Implicit quantile preferences of the Fed and the Taylor rule

Gabriel Montes-Rojas, Fernando Toledo, Nicolás Bertholet, Kevin Corfield · 2025

Read Implicit quantile preferences of the Fed and the Taylor rule by Gabriel Montes-Rojas, Fernando Toledo, Nicolás Bertholet, Kevin Corfield (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-24362.txt.

Introduction

Gabriel Montes-Rojas and three co-authors study monetary policy when a central bank cares about a quantile of outcomes rather than the average. In their framework, the bank's risk attitude is set by a quantile index, giving a clear map between hawkish or dovish stances and attention to bad outcomes. They set up the infinite horizon problem with a Bellman equation using a quantile operator.

From an Euler equation approach, they derive Taylor rule style reaction functions for interest rates. Using indirect inference, they estimate the implicit quantile index that reveals the Federal Reserve's risk aversion. The empirical plan for the United States uses reduced form dynamics with changing volatility.

Catalog record

CREATORGabriel Montes-Rojas, Fernando Toledo, Nicolás Bertholet, Kevin Corfield
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE59 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-24362

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Implicit quantile preferences of the Fed and the Taylor rule Gabriel Montes-Rojas, Fernando Toledo, Nicolás Bertholet, Kevin Corfield Abstract We study optimal monetary policy when a central bank maximizes a quantile utility objective rather than expected utility. In our framework, the central bank’s risk attitude is indexed by the quantile index level, providing a transparent mapping between hawkish/dovish stances and attention to adverse macroeconomic realizations. We formulate the infinite-horizon problem using a Bellman equation with the quantile operator. Implementing an Euler-equation approach, we get Taylor-rule-type reaction functions. Using an indirect inference approach, we derive a central bank risk aversion implicit quantile index. An empirical implementation for the US is outlined based on reduced-form laws of motion with conditional heteroskedasticity, enabling estimation of the new monetary policy rule and its dependence on the Fed risk attitudes. The results reveal that the Fed has mostly a dovish-type behavior but with some periods of hawkish attitudes. Keywords: Taylor rule; inflation; output gap; quantile preferences; dynamic programming; recursive model. JEL: C22; C61; E52; E58. 1 Introduction The debate between hawkish and dovish monetary policy authorities has received increased attention (see Tobback, Nardelli, and Martens 2017 , Hack, Istrefi, and Meier 2025 ). For example, the London Investment Service Company In Touch Capital Markets has introduced a relative scale to explain the position of Fed’s regarding their relative aversion to inflationary pressures: the lowest bound on the scale indicates very hawkish members and the upper bound specifies very dovish ones. In the empirical literature, CBs are often classified as hawkish or dovish based on projected Taylor rules, particularly the interest rate’s long-term response to inflation (see Castro 2011 ; Wilson 2020 ; Malmendier, Nagel, and Yan 2021 ; González-Astudillo and Tanvir 2023 ). The responses of monetary authorities to the post-pandemic period and the Ukraine war are paramount to understand coordinated monetary policy actions in terms of interest rate hikes to recent global inflation synchronization ( Ha, Kose, Ohnsorge, and Yilmazkuday 2024 ). Although this empirical regularity, the intensity of restrictive monetary policy measures differs among countries. This stylized fact reminds us how important it is for CBs to find an optimal policy monetary rule that reflects the distinct degree of risk aversion to inflation and economic fluctuations. For example, the Fed’s approach was shaped by empirical evidence that gathered in the years before the pandemic, and the results were impacted by a decrease in inflation persistence, a flattening of the Phillips curve’s slope, and inaccurate assessments of real-time output or unemployment ( Sargent and Williams 2025 ). Taylor rules have become a cornerstone of modern monetary policy science ( Woodford 2003 , Taylor 1993 ). Optimal monetary policy involves setting short-term nominal interest rates to stabilize the economy by managing inflation and output gaps, often guided by rules that recommend increasing rates when inflation is high or output exceeds its potential and lowering them otherwise ( Clarida, Galí, and Gertler 1999 ). Although Taylor rules provide a simple and robust framework, true optimal policy depends on specific economic models, policy objectives, and whether policymakers prioritize inflation, output, or a combination of both, leading to ongoing debates and refinements of such rules. In that regard, during the last Jackson Hole Symposium (August 2025, 21-23), Nakamura, Riblier, and Steinsson 2025 presented a study that remarks the descriptive nature of Taylor rules instead of their prescriptive one. These authors have also observed deviations from the Taylor principle after exploring the recent Fed’s behavior and also pointed out the coexistence of early and late policy interest rate hikers. In the case of New Keynesian macroeconomic models, the discussion about the theoretical validity of optimal Taylor rules usually includes these and other relevant issues (see Boehm and House 2014 ). The main point we would like to state here is the discontent that some contributions express in terms of the theoretical form of optimal Taylor rules (see Cochrane 2007 , Benhabib, Schmitt-Grohé, and Uribe 2001 ). Theoretical contributions have usually approached the different preferences toward the traditional monetary policy trade-off (inflation versus output fluctuations) by deriving an optimally monetary policy Taylor rule minimizing a quadratic loss intertemporal function ( Woodford 2003 ). However, problems arise in applying these functions when the underlying economic model is nonlinear ( Benigno and Eggertsson 2023 ), shocks are non-normal ( Hofmann, Manea, and Mojon 2024 ), or the quadratic assumption is too simplistic ( al Nowaihi and Stracca 2002 ). Furthermore, although linear-quadratic models offer analytical tractability for deriving optimal rules, they may fail to capture key asymmetric preferences that drive actual monetary policy behavior in the real world ( Svensson 2003 ) 1 1 1 El-Shagi 2025 has recently shown that the Fed prioritizes business cycle stabilization over containing inflation. . So, traditional methods often look at the average policy reaction function of a CB. After the 2008 global financial crisis, many authors argued that CBs should pay more attention to tail risks (especially downside risks) rather than just average outcomes (see Demirguc-Kunt, Detragiache, and Merrouche 2013 ). For instance, regardless of the US economy’s condition, Barci 2025 notes that monetary policy can increase downside risk; nevertheless, this ability is significantly diminished during economic expansions. Such disparity, if not appropriately taken into consideration, could cause monetary authorities to be too cautious when it comes to tightening during booms. In the present paper, our theoretical contribution is to introduce quantile utility (QU) preferences into the intertemporal minimization of the loss function of CBs. As far as we know, this contribution is completely new. We add to the literature on quantile preferences applications a new analytical framework to analyze how CBs minimize their intertemporal loss function using dynamic programming through the Bellman equation solution as in de Castro and Galvao 2019 . In contrast to the usual framework of minimizing a quadratic intertemporal loss function using expected utility to attain the optimal policy Taylor rule, we incorporate QU preferences to study how CBs respond to undesirable macroeconomic outcomes. It is worth noting that our analytical framework assumes full credibility of the policymaker’s announcements (see Woodford 2003 ). Our research adds new arguments to the theoretical discussion about the accurate form of the optimal Taylor rule. We depart from the conventional dynamic optimization problem faced by CBs to propose a new closed analytical form for their reaction function. The main advantage of the new Taylor rule is that CBs are concerned not only with average inflation-output trade-off but also in analyzing scenarios of inflation and output gaps. Moreover, by comparing the observed policy actions (i.e. interest rate) with the entire myriad of available actions for all quantiles, we can infer the type of the CB at each point in time. We define this the implicit quantile preference index, which is a dynamic index of the CB risk aversion. In turn, we intepret this index as a dovish/hawkish scale. We use US quarterly long-run data from 1954-Q4 to 2025-Q2. This framework suggests that the Fed often appear more dovish than simple Taylor rules would suggest and they may be intrinsically less concerned with downside risks (unemployment spikes, financial instability). However, this is not a general description, and there are specific periods where the Fed is characterized

Read the complete text