Skyrmion-vortex pairing from duality

Shantonu Mukherjee · 2025

Read Skyrmion-vortex pairing from duality by Shantonu Mukherjee (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-24404.txt.

Introduction

Shantonu Mukherjee proposes a pairing between skyrmions and vortices in a two dimensional ferromagnetic superconductor, working alone. He formulates an interaction between ferromagnetic and superconducting orders that obeys the needed symmetry principles. This allows a duality similar to boson vortex duality in superfluids, where the two topological excitations interact through an emergent gauge field.

The static potential attracts a skyrmion and a vortex of opposite topological charge, so bound pairs can form. Mukherjee further argues that such pairing makes a Magnus force on the vortex induce a transverse, Hall like drift of the skyrmion. The theory predicts a coupled motion that experiments on ferromagnetic superconductors could test.

Catalog record

CREATORShantonu Mukherjee
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE22 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-24404

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Skyrmion-vortex pairing from duality Shantonu Mukherjee Abstract An interaction between ferromagnetic and superconducting order, to be realized in a 2d ferromagnetic superconductor, is proposed obeying necessary symmetry principles. This interaction allow us to formulate a duality, similar to the Boson-vortex duality in 2+1 dimensional superfluid. In the dual theory Skyrmion and vortex excitations interact with each other via an emergent gauge field. The static interaction potential is attractive for a Skyrmion and a vortex with opposite topological charges. This interaction can lead to formation of bound pairs of the mentioned topological excitations. I Introduction The coexistence of ferromagnetism and superconductivity, though seemingly counterintuitive, has been experimentally realized in various material systems owing to recent advances in experimental techniques Oner et al. 2020 ; Jin et al. 2006 ; Kakani and Upadhyaya 1987 ; Zhu et al. 2016 . This coexistence phase provides a fertile ground for exploring rich physical phenomena emerging from the interplay between topological excitations such as superconducting vortices and magnetic Skyrmions. Among the most intriguing directions of current research is the realization of hybrid or composite topological entities formed by the coupling of superconducting vortices and magnetic Skyrmions at superconductor–ferromagnet interfaces Baumard et al. 2019 ; Dahir et al. 2019 ; Hals et al. 2016 ; Andriyakhina and Burmistrov 2021 ; Dahir et al. 2020 ; Petrović et al. 2021 as well as within ferromagnetic superconducting bulks Mukherjee and Lahiri 2025 . In these studies, the internal structure of the composite objects and their mutual interactions have been analyzed through collective field descriptions, often by solving the corresponding Euler-Lagrange equations. While that approach captures the microscopic details faithfully, it often obscures an intuitive understanding of the effective macroscopic dynamics of these collective excitations. To gain such physical intuition, it is convenient to adopt an effective point-particle like description of these mesoscopic topological entities. In this framework, the dynamics of each composite object can be tracked via the motion of its center, enabling one to employ the language of classical particle mechanics. This description allows a natural characterization of local interactions between these emergent particles. One systematic way to construct such an effective point-particle description is through duality transformations that map collective field configurations to particle degrees of freedom with emergent local interactions. A well-known example of this correspondence is the particle-vortex duality in (2+1)-dimensional field theories Peskin 1978 ; Dasgupta and Halperin 1981 . This duality plays a central role in the Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless (BKT) transition Kosterlitz and Thouless 1973 and is typically discussed in the context of the planar X–Y model–an effective low-energy description for two-dimensional superfluids or spin systems Savit 1980 . The particle-vortex duality maps vortex excitations into point particles interacting via an effective logarithmic potential. Such interactions lead to bound vortex-antivortex pairs forming a confined phase, while the BKT transition describes a transition to a deconfined phase in which isolated vortices emerge. Moreover, in the dual formulation, the vortex dynamics is characterized in terms of the motion of its core, which provides a powerful tool to study vortex motion and response under external perturbations such as electromagnetic fields. Constructing an analogous duality in the present context would yield an equally powerful framework for analyzing the dynamics of Skyrmion-vortex bound states . In this work, we begin with a theoretical model akin to that introduced in a preceding study Mukherjee and Lahiri 2025 . The model consists of a nonlinear sigma model coupled to the Landau–Ginzburg theory of superconductivity through a spin–magnetic-field interaction (SMFI) term, augmented by an additional direct coupling term (discussed in Section III ). The inclusion of this direct coupling term is pivotal for formulating a dual theory. As will be demonstrated, the dual formulation features an emergent gauge field mediating the interaction between Skyrmion and vortex excitations. Depending on the field configuration, this interaction can be attractive for Skyrmion-antivortex or anti-Skyrmion-vortex pairs, leading to the formation of bound states. Notably, this direct coupling, essential for realizing the dual mapping, has not been explored previously in the context of magnetic systems to our knowledge, making the duality developed here novel. (For comparison, see Lee and Kane 1990 for an analogous duality in fermionic systems.) The dual theory provides a natural framework to study the coupled dynamics of Skyrmion-vortex bound states via coupled Thiele-type equations and offers a theoretical avenue to explore BKT-like unbinding transitions of these composite excitations–an exciting new direction in the field. II Revisiting the CP 1 representation of spin system Two component complex spinors form a 2d complex ( \mathbb{C} ) Hilbert space. However, for any given state \ket{\psi} there will be states \ket{\psi^\prime}=\lambda\ket{\psi} which will differ by a complex phase factor. These states form a equivalent class of states. Thus the Hilbert space is a collection of such equivalent classes or rays . The space formed by these physical states or rays is called a projective Hilbert space or \mathbb{C}P^{1} (Quotient space (\mathbb{C}^{2}\setminus\{0\})/\mathbb{C}^{*} ). For Normalized spinors |z|^{2}=1 , the \mathbb{C}P^{1} space become the Bloch sphere. This is because |z|^{2}=1 defines a 3-sphere, while the space of equivalent states connected by U(1) transformations forms a circle leading to a quotient space S^{3}/U(1) which is topologically equivalent to S^{2} . Thus space of normalized 2d rays forms a 2-sphere known as Bloch sphere. The fluctuation in a spin system is expressed in terms of the normalized spin vector \hat{n} . The spin states expressed by these vectors lie on a 2-sphere which is again the Bloch sphere. This induces a map between normalized spin vector \hat{n} and \mathbb{C}P^{1} spinor expressed by the following relation \hat{n}=z^{\dagger}\bm{\sigma}z,\,\,\,\,z^{\dagger}z=1. (1) The 2d spinor z can be chosen as z=\begin{pmatrix}\cos(\theta/2)\\ e^{i\phi}sin(\theta/2)\end{pmatrix} (2) Let us now see how various terms in the action of an ferromagnetic system changes in this new representation. We first write down the general action for the unit spin field for such systems S_{FM}=\int d^{3}x\left(\bm{\mathcal{A}}(\hat{n})\cdot\partial_{t}\hat{n}-\frac{\rho_{M}}{2}\left(\mathbf{\gradient}n^{i}\right)^{2}-\mu n^{i}\varepsilon^{ijk}\partial^{j}A^{k}\right) (3) Here the first term is the geometric phase that a dynamical spin gains while tracing a path in spin space. This term arises in the following way \displaystyle L=i\bra{\hat{n}}\partial_{t}\ket{\hat{n}}-H=i\bra{\hat{n}}\partial_{n^{i}}\ket{\hat{n}}\frac{\partial n^{i}}{\partial t}-H (4) One can recognize that the first term in the second line of Eq ( 4 ) to be the berry connection \bm{\mathcal{A}}=i\bra{\hat{n}}\gradient_{\hat{n}}\ket{\hat{n}} . Presence of this geometric phase in a dynamical spin action can be rigorously derived using spin coherent states Han 2017 . It can be readily verified that in the new \mathbb{C}P^{1} representation this geometric phase term takes the following form \bm{\mathcal{A}}\cdot\partial_{t}\hat{n}=i\bra{\hat{n}}\gradient_{\hat{n}}\ket{\hat{n}}\cdot\partial_{t}\hat{n}=S(\cos\theta-1)\dot{\phi}=iz^{\dagger}\partial_{t}z, (5) where in the second line we have obtained the expression using spin coherent states for \ket{\hat{n}} Han 2017 . Now we take a look at the second term of Eq ( 3 ). This term is called a non-linear sigma term which captures the fluctuation of the spin field \hat{n} . The constant \rho_{M} is the spin stiffness which determine the energy cost for spin variation . In the new \mathbb{C}P^{1} representation this term will have the following form \frac{\rho_{M}}{2}\left(\mathbf{\gradient}n^{i}\right)^{2}=2\rho_{M}\left((\gradient z^{\dagger})\cdot(\gradient z)-(z^{\dagger}\gradient z)\cdot(\gradient z^{\dagger}z)\right), (6) where we have used the identity \sigma^{i}_{ab}\sigma^{i}_{\alpha\beta}=2\delta_{a\beta}\delta_{b\alpha}-\delta_{ab}\delta_{\alpha\beta} and z^{\dagger}z=1 . The term z^{\dagger}\gradient z or more generally a_{\mu}=-iz^{\dagger}\partial_{\mu}z behaves as a gauge field under the transformation z\rightarrow e^{i\chi}z : z\rightarrow e^{i\chi}z,\quad a_{\mu}\rightarrow a_{\mu}+\partial_{\mu}\chi. (7) Due to this gauge degree of freedom the

Read the complete text