S3C2 Summit 2025-03: Industry Secure Supply Chain Summit

Elizabeth Lin ∗ , Jonah Ghebremichael ∗ , William Enck ∗ , Yasemin Acar † , Michel Cukier ‡ , Alexandros Kapravelos ∗ , Christian Kästner § , Laurie Williams ∗ · 2025

Read S3C2 Summit 2025-03: Industry Secure Supply Chain Summit by Elizabeth Lin ∗ , Jonah Ghebremichael ∗ , William Enck ∗ , Yasemin Acar † , Michel Cukier ‡ , Alexandros Kapravelos ∗ , Christian Kästner § , Laurie Williams ∗ (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-24920.txt.

Introduction

Elizabeth Lin and seven co-authors report a March 2025 meet of firms and state staff on safe software supply chains. Such chains give much worth, but a weak link can let in an attack that hits near all web users. Hacks on these chains have grown fast in the past few years.

Four hosts from a state backed safe chain hub ran the meet, with eighteen guests from seventeen groups. Goals were to swap field tales on what works and what hurts in guard of these chains. The report sums what guests shared on real use, gaps, and needs. It is a field view for both shops and rule makers.

Catalog record

CREATORElizabeth Lin ∗ , Jonah Ghebremichael ∗ , William Enck ∗ , Yasemin Acar † , Michel Cukier ‡ , Alexandros Kapravelos ∗ , Christian Kästner § , Laurie Williams ∗
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE30 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-24920

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

S3C2 Summit 2025-03: Industry Secure Supply Chain Summit Elizabeth Lin ∗ , Jonah Ghebremichael ∗ , William Enck ∗ , Yasemin Acar † , Michel Cukier ‡ , Alexandros Kapravelos ∗ , Christian Kästner § , Laurie Williams ∗ Abstract . Software supply chains, while providing immense economic and software development value, are only as strong as their weakest link. Over the past several years, there has been an exponential increase in cyberattacks specifically targeting vulnerable links in critical software supply chains. These attacks disrupt the day-to-day functioning and threaten the security of nearly everyone on the internet, from billion-dollar companies and government agencies to hobbyist open-source developers. The ever-evolving threat of software supply chain attacks has garnered interest from both the software industry and US government in improving software supply chain security. On Thursday, March 6th, 2025, four researchers from the NSF-backed Secure Software Supply Chain Center (S3C2) conducted a Secure Software Supply Chain Summit with a diverse set of 18 practitioners from 17 organizations. The goals of the Summit were: (1) to enable sharing between participants from different industries regarding practical experiences and challenges with software supply chain security; (2) to help form new collaborations; and (3) to learn about the challenges facing participants to inform our future research directions. The summit consisted of discussions of six topics relevant to the government agencies represented, including software bill of materials (SBOMs); compliance; malicious commits; build infrastructure; culture; and large language models (LLMs) and security. For each topic of discussion, we presented a list of questions to participants to spark conversation. In this report, we provide a summary of the summit. The open questions and challenges that remained after each topic are listed at the end of each topic’s section, and the initial discussion questions for each topic are provided in the appendix. 1. Introduction On Thursday, March 6th, 2025, four researchers from the NSF-backed Secure Software Supply Chain Center (S3C2) 1 1 1 https://s3c2.org/ conducted a day-long Secure Software Supply Chain Summit with a diverse set of 18 participants from 17 companies. The goals of the Summit were to: (1) to enable sharing between participants from different industries regarding practical experiences and challenges with software supply chain security; (2) to help form new collaborations; and (3) to learn about the challenges facing participants to inform our future research directions. The Summit was conducted under the Chatham House Rule, which means that all participants can freely use the information discussed. However, disclosing who was present, their affiliations, or who said what is forbidden. As such, this report also adheres to the Chatham House Rule, and the affiliations of the participants are not disclosed. Summit participants were recruited from 17 companies invested in software security. Attendance was intentionally capped to create an environment that encourages candid conversations among key stakeholders. The Summit consisted of discussions of six topics that were decided ahead of time by the participants through voting on which topics to discuss. The voting process ensured that the topics were of interest and relevant to the companies represented. The discussion topics included software bill of materials (SBOMs), compliance, malicious commits, build infrastructure, culture, and large language models. Each topic was moderated by one of the S3C2 researchers, beginning with a list of questions to spark conversation. These questions are provided in the appendix. For each of the six topics, this report provides a discussion of continued themes from prior summits ( Tran et al. 2022 ; Dunlap et al. 2023 ; Enck et al. 2023 ; Zahan et al. 2023 ; Tystahl et al. 2024 ; Miller et al. 2024 ; Rahan et al. 2024 ) , followed by new ideas that emerged in this particular summit. Four S3C2 researchers (two professors and two PhD students) took notes on the discussion. The PhD students created a first draft of this report based on these notes, which the two professors then reviewed and revised. The draft was then reviewed by the Summit participants and the other authors of this report, who are also S3C2 researchers and experts in software supply chain security. The remaining sections of this report summarize the Secure Software Supply Chain Summit. 2. Software Bill of Materials The first topic of discussion was Software Bill of Materials. A Software Bill of Materials (SBOM) is a nested inventory of “ingredients” that make up the software component or product and helps to identify and keep track of third-party components of a software system. The Executive Order (EO) 14028 states that any company that sells software to the federal government must issue a complete SBOM that complies with the National Telecommunications and Information Administration (NTIA) Minimal Elements ( House 2021 ) . 2.1. Continued Themes SBOM as a Checkbox One of the key takeaways from our initial summits in 2021 ( Enck and Williams 2022 ) was the desire to utilize SBOMs to enhance security, rather than simply serving as a checkbox. Four years later, this fear was still a topic of discussion. Participants pointed out that some companies do not want any questions on their produced SBOMs and would sometimes “greenwash” the SBOM results, making it seem as if there are no security issues within their software. This sentiment was intertwined with a significant concern about the trust and accuracy of SBOM results. There was a growing concern that developers checking off the SBOM box without giving much thought to its accuracy would undermine its value. Similar to prior summits, some attendees argued that the real importance of SBOMs lies in the process : generating and consuming SBOMs provides an opportunity to better understand software components. They argued that companies willing to provide SBOMs are likely to be more transparent with their software and more willing to address any security issues that arise. SBOMs as a checkbox create an opportunity for companies to communicate and discuss any security issues. During this process, you can assess the company’s stance and attitude toward security in its products. Trusting SBOMs Participants noted that SBOMs received from a supplier may differ from what was expected in the software. SBOMs from different tools may also return different results. Companies face challenges in resolving these differences and are unsure how much trust to place in SBOM results. An attendee expressed the opinion that the software industry should decide on a tool so there is no need to resolve differences. SBOM Sharing Participants shared that they are still unsure of how to generate and consume SBOMs. There is high-level guidance from the EO and corporate, but it is not clear to developers how to implement that. Communicating SBOM information across software suppliers and consumers is challenging. A participant shared that they have yet to receive many requests from customers for SBOMS, but they have been using SBOMs internally to help keep track of components in the company. Legacy Software A participant from a large organization shared their challenges with generating SBOMs for legacy software. Large organizations frequently maintain dozens of products and applications. Many of these products are from companies they acquired, or companies that those companies acquired. These products are also spread across many different business units. Each product has its own supply chain and

Read the complete text