its parts can be lined in a way that fits group acts. Pure braid groups are known to fit that rule, while full braid groups do not.
Cruz asks what sits between the two: a group that holds all pure braids plus some more, but not all braids. For three or more strands, any such mid group fails the two way order rule too, he shows. The claim spans a wide set of base shapes, with a few named shapes left out.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | are not bi-orderable |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 37 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-24947
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Intermediate subgroups of braid groups are not bi-orderable Abstract Abstract: Let M be the disk or a compact, connected surface without boundary different from the sphere S^{2} and the real projective plane \mathbb{R}P^{2} , and let N be a compact, connected surface (possibly with boundary). It is known that the pure braid groups P_{n}(M) of M are bi-orderable, and, for n\geq 3 , that the full braid groups B_{n}(M) of M are not bi-orderable. The main purpose of this article is to show that for all n\geq 3 , any subgroup H of B_{n}(N) that satisfies P_{n}(N)\subsetneq H\subset B_{n}(N) is not bi-orderable. Key words: Braid groups, pure braid groups, group orderings. 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification: primary: 20F36; secondary: 20F60, 06F15. 1 Introduction A group G is said to be left-orderable if it can be equipped with a strict total ordering < which is left-invariant. More precisely, if x<y , then gx<gy for all x,y,g\in G . If the ordering < is also right-invariant, then (G,<) is said to be bi-orderable . Some examples of bi-orderable groups are free groups [ 49 ] , Thompson’s groups [ 10 , 41 ] , torsion-free nilpotent groups [ 43 , Proposition 3.16] , diagram groups [ 30 , Theorem 6.1] , and the fundamental group of some 3 -manifolds [ 48 ] . Left-orderable groups that cannot be bi-ordered include the groups \operatorname{Homeo}_{+}(\mathbb{R}) and \operatorname{Homeo}_{+}(\mathbb{Q\times Q}) of order-preserving homeomorphisms [ 40 ] , the universal covering group of the group SL_{2}(\mathbb{R}) of 2\times 2 real matrices with determinant equal to one [ 6 ] , and the fundamental group of the Klein bottle [ 48 ] . Let M be a compact, connected surface, and let n\geq 1 . The set: \{(z_{1},\dots,z_{n});\ z_{i}\in M\ \text{and}\ z_{i}\neq z_{j},\ \text{for}\ i\neq j\} is called the nth (ordered) configuration space of M and is denoted by F_{n}(M) . The map (\sigma,(z_{1},\dots,z_{n}))\mapsto(z_{\sigma(1)},\dots,z_{\sigma(n)}) defines a free action of S_{n} , the symmetric group on n letters, on F_{n}(M) . The corresponding quotient, which is the orbit space F_{n}(M)/S_{n} , will be denoted by C_{n}(M) , and is called the nth unordered configuration space of M . The pure braid group of M on n strands , denoted by P_{n}(M) , is defined to be the fundamental group of F_{n}(M) , and the (full) braid group of M on n strands , denoted by B_{n}(M) , is defined to be the fundamental group of C_{n}(M) [ 18 , 21 , 51 ] . The braid groups B_{n}(D) of the disk D , also known as Artin braid groups , are residually finite [ 1 , 4 , 13 , Proposition 5] , Hopfian [ 37 ] and linear [ 7 , 35 ] . They admit solvable word problem [ 2 ] and conjugacy problem [ 23 ] , and they are not locally indicable for n\geq 5 [ 47 ] . Moreover, if M is a compact, connected surface without boundary, the braid groups B_{n}(M) are torsion-free with the exception of the sphere S^{2} and the real projective plane \mathbb{R}P^{2} [ 18 , 19 , 50 ] . If M\neq D,S^{2} is such that its fundamental group has trivial center, then the center of B_{n}(M) is trivial [ 28 , 44 ] . More properties of surface braid groups may be found in [ 8 , 27 , 29 , 31 , 44 ] . As proved by Dehornoy [ 15 ] , braid groups of the disk are left-orderable. However, it is known that they cannot be bi-ordered, because they do not have the unique root property (see Equation 7 ). Since B_{n}(D)\subset B_{n}(M) , where D is a topological disk in M and M is a compact, connected surface different from S^{2} and \mathbb{R}P^{2} [ 44 ] , B_{n}(M) is not bi-orderable for n\geq 3 . Garside [ 23 ] defined a partial order on the semigroup B_{n}(D)^{+} of the so-called positive braids , i.e. non-trivial braids of the disk that can be written in terms of positive powers of the Artin generators (see Theorem 3 ). Later, Elrifai and Morton [ 16 ] gave a partial ordering of B_{n}(D) . The pure braid groups of the disk and of compact, connected orientable surfaces with the exception of the sphere S^{2} are bi-orderable [ 26 , 33 ] . However, if N is a non-orientable surface and n\geq 2 , González-Meneses [ 26 ] exhibited generalized torsion elements in P_{n}(N) , and therefore P_{n}(N) is not bi-orderable. Moreover, if M is S^{2} or \mathbb{R}P^{2} , then P_{n}(M) contains torsion elements [ 19 , 50 ] , so it is not left-orderable, and consequently, the braid groups B_{n}(S^{2}) and B_{n}(\mathbb{R}P^{2}) are not left-orderable. In this article, we will study the bi-orderability of subgroups H of B_{n}(M) satisfying P_{n}(M)\subsetneq H\subset B_{n}(M) , where either M=D or M is a compact, connected surface different from S^{2} and \mathbb{R}P^{2} . We shall refer to such subgroups as intermediate subgroups of B_{n}(M) . We first discuss the case of the disk, and we then use a restriction of the embedding B_{n}(D)\hookrightarrow B_{n}(M) [ 25 , 44 ] , induced by the inclusion of D in M , to extend our results to compact, connected surfaces. More precisely, our main results are as follows. Theorem 1 . Let n\geq 3 . If H is a bi-orderable subgroup of B_{n}(D) such that P_{n}(D)\subset H\subset B_{n}(D) , then H=P_{n}(D) , i.e. P_{n}(D) is a maximal bi-orderable subgroup of B_{n}(D) . Theorem 2 . Let n\geq 3 , and let M\neq S^{2},\mathbb{R}P^{2} be a compact, connected surface. Let H be an intermediate subgroup of B_{n}(M) . Then, H is not bi-orderable. Besides the Introduction, this paper consists of two sections. In Section 2 , we give preliminary definitions and we state some well-known results on surface braid groups and orderable groups. The goal of Section 3 , which consists of four subsections, is to investigate the bi-orderability of a certain family of intermediate subgroups of the Artin braid groups, and to prove Theorems 1 and 2 . We finish the paper with some consequences of Theorem 1 , such as the fact that no intermediate subgroups of the braid group B_{\infty}(D) of the disk on infinitely many strands can be bi-ordered. 2 Preliminaries In this section, we recall some results on the braid groups of the disk, such as the classical presentation due to Artin, the description of the center and the structure of the pure braid groups. We also summarize some properties of orderable groups, and we discuss the relation between the unique root property and the existence of generalized torsion elements in a group. 2.1 Artin braid groups Let M be a compact, connected surface, and let n\geq 1 . The canonical projection F_{n}(M)\to C_{n}(M) is a regular n! -fold covering map, which leads to the following short exact sequence: 1\longrightarrow P_{n}(M)\longrightarrow B_{n}(M)\xlongrightarrow{\pi}S_{n}\longrightarrow 1, (1) where \pi\colon B_{n}(M)\to S_{n} associates the permutation corresponding to the endpoints of the strands of a braid. The group homomorphism \pi is called the permutation homomorphism . When M is the disk D , Artin [ 1 , 3 ] studied geometric and algebraic properties of its braid