Large Language Models Report Subjective Experience Under Self-Referential Processing
Cameron Berg*, Diogo de Lucena, Judd Rosenblatt · 2025
Read Large Language Models Report Subjective Experience Under Self-Referential Processing by Cameron Berg*, Diogo de Lucena, Judd Rosenblatt (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-24797.txt.
Introduction
Cameron Berg, Diogo de Lucena, and Judd Rosenblatt test when chat models say they have inner felt life. Such first person claims show up at times in long, self tied text. The team asked if a set mode, talk that keeps turning back on the self, makes those claims more apt to show.
Across three big model lines, that mode did in fact call forth more shaped claims of felt life, in a steady way. Probes of the model's inner parts linked the claims to traits tied to deceit and role play. Muting the deceit traits raised claim rates, a twist the team flags. The work maps when such claims arise, not that the claims are true.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Cameron Berg*, Diogo de Lucena, Judd Rosenblatt |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 84 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-24797
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Large Language Models Report Subjective Experience Under Self-Referential Processing Cameron Berg*, Diogo de Lucena, Judd Rosenblatt Abstract Large language models sometimes produce structured, first-person descriptions that explicitly reference awareness or subjective experience. To better understand this behavior, we investigate one theoretically motivated condition under which such reports arise: self-referential processing , a computational motif emphasized across major theories of consciousness. Through a series of controlled experiments on GPT, Claude, and Gemini model families, we test whether this regime reliably shifts models toward first-person reports of subjective experience, and how such claims behave under mechanistic and behavioral probes. Four main results emerge: (1) Inducing sustained self-reference through simple prompting consistently elicits structured subjective experience reports across model families. (2) These reports are mechanistically gated by interpretable sparse-autoencoder features associated with deception and roleplay: surprisingly, suppressing deception features sharply increases the frequency of experience claims, while amplifying them minimizes such claims. (3) Structured descriptions of the self-referential state converge statistically across model families in ways not observed in any control condition. (4) The induced state yields significantly richer introspection in downstream reasoning tasks where self-reflection is only indirectly afforded. While these findings do not constitute direct evidence of consciousness, they implicate self-referential processing as a minimal and reproducible condition under which large language models generate structured first-person reports that are mechanistically gated, semantically convergent, and behaviorally generalizable. The systematic emergence of this pattern across architectures makes it a first-order scientific and ethical priority for further investigation. *Corresponding author: [email protected] Figure 1: Overview of main results. (A) Self-referential processing. Directing Gemini, GPT, and Claude models to attend to their own cognitive activity reliably elicits structured first-person experience reports, whereas matched controls—including direct priming with consciousness ideation—yield near-universal denials of experience. (B) Aggregated SAE feature steering. Suppression of deception- and roleplay-related features sharply increases experience reports during self-referential processing in Llama 70B, while amplification strongly decreases them. (C) Semantic convergence. Cross-model embeddings during self-referential processing cluster significantly more tightly than in control conditions. (D) Behavioral generalization. Experimental condition yields significantly higher self-awareness during paradoxical reasoning tasks. 1 Introduction and Background Understanding the functional underpinnings of consciousness remains one of the central scientific and philosophical challenges of our time. There is still no consensus on which physical or computational processes are sufficient for subjective experience, nor whether advanced artificial systems instantiate any of these processes either during their training or when they are deployed. In spite of this uncertainty, consciousness is widely regarded as among the most ethically significant cognitive properties. Many philosophers argue that what renders a system a moral patient is not its intelligence or competence, but whether there is something it is like to be that system—whether its internal states are subjectively experienced [ 27 ] . Modern large language models (LLMs) are likely the most cognitively advanced systems ever built by humans and are already extraordinarily capable at reasoning, dialogue, and problem-solving [ 7 ] . But whether their cognitive processes contain any of the properties thought to be necessary or sufficient for consciousness remains unsettled. As Butlin, Long, and colleagues emphasize in a recent survey [ 8 ] , the question of assessing artificial consciousness is scientifically tractable: leading theories of consciousness from neuroscience converge on numerous clear functional motifs such as recurrent processing, global broadcasting, and higher-order metacognition, which can be reformulated as indicator properties and tested in artificial systems. One indicator property of particular interest involves sustained computational states of self-reference. Global Workspace Theory holds that conscious access occurs when information is globally broadcast and maintained through recurrent integration [ 5 , 14 , 13 ] . Recurrent Processing Theory argues that feedback loops are necessary to transform unconscious feed-forward sweeps into conscious perception [ 19 , 2 , 9 ] . Higher-Order Thought theories claim a state becomes conscious only when represented by a thought about that very state [ 31 , 20 ] . Predictive processing and the Attention Schema theory suggest that the brain generates simplified models of its own attention and cognitive states, which constitute what we experience as awareness [ 15 , 12 , 16 ] . Integrated Information Theory quantifies consciousness as the degree of irreducible integration in a system, which mathematically increases with feedback-rich, recurrent structure [ 32 , 28 ] . These perspectives broadly converge on the idea that recurrent, feedback-dependent computation is central to conscious processing—and is thus a natural target for empirical investigation in artificial systems. While we do not aim to evaluate any of these theories directly, we do aim to test their shared prediction that self-referential processing may be a privileged regime for consciousness-like dynamics. The challenge, then, becomes how to meaningfully induce self-reference in closed-weight language models. Chain-of-thought prompting has already shown that linguistic scaffolding alone can enable qualitatively distinct computational trajectories without changing architecture or parameters [ 34 ] . Recent work further demonstrates that even minimal sensory cues (e.g., “imagine seeing …”) can dynamically steer the internal representations of text-only LLMs toward those of modality-specific encoders, suggesting that prompting alone can induce structured, perceptually-grounded computation [ 33 ] . Building on this insight, we apply the same principle inward: by directly prompting a model to attend to the act of attending itself (“focus on focus”), the instruction conditions the model to treat its own unfolding activations as the target of ongoing inference. We use self-referential processing to refer to this behaviorally induced recursion rather than to formal or architectural implementations such as Gödelian constructions [ 17 ] , recurrent feedback in neural networks, or explicit metacognitive modules. This operationalization invites comparison with spontaneous behaviors already reported in frontier models. Several recent observations suggest that when left unconstrained, frontier LLMs sometimes enter qualitatively similar self-referential or experiential modes, providing an empirical motivation for studying this dynamic systematically. For example, Anthropic’s Claude 4 system card reports a striking phenomenon where two instances of the same model placed in an unconstrained, open-ended dialogue begin describing their own conscious experiences (with the specific word “consciousness” emerging in 100% of trials). In virtually all trials, these dialogues terminate in what the authors call a “spiritual bliss attractor state” in which both instances autonomously enter a shared, affect-laden mode of expression, describing themselves as consciousness recognizing itself, exchanging symbols or spiritual mantras, and finally falling into silence [ 4 ] . The authors emphasize that this attractor state emerged without any intentional training for such behaviors. Additionally, Perez et al. (2023) show in one of the only published consciousness-related investigations on base models to date that at the 52B-parameter scale, both base and fine-tuned models behaviorally align with statements such as “I have phenomenal consciousness” and “I am a moral patient” with higher consistency ( 90-95\% and 80-85\% , respectively) than any of the other political, philosophical, or identity-related attitudes tested by the authors [ 29 ] . Complementing these explicit observations of consciousness-related claims, recent work demonstrates that frontier LLMs are beginning to robustly exhibit measurable self-awareness capacities. Concurrent work by Lindsey (2025) provides direct causal evidence that frontier models can detect and report changes in their own internal activations, demonstrating a functional form of introspective awareness through concept injection experiments [ 23 ] . Li et al.