Approaching the Thermodynamic Limit of an Ideal Gas

Prabal Adhikari, Brian C. Tiburzi, Sona Baghiyan · 2025

Read Approaching the Thermodynamic Limit of an Ideal Gas by Prabal Adhikari, Brian C. Tiburzi, Sona Baghiyan (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-24552.txt.

Introduction

Prabal Adhikari and two co-authors examine how an ideal gas approaches the thermodynamic limit, where particle number and volume grow huge. For a confined gas, interactions between particles and the container wall modify the partition function through the average surface density of particles near the wall. These correlations vanish in the limit, but studying them sharpens understanding of how the limit is reached.

Working in the canonical ensemble, the authors contrast a classical and a quantum model of particle wall correlations. Comparing the two shows which finite size effects are purely classical and which come from quantum statistics. The results refine textbook treatments of finite gases in containers.

Catalog record

CREATORPrabal Adhikari, Brian C. Tiburzi, Sona Baghiyan
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE28 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-24552

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Approaching the Thermodynamic Limit of an Ideal Gas Prabal Adhikari, Brian C. Tiburzi, Sona Baghiyan Abstract For a gas confined in a container, particle-wall interactions produce modifications to the partition function involving the average surface density of gas particles. While such correlations have a vanishing effect in the thermodynamic limit, examining them is beneficial for a sharper understanding of how the limit is attained. We contrast a classical and a quantum model of particle-wall correlations within the canonical ensemble. I Introduction Among the primary goals of statistical mechanics is the demonstration of the underlying statistical foundation for the laws of thermodynamics. Extensive thermodynamic quantities emerge for idealized systems containing a large number of particles, and many characteristic properties of macroscopic systems only appear in the thermodynamic limit Sheehan and Gross 2006 ; Kuzemsky 2014 , such as phases and critical points. For an ideal gas with N particles considered in this work, the thermodynamic limit is specified by N\gg 1 , but with the particle number density \rho=N/V, (1) held fixed. Discussion of this thermodynamic limit is minimal in most undergraduate courses. a a a For a few paradoxes that emerge without proper treatment of the thermodynamic limit, see Ref. Styer 2004 . The equivalence between ensembles is another aspect of the thermodynamic limit which is often omitted, but is lucidly demonstrated for the microcanonical and canoncical ensembles in Ref. Gurarie 2007 . However, as the thermodynamic limit can only be an approximation to nature, it is useful to consider the size of corrections when the system varies from this limit. The thermodynamic limit is well established for classical ideal gases in containers with inert walls and is a staple topic in statistical mechanics courses. Without particle-particle interactions in the gas, however, particles-wall interactions are required to achieve thermal equilibrium. These interactions ensure that information about the initial preparation of the gas is washed out. After thermal equilibrium is attained, particle-wall correlations have a negligible effect on the gas, which is a feature characteristic of the thermodynamic limit. The leading correction to the thermodynamic limit of a classical ideal gas can be gleaned qualitatively as follows. At equilibrium, the average number of particles interacting with the walls is proportional to the area of the container. For a gas of N particles contained in a volume V , the area is proportional to V^{2/3}\propto N^{2/3} . The energy of the gas has two contributions: the kinetic energy of the gas particles and the particle-wall interaction energy. The former is additive, that is, \propto N , due to the absence of particle-particle interactions, while the latter depends on the average surface density of particles near the walls, \propto N^{2/3} . The ratio of these effects is proportional to N^{-1/3} and therefore vanishes as N\to\infty , resulting in thermodynamic quantities that are extensive to a good approximation. b b b For a discussion of finite size corrections to the free energy, see, for instance, Ref. Hill 2013 . For a gas of 10^{23} particles, extensivity is realized at better than one part in ten million. The focus of the present work is to make the above argument concrete, at least in the context of static potential models, and thereby to sharpen student understanding of the thermodynamic limit. c c c Another illuminating way to explore the approach to the thermodynamic limit is through numerical experiments, for example, see Refs. Boozer 2010 ; Price and Swendsen 2013 ; Mulhall and Moelter 2014 . Particle-wall correlations are straightforwardly accounted for through interactions within the canonical ensemble, and can thus readily be addressed in undergraduate and graduate statistical mechanics courses. In Sec. II , we begin with generalities concerning the classical ideal gas partition function in a cubic volume and contributions from the surface density of gas particles. Simple models for particle-wall interactions are taken up in Sec. III . First, we use a simple interaction in a fully classical description of the gas. The leading effect of the interaction on the distribution of energy within the canonical ensemble is investigated, and it matches the scaling with N obtained from the qualitative argument above. Next, we use a quantum mechanical description of the gas. Enforcing Dirichlet boundary conditions on the single-particle wavefunctions provides a rudimentary particle-wall interaction of very short range. Nonetheless, the same qualitative features of the approach to the thermodynamic limit are observed. At the end, Sec. IV , we provide several suggestions for further investigations. Some of these can be adapted for problem sets, while others are suited as options for end-of-term projects. II Confining a Classical Ideal Gas For a system of fixed volume and with a fixed number of particles, the canonical ensemble characterizes its thermal equilibrium with a reservoir of heat. When the system is a classical gas of N non-interacting particles, its canonical partition function {\mathcal{Z}} has the form {\mathcal{Z}}=\frac{\,\,Z^{N}}{N!}, (2) where Z is the single-particle partition function, which can be written as a phase-space integral as follows: Z=\int\frac{d^{3}p\,d^{3}r}{(2{\pi}\hbar)^{3}}\,e^{-{\beta}\,H(\vec{p},\vec{r})}, (3) where H is the classical Hamiltonian governing a particle of the gas interacting with a confining potential, and the parameter {\beta}=(k_{B}T)^{-1} is proportional to the inverse temperature of the reservoir. Included in the partition function is the Maxwell-Boltzmann factor N! , which accounts for the classical statistics of identical particles and is required so that intensive thermodynamic quantities possess a finite thermodynamic limit. Additionally included is the factor (2{\pi}\hbar)^{3} , which can be thought of as an elementary volume of points in phase-space; it renders the partition function dimensionless. Quantum mechanics allows 2{\pi}\hbar to be identified with Planck’s constant, but this is irrelevant in classical statistical mechanics. Throughout, the gas is confined in a cubical container of volume V=L^{3} . For an ideal gas, the functional form of Z depends on the potential, encoded through the classical Hamiltonian, that confines the particles within the container. For simplicity, we assume that the confining potential respects the cubic symmetry of the volume. Due to this assumption, the single-particle partition function is the product of one-dimensional partition functions as follows: Z=\left(Z_{1}\right)^{3}. (4) With the further assumption of momentum-independent particle-wall interactions, the one-dimensional partition function itself factorizes into the product of a momentum contribution P_{1} and a coordinate contribution Q_{1} , Z_{1}=P_{1}\,Q_{1}\,. (5) The momentum contribution is defined to be P_{1}=\int_{-\infty}^{+\infty}\frac{dp}{2{\pi}\hbar}\,e^{-{\beta}\frac{p^{2}}{2m}}=\frac{1}{{\lambda}_{T}}, (6) where m is the mass of a gas particle; and, by virtue of the \hbar , the inverse of the thermal de Broglie wavelength, defined below, appears, {\lambda}_{T}=\hbar\,\sqrt{\frac{2{\pi}}{m\,k_{B}T}}\,. (7) The coordinate contribution takes the form Q_{1}=\int_{-\infty}^{+\infty}e^{-{\beta}\,V(x)}\,dx, (8) where V(x) is the one-dimensional particle-wall potential. The factorization in Eq. ( 5 ) expresses the statistical independence of the momentum and position of the particle, which is a feature of classical statistical mechanics — in particular the assumption that the interaction with the wall is independent of the particle’s momentum. In the typical treatment of the gas, a particle is confined through the potential V_{c}(x)=\begin{cases}0,&0<x<L\\ +\infty,&\text{otherwise}\end{cases}\quad, (9) for which the coordinate contribution Q_{1} is simply L . The infinite height of the potential is necessary to confine the particle; however, the infinitely abrupt rise at each wall is rather unphysical. For a realistic potential, d d d For a treatment of confinement parameterized

Read the complete text