Comparative Analysis of Procedural Planet Generators
Manuel Zechmann, Helmut Hlavacs · 2025
Read Comparative Analysis of Procedural Planet Generators by Manuel Zechmann, Helmut Hlavacs (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-24764.txt.
Introduction
Manuel Zechmann and Helmut Hlavacs built two real time world makers for fake planets in a game engine, then matched them head to head. One maker stacks a known rough noise in layers. The other copies a layered noise style known from a block game, with its own twists.
Both makers share a tree based detail scheme that adds mesh detail near the viewer. A small user study had fifteen players roam worlds from both makers plus two past world tools. The work lays out how each maker is built, mesh snags they hit, and what users made of each world. It is a hands on guide for small teams.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Manuel Zechmann, Helmut Hlavacs |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 19 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-24764
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Comparative Analysis of Procedural Planet Generators Manuel Zechmann, Helmut Hlavacs Abstract This paper presents the development of two distinct real-time procedural planet generators within the Godot engine: one employing Fractal Brownian Motion (FBM) with Perlin Noise, and another adapting Minecraft-inspired layered noise techniques. We detail their implementation, including a quadtree-based Level of Detail (LOD) system and solutions for planetary mesh generation. A comparative user study (N=15) was conducted where participants explored unique instances generated by our two algorithms alongside two existing procedural planet projects. 1 Introduction Procedural generation enables the creation of vast, diverse worlds without the need for enormous storage. This technique is widely used in video games, such as “No Man’s Sky” [ 12 ] and “Minecraft,” [ 11 ] where algorithms generate massive environments, like unique planets or expansive terrains, with relatively small data sizes. Beyond gaming, procedural generation also finds applications in fields like simulations, urban planning, and real-time modeling, where efficient creation of large and dynamic environments is essential [ 14 ] . This paper details the design, implementation, and comparative evaluation of two distinct real-time procedural planet generation approaches within the Godot game engine. A key challenge in real-time planetary rendering is balancing visual fidelity with performance, particularly given the complexities of spherical geometry. To address this, our framework incorporates a quadtree-based Level of Detail (LOD) system that dynamically adjusts terrain complexity based on camera proximity, alongside solutions for mesh seam stitching and managing large-scale floating-point precision issues by recompiling Godot for 64-bit precision. A comparative study (N=15) assessed how these methods, and two reference projects, influenced immersion, exploration, realism, and controls, with participants exploring unique instances from our generators. 2 Related Work Procedural Content Generation (PCG) is a key technique for efficiently creating vast and detailed worlds in applications such as video games and film. With the growing scale and complexity expected in these areas, PCG offers significant advantages by reducing manual asset creation workload, allowing design teams to focus on core gameplay or narrative elements. PCG particularly excels in generating large-scale environments, including peripheral areas that contribute to a sense of scale and realism with minimal authoring effort [ 16 ] . Noise functions are fundamental to procedural content generation, providing the pseudo-randomness necessary for creating diverse and naturalistic patterns in terrains, textures, and other generated content. A wide array of noise functions exists, from simple White Noise to more structured types like lattice gradient noises (e.g., Perlin Noise [ 13 ] and Simplex Noise) and explicit noises (e.g., Wavelet Noise), each offering distinct visual characteristics and performance trade-offs. An extensive comparison of common procedural noise functions, detailing their computational efficiency, dimensional scalability, visual quality, and memory requirements, is provided by Lague et al. [ 6 ] . The application of Procedural Content Generation (PCG) spans diverse content types in interactive entertainment. De Carli et al. [ 2 ] provide a comprehensive survey, categorizing PCG techniques by content (e.g., terrain, cities) and the level of human involvement required, offering a valuable taxonomy for developers. Noise-based PCG has been particularly successful in generating vast game worlds. “Minecraft” stands as an iconic example, utilizing multiple layers of Perlin noise to create its expansive block-based terrains and diverse biomes [ 18 , 10 ] , inspiring aspects of our "Minecraft-inspired Planet" generator’s layered approach. Generating realistic and engaging terrain is a cornerstone of creating immersive virtual worlds, especially for expansive planetary environments. A multitude of procedural techniques have been explored, broadly ranging from direct noise application to more complex simulation-based and learning-based methods. Noise-based algorithms, particularly those employing Perlin noise and Fractal Brownian Motion (FBM), are widely used for their ability to produce naturalistic, fractal landscapes. Li and Gao [ 8 ] , for instance, demonstrated a method using FBM with modified random midpoint displacement for controllable and diverse terrain features, an approach sharing foundational principles with our “Simple Planet” generator. Creating complete procedural planets extends beyond terrain height generation to encompass atmospheric effects, biome distribution on a spherical surface, and overall environmental coherence. While practical guidance for implementing planetary features such as spherical mesh construction, LOD systems, and basic biome layers can be found in community resources and tutorials (e.g., inspired by work from Lague [ 7 ] and SimonDev [ 15 ] ), academic research also addresses these complex integrations. Efficiently rendering expansive planetary terrains necessitates robust Level of Detail (LOD) systems to balance visual fidelity with real-time performance. Quadtree-based structures are a common approach for dynamically adjusting mesh complexity based on viewer proximity, particularly for large, regular grid terrains, as explored by Liang, Zhou, and Liu [ 9 ] . They emphasized that for very large scales, basic LOD needs to be augmented with further optimizations like view frustum culling and adaptive tiling to manage memory and rendering load effectively. 3 Creation of the Planet Generators This work details the development of two procedural planet generation frameworks, which allow for creation of a random new planet on demand. The complete project is publicly available on GitHub https://github.com/mani1709/PlanetGenerator and the thesis containing more information is available on the website of the University of Vienna 1 1 1 https://phaidra.univie.ac.at/detail/o:2124844 . The engine used for this project is Godot, an open-source game engine known for its flexibility, ease of prototyping, and modifiability. To address precision issues rooted in the large scales involved in planetary generation, the engine was adapted to use 64-bit floating-point precision instead of 32-bit by compiling it from source with the precision=double flag [ 3 ] . This adjustment ensures accurate position calculations at planetary scales while maintaining the benefits of Godot’s rapid development environment. The first of the two planet generators (called “Simple Planet”, see Figure 2 (a)) used in this paper employs Fractal Brownian Motion (FBM) with Perlin Noise to generate 2D heightmaps. By combining multiple octaves of noise, this method produces naturalistic fractal landscapes. Key FBM parameters such as persistence, lacunarity, exponentiation, and the number of octaves are configurable; by adjusting these, developers can generate a wide range of distinct planetary terrain styles, from smooth hills to mountainous worlds. Heights are scaled by a base factor and clamped to always be above a specified ocean level, ensuring flat ocean surfaces. The second planetary generator (“Minecraft-inspired Planet”, see Figure 2 (b)) adapts layered noise for more intricate terrain and biome control, drawing inspiration from games like Minecraft but tailored for spherical surfaces. This method utilizes four distinct 2D Perlin noise layers to generate values for continentalness, erosion, peaks & valleys, and a random temperature component. A key feature for control is the use of configurable spline curves for each noise generator. These splines allow developers to define custom remapping functions by setting control points (e.g., specifying that raw noise inputs from 0.1-0.3 should be remapped to output values of 0.4-0.5). The final terrain height is dynamically calculated based on these noise layers. The continentalness and peaks & valleys values are combined, and this sum is then multiplied by the inverse erosion value (where higher erosion reduces the height). This resulting height factor is scaled by a configurable maximum terrain amplitude and applied to displace each vertex of the normalized quadsphere along its normal, effectively sculpting the planetary surface. An ocean