Quantum Relative Entropy implies the Semiclassical Einstein Equations
Philipp Dorau, Albert Much · 2025
Read Quantum Relative Entropy implies the Semiclassical Einstein Equations by Philipp Dorau, Albert Much (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-24491.txt.
Introduction
Philipp Dorau and Albert Much argue that the semiclassical Einstein equations follow from quantum relative entropy on a horizon. Using modular theory, they show the relative entropy between the vacuum and coherent excitations of a scalar field on a bifurcate Killing horizon equals the energy flux across the horizon. The Bekenstein-Hawking formula then ties that flux to a change in horizon area.
From this identification, the semiclassical Einstein equations follow automatically. The approach generalizes Jacobson's thermodynamic derivation of gravity to a quantum field theoretic setting. It supports the view that spacetime dynamics can emerge from entropy and information principles near horizons.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Philipp Dorau, Albert Much |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 23 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-24491
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Quantum Relative Entropy implies the Semiclassical Einstein Equations Preprint: APS/123-QED Philipp Dorau, Albert Much Abstract We prove that the semiclassical Einstein equations emerge directly from quantum information theory. Using modular theory, we establish that the relative entropy between the vacuum state and coherent excitations of a scalar quantum field on a bifurcate Killing horizon is given by the energy flux across the horizon. Under the assumption of the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy-area formula, this energy flux is proportional to a variation in the surface area of the horizon cross section. The semiclassical Einstein equations follow automatically from this identification. Our approach provides a rigorous quantum field theoretic generalization of Jacobson’s thermodynamic derivation of Einstein’s equations, replacing classical thermodynamic entropy with the well-defined quantum relative (Araki-Uhlmann) entropy. This suggests that quantum information plays a fundamental role in what is seen as a zeroth order approximation of a theory of quantum gravity, namely quantum field theory in curved spacetimes. Introduction. Jacobson demonstrated in Ref. Jacobson 1995 that Einstein’s equations can be derived from the thermodynamic relation \delta Q=T\delta S applied to local Rindler horizons, where the heat flux through the horizon is connected to the entropy change, itself proportional via the Bekenstein-Hawking formula to the variation of the horizon area. This raises the question: Is there an analogous derivation within quantum field theory? Seeking a quantum field theoretic version of the Bekenstein bound, classically derived from the black hole area law, Casini Casini 2008 was led to relative entropy as the natural entropic quantity in this context. Furthermore, the von Neumann entropy is ill-defined in quantum field theory due to ultraviolet divergences arising from the type \mathrm{III} structure of local von Neumann algebras, which is a manifestation of vacuum fluctuations. In comparison, a finite and well-defined entropic quantity in QFT is the relative (Araki-Uhlmann) entropy Araki 1976 ; Uhlmann 1977 , naturally formulated within modular theory Takesaki 1970 , which quantifies the distinguishability of quantum states and occupies a central role within the framework of quantum information theory, see Longo 2019 ; Hollands 2020 ; Hollands and Ishibashi 2019 ; Casini et al. 2019 . To establish a quantum field theoretic version of Jacobson’s argument, we follow Casini’s approach and employ the relative entropy, given its previously discussed properties. For quantum fields in spacetimes with bifurcate Killing horizons, such as Rindler, Schwarzschild (in its maximal extension), and Kerr-Newman geometries, the relative entropy is explicitly computable and is directly related to the expectation value of the field’s energy momentum tensor Casini et al. 2019 ; Kay and Wald 1991 ; Summers and Verch 1996 ; Kurpicz et al. 2021 . Our strategy is as follows. Invoking the equivalence principle, we approximate any sufficiently small spacetime region by Minkowski space and consider a uniformly accelerated observer associated with a local Rindler horizon. In this bifurcate Killing horizon setting we compute the relative entropy between the vacuum and a coherent excitation of a Klein-Gordon field. The resulting expression is given in terms of the expectation value of the field’s energy momentum tensor, which is directly related to the energy flux across the horizon. Following the reasoning of Ref. Jacobson 1995 , the relative entropy is therefore proportional to the variation of the horizon cross-sectional area. From this, the semiclassical Einstein equations are recovered. Local Spacetime Geometry. Consider a spacetime manifold \mathcal{M} , together with a sufficiently small neighborhood \mathcal{U}\subset\mathcal{M} around some point p\in\mathcal{M} such that its causal completion \overline{\mathcal{U}}^{\diamond} is globally hyperbolic, and, following the equivalence principle Wald 1984 , the spacetime metric g_{ab} restricted to \mathcal{U} is well-approximated by that of a local inertial frame, i.e., g_{ab}\big|_{\mathcal{U}}\approx\eta_{ab} (1) where \eta_{ab} denotes the flat Minkowski metric. Figure 1: Sketch of the local region \mathcal{U}\subset\mathcal{M} endowed with a local Rindler horizon, consisting of the null hypersurfaces \mathcal{H}_{A} and \mathcal{H}_{B} intersecting at the horizon cross section \mathcal{S} . \mathcal{H}_{A} is affinely parametrized by V , and likewise \mathcal{H}_{B} by U , yielding a local double null coordinate system on \mathcal{U} . Consequently, the region \mathcal{U} is separated into two wedge-shaped regions, correspondingly decomposing \mathcal{H}_{A},\mathcal{H}_{B} into \mathcal{H}_{A}^{\mathcal{R}},\mathcal{H}_{A}^{\mathcal{L}} and \mathcal{H}_{B}^{\mathcal{L}},\mathcal{H}_{B}^{\mathcal{R}} , respectively. The purple curves indicate the flow generated by the local Killing vector field \xi^{a} , which becomes null on \mathcal{H}_{A} and \mathcal{H}_{B} . In this locally flat region, the generating vector field \xi^{a} of Lorentz boosts constitutes an approximate Killing vector field on \mathcal{U} . Moreover, \xi^{a} becomes null on two null hypersurfaces \mathcal{H}_{A} and \mathcal{H}_{B} , to which it is both tangent and normal, and which intersect on a spacelike 2 –surface \mathcal{S} , as illustrated in Fig. 1 . Hence, the region \mathcal{U} possesses a local Rindler horizon, which is a special case of a (local) bifurcate Killing horizon, see Kay and Wald 1991 ; Summers and Verch 1996 . Algebraic QFT and Relative Entropy. Next, we turn to the corresponding algebraic formulation of a local quantum field theory. Consider a real, minimally coupled scalar field \Phi of mass m on a globally hyperbolic spacetime region (\overline{\mathcal{U}}^{\diamond},g) satisfying the Klein-Gordon equation \left(\square_{g}+m^{2}\right)\Phi=0. (2) Algebraic quantization of \Phi then gives rise to the CCR-algebra \mathscr{C} of scalar field operators, see, e.g., Fewster and Rejzner 2020 . Let \tau^{t} denote the flow generated by the Killing vector field \xi^{a} , and let \omega_{0} be a quasifree \tau^{t} -invariant Hadamard state on \mathscr{C} . This class of states forms the natural curved spacetime generalization of the Minkowski vacuum Kay and Wald 1991 . In the specific case of a Rindler horizon in flat spacetime, the relevant \tau^{t} -invariant state is indeed the Minkowski vacuum itself, i.e., the unique Poincaré-invariant Hadamard state, see Haag 1996 . Kay and Wald derived in Ref. Kay and Wald 1991 that the restriction of any such \omega_{0} to the Killing horizon \mathcal{H}_{B} associated to \xi^{a} possesses the universal scaling-limit two-point function \Lambda(\phi,\psi)=-\frac{1}{\pi}\int\frac{\phi(U,s)\,\psi(U^{\prime},s)}{(U-U^{\prime}-i0^{+})^{2}}\,dU\,dU^{\prime}\,d\mathrm{vol}_{\mathcal{S}}, (3) see also Haag et al. 1984 , where \phi,\psi\in C_{c}^{\infty}(\mathcal{H}_{B}) are compactly supported solutions of ( 2 ) restricted to the horizon \mathcal{H}_{B} , U denotes a null coordinate affinely parametrizing \mathcal{H}_{B} , as before, and s denotes coordinates on the bifurcation surface \mathcal{S} . In particular, this two-point function satisfies the KMS condition at inverse temperature \beta=\tfrac{2\pi}{\kappa} with respect to the projected Killing flow \left.\tau^{t}\right|_{\mathcal{H}} Kay and Wald 1991 , thereby recovering the Hawking and, in the Rindler case, the Unruh temperature. Note that, in contrast to stationary black holes, the boost Killing field generating a Rindler horizon has no unique normalization, since any rescaling changes the proper acceleration a of the corresponding uniformly accelerated observers and thereby the surface gravity \kappa of the associated horizon. Building on these results, Summers and Verch Summers and Verch 1996 reformulated the thermal properties of QFT on bifurcate Killing horizons in a purely operator algebraic language, using Tomita-Takesaki modular theory, see Takesaki 1970 ; Borchers 2000 . Let \mathscr{A}_{\mathcal{R}} denote the von Neumann algebra of observables localized in the right wedge of a bifurcate Killing horizon, see Fig. 1 , and let \omega_{0} be a KMS state on \mathscr{A}_{\mathcal{R}} with respect to the Killing flow \tau^{t} . Then, there exists a subalgebra \mathscr{N}_{\mathcal{R}}\subset\mathscr{A}_{\mathcal{R}} , localized on the horizon portion \mathcal{H}_{B}^{\mathcal{R}} , such that the restricted state \left.\omega_{0}\right|_{\mathscr{N}_{\mathcal{R}}} is a KMS state for the projected