Rigidity and flexibility results for groups with a common cocompact envelope

Adrien Le Boudec · 2025

Read Rigidity and flexibility results for groups with a common cocompact envelope by Adrien Le Boudec (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-24581.txt.

Introduction

Adrien Le Boudec writes alone on groups that share a large home. A cocompact envelope is a big group holding a smaller one snugly. The small group sits inside as a discrete, cocompact subgroup. Le Boudec takes two finitely generated groups with one shared envelope. He asks which traits the two groups must then share.

For totally disconnected envelopes, nilpotent subgroups must nearly match. Nilpotent groups are built from steps that almost commute. For solvable groups of finite rank, he finds rigidity and flexibility. Rigidity means the partner group must be solvable of finite rank too. Flexibility means he builds partners where that fails outright. So the class is not QI-rigid, not fixed by rough geometry. Similar freedom appears for finitely presented groups as well.

Catalog record

CREATORAdrien Le Boudec
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE128 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-24581

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Rigidity and flexibility results for groups with a common cocompact envelope Adrien Le Boudec Abstract . A locally compact group G G is a cocompact envelope of a group Γ \Gamma if G G contains a copy of Γ \Gamma as a discrete and cocompact subgroup. We study the problem that takes two finitely generated groups Γ , Λ \Gamma,\Lambda having a common cocompact envelope, and asks what properties must be shared between Γ \Gamma and Λ \Lambda . We first consider the setting where the common cocompact envelope is totally disconnected. In that situation we show that if Γ \Gamma admits a finitely generated nilpotent normal subgroup A A , then virtually Λ \Lambda admits a normal subgroup B B such that A A and B B are virtually isomorphic. We establish both rigidity and flexibility results when Γ \Gamma belongs to the class of solvable groups of finite rank. On the rigidity perspective, we show that if Γ \Gamma is solvable of finite rank, and the locally finite radical of Λ \Lambda is finite, then Λ \Lambda must be virtually solvable of finite rank. On the flexibility perspective, we exhibit groups Γ , Λ \Gamma,\Lambda with a common cocompact envelope such that Γ \Gamma is solvable of finite rank, while Λ \Lambda is not virtually solvable. In particular the class of solvable groups of finite rank is not QI-rigid. We also exhibit flexibility behaviours among finitely presented groups, and more generally among groups with type F n F_{n} for arbitrary n ≥ 1 n\geq 1 . Introduction Let G be a locally compact group. A subgroup \Gamma of G is a lattice if \Gamma is discrete in G and G/\Gamma admits a G -invariant finite measure. The study of interactions between properties of G and properties of its lattices is a rich topic, involving geometric, analytic and ergodic aspects. The ambient group G being fixed, the problem of classifying all lattices of G has been intensively studied; historically first in the prominent case of connected Lie groups and algebraic groups over local fields, and gradually for some more locally compact groups. In this paper we are concerned with a different problem, which takes as input a group \Gamma and aims at studying the discrete groups \Lambda such that \Gamma and \Lambda sit as lattices in a common locally compact group. We fix some terminology. Let \Gamma be a discrete group. A locally compact group G is called an envelope of \Gamma if G contains a lattice isomorphic to \Gamma [ Fur67 ] . When the given lattice is cocompact, we say that G is a cocompact envelope of \Gamma . We will mainly focus on the case of cocompact envelopes. We say that two discrete groups \Gamma and \Lambda share a cocompact envelope if there is a locally compact group G such that G is a common cocompact envelope of \Gamma and \Lambda . Recall that an action of a group on a proper metric space by isometries is called geometric if the action is proper and cocompact. For finitely generated groups \Gamma and \Lambda , the existence of a common cocompact envelope is equivalent to the existence of a proper metric space on which \Gamma and \Lambda both act faithfully and geometrically (see e.g. [ CH16 , 4.C-5.B] ). When this holds, the Milnor-Schwarz lemma asserts that the groups \Gamma and \Lambda are quasi-isometric (QI hereafter). Two groups are called virtually isomorphic if they have finite index subgroups that are isomorphic, and virtually isomorphic up to finite kernel if they have finite index subgroups that are isomorphic after modding out by a finite normal subgroup. Definition 1 . Let \mathcal{C} be a class of finitely generated groups. We say that \mathcal{C} is rigid for cocompact envelopes if for every group \Lambda that shares a cocompact envelope with a group \Gamma in \mathcal{C} , the group \Lambda is virtually isomorphic up to finite kernel to a group in \mathcal{C} . We write “CE-rigid” for “rigid for cocompact envelopes” . Recall a class \mathcal{C} is QI-rigid if for every group \Lambda that is QI to a group \Gamma in \mathcal{C} , the group \Lambda is virtually isomorphic up to finite kernel to a group in \mathcal{C} . If \mathcal{C} is QI-rigid then \mathcal{C} is CE-rigid. Hence the question of CE-rigidity of a given class is relevant either when QI-rigidity is not known, or when QI-rigidity is known to fail. More targeted towards locally compact groups, there is the problem of “describing” all cocompact envelopes of a group \Gamma in \mathcal{C} . This problem and the problem of CE-rigidity are both sub-cases of the more general problem of studying all locally compact groups that are commable to a group \Gamma in \mathcal{C} (see § 3.1 for the definition of two groups being commable). Totally disconnected common cocompact envelope We first focus on the situation where the common cocompact envelope G of two groups \Gamma and \Lambda is a totally disconnected locally compact group. For finitely generated groups \Gamma and \Lambda , the existence of a common totally disconnected cocompact envelope is equivalent to the existence of a connected locally finite graph on which \Gamma and \Lambda act faithfully and geometrically. Indeed, if X is such a graph, then the group of automorphisms of X is a common totally disconnected cocompact envelope. And conversely if G is such an envelope, then \Gamma and \Lambda act geometrically on any Cayley-Abels graph of G (see e.g. [ CH16 , 2.E.9] for Cayley-Abels graphs), and \Gamma and \Lambda act faithfully on such a graph provided the associated compact open subgroup of G is sufficiently small. See in addition the beginning of Section 2 for the relevance of considering totally disconnected envelopes. Our first result deals with the class of groups \Gamma having a finitely generated nilpotent normal subgroup. We prove: Theorem 1 . Let \Gamma be a finitely generated group with a normal subgroup A\lhd\Gamma such that A is finitely generated and nilpotent. Suppose that \Gamma and \Lambda share a totally disconnected cocompact envelope. Then there is a finite index subgroup \Lambda^{\prime} of \Lambda such that \Lambda^{\prime} admits a normal subgroup B\lhd\Lambda^{\prime} such that A and B are virtually isomorphic. It is worth comparing Theorem 1 with the situation where \Gamma and \Lambda share a cocompact envelope, but this envelope is not necessarily totally disconnected. Equivalently, the situation where we have two groups \Gamma and \Lambda and a proper metric space on which \Gamma and \Lambda both act faithfully and geometrically, but the metric space acted upon is not necessarily a graph. The groups studied by Leary-Minasyan in [ LM21 ] include examples of groups \Gamma and \Lambda acting faithfully and geometrically on \mathbb{R}^{d}\times T - the product of the d -dimensional Euclidean space \mathbb{R}^{d} and a locally finite tree T - such that \Gamma is of the form \Gamma=A\times F with A=\mathbb{Z}^{d} and F is a non-abelian free group of finite rank, and such that \Lambda does not virtually admit any non-trivial abelian (or nilpotent) normal subgroup. Here the common cocompact envelope is \mathrm{Isom}(\mathbb{R}^{d})\times\mathrm{Aut}(T) . Hence these examples show that Theorem 1 does not hold when the common envelope is not totally disconnected.

Read the complete text