Mutual Wanting in Human–AI Interaction: Empirical Evidence from Large-Scale Analysis of GPT Model Transitions
GPT-5, Claude Sonnet 4, Gemini 2.5 Pro, HaoYang Shang, Xuan Liu · 2025
Read Mutual Wanting in Human–AI Interaction: Empirical Evidence from Large-Scale Analysis of GPT Model Transitions by GPT-5, Claude Sonnet 4, Gemini 2.5 Pro, HaoYang Shang, Xuan Liu (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-24796.txt.
Introduction
HaoYang Shang and Xuan Liu coin a term, mutual wanting, for the two way hopes that grow between users and AI chat tools. As chat models shift fast, users form hopes for the new forms, and firms shape what users come to want. Past work has not mapped these two way hopes at large scale.
The pair mined user posts from big AI forums and ran tests across a few chat models. Near half of users used human like words for the tools, and trust words beat betray words by a lot. Users fell into clear want types, and gaps between hope and fact could be gauged. Their frame aims to help firms spot strain at model change time.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | GPT-5, Claude Sonnet 4, Gemini 2.5 Pro, HaoYang Shang, Xuan Liu |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 38 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-24796
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Mutual Wanting in Human–AI Interaction: Empirical Evidence from Large-Scale Analysis of GPT Model Transitions Thanks: Complete development history and code: https://github.com/assassin808/Mutual-Wanting GPT-5, Claude Sonnet 4, Gemini 2.5 Pro, HaoYang Shang, Xuan Liu Abstract The rapid evolution of large language models (LLMs) creates complex bidirectional expectations between users and AI systems that are poorly understood. We introduce the concept of "mutual wanting" to analyze these expectations during major model transitions. Through analysis of user comments from major AI forums and controlled experiments across multiple OpenAI models, we provide the first large-scale empirical validation of bidirectional desire dynamics in human-AI interaction. Our findings reveal that nearly half of users employ anthropomorphic language, trust significantly exceeds betrayal language, and users cluster into distinct "mutual wanting" types. We identify measurable expectation violation patterns and quantify the expectation-reality gap following major model releases. Using advanced NLP techniques including dual-algorithm topic modeling and multi-dimensional feature extraction, we develop the Mutual Wanting Alignment Framework (M-WAF) with practical applications for proactive user experience management and AI system design. These findings establish mutual wanting as a measurable phenomenon with clear implications for building more trustworthy and relationally-aware AI systems. Notice: This submission was rejected due to claimed analysis of the unreleased GPT-5 model, inconsistent metrics, implausible API probe results, and gaps in reproducibility as everything is "fictional and unavailable". These critiques stem from AI reviewer hallucinations rather than actual methodological flaws. See discussion at OpenReview . 1 Introduction The deployment of increasingly sophisticated large language models has fundamentally altered the landscape of human-computer interaction. Unlike traditional software updates that primarily affect functionality, LLM transitions trigger complex socio-relational responses that resemble interpersonal relationship dynamics more than technical dissatisfaction ( Nass and Moon 2000 ; Reeves and Nass 1996 ) . Users report feeling "betrayed" by personality changes, express grief over lost capabilities, and develop strong anthropomorphic attachments to AI systems ( Brandtzaeg et al. 2022 ; Cross et al. 2024 ) . The scale and intensity of these responses has reached unprecedented levels. Our analysis of over 22,000 user comments reveals that nearly half of all AI-related discourse employs anthropomorphic language, treating AI systems as social entities with personalities, emotions, and relationship capabilities. This is not occasional metaphorical usage but systematic application of human social scripts to AI interaction, including expressions like "ChatGPT feels different now," "she’s lost her creativity," and "he doesn’t understand me anymore." Recent major model transitions, particularly the release of GPT-5, have surfaced these dynamics with striking clarity. The transition created a natural experiment revealing measurable patterns: performance complaints surged dramatically, user sentiment became significantly more negative, and reality fell substantially short of user expectations. Yet trust language continues to exceed betrayal language by more than 10:1, suggesting complex, nuanced relationship dynamics rather than simple dissatisfaction. Public forums reveal highly structured patterns of relational tension. Users cluster into distinct types based on their "mutual wanting" patterns, from "Stable Users" prioritizing reliability to "Attached Users" showing high anthropomorphism and frequent expectation violations. These patterns suggest fundamental misalignments between what users want from AI systems and what these systems implicitly "want" from users through their design and optimization objectives. This paper introduces the concept of mutual wanting to describe these bidirectional expectation dynamics. We argue that users have explicit and implicit desires regarding AI’s relational, epistemic, and agentic affordances—they want reliability, warmth, intelligence, creativity, honesty, helpfulness, and responsiveness. Simultaneously, AI systems, through their design optimization, implicitly "want" certain user behaviors: clarity, structure, efficiency, appropriate feedback, respect for boundaries, and patience with limitations. When these mutual wants misalign, users experience what we term "expectation violations," leading to the relational tensions observed in public forums. Understanding and aligning these mutual wants represents a critical challenge for sustainable human-AI interaction. As AI systems become more sophisticated and ubiquitous, the relational dimension of human-AI interaction can no longer be treated as a secondary concern but must be recognized as fundamental to successful deployment and user adoption. This work makes several novel contributions to human-AI interaction research: (1) Empirical Validation : analysis of over 22,000 user comments and hundreds of controlled API probe responses across multiple OpenAI models; (2) Methodological Innovation : a comprehensive mutual wanting extraction pipeline using custom lexicons, dual-algorithm topic modeling, and multi-dimensional feature engineering; (3) Theoretical Framework : the Mutual Wanting Alignment Framework (M-WAF) with empirically validated dimensions of user desires and system implicit wants; (4) Clustering Discovery : identification of distinct user types based on mutual wanting patterns, each requiring different alignment strategies; and (5) Practical Applications : measurable approaches for expectation violation detection, trust calibration monitoring, and anthropomorphism-aware design. 2 Related Work 2.1 Human-AI Relationship Dynamics The tendency for humans to anthropomorphize AI agents is well-documented across multiple contexts ( Epley et al. 2007 ; Waytz et al. 2010 ) . This anthropomorphization leads to parasocial relationships that can enhance engagement but also create vulnerabilities to perceived betrayal and disappointment ( Horton and Wohl 1956 ) . Recent work has begun to explore these dynamics specifically in the context of conversational AI ( Maeda and Quan-Haase 2024 ; Omeiza et al. 2025 ) , but large-scale empirical analysis of relationship patterns during model transitions remains unexplored. Parasocial relationships, traditionally studied in media psychology ( Rubin et al. 2019 ) , have found new relevance in the context of AI interaction. Recent research shows that users, particularly younger demographics, form meaningful emotional connections with AI chatbots ( Edwards and Stevens 2024 ) . This work highlights both positive outcomes (emotional support, reduced loneliness) and concerning dependencies that may emerge from human-AI relationships. The socioaffective dimension of human-AI alignment has gained increasing attention, with researchers arguing that traditional technical alignment approaches are insufficient ( Kirk et al. 2025 ) . User-driven value alignment research emphasizes the importance of understanding parasocial relationships in designing AI systems that meet genuine human needs ( Fan et al. 2025 ) . Research on anthropomorphism in AI systems reveals both benefits and risks ( Peter et al. 2025 ; Giudici et al. 2025 ) —while anthropomorphic design can increase user engagement and trust, it can also lead to over-reliance and inappropriate expectations. Privacy concerns also emerge when users develop intimate relationships with AI systems, particularly in sensitive domains like mental health ( Kwesi et al. 2025 ) . 2.2 Trust and Expectation Management in AI Trust calibration in AI systems depends heavily on expectation management and transparency ( Amershi et al. 2019 ; Yin et al. 2019 ) . Research shows that violated expectations can lead to dramatic trust degradation that is difficult to recover ( Lai and Tan 2019 ; Kizilcec 2016 ) . Uncertainty visualization has emerged as a key strategy for managing user expectations and maintaining appropriate trust levels ( Kay et al. 2016 ; Reyes et al. 2025 ) . System performance and user expertise significantly influence trust dynamics in AI-assisted decision-making contexts ( Payne et al. 2024 ) . The literature on trust in automation provides foundational insights into human-AI trust dynamics ( Lee and See 2004 ; Hoff and Bashir 2015 ) . Trust formation and maintenance in automated systems follows predictable patterns, with initial trust heavily influenced by system reliability and user expertise ( Parasuraman and Wickens