Cosmology and philosophy

Daniel Parrochia · 2025

Read Cosmology and philosophy by Daniel Parrochia (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-24296.txt.

Introduction

Daniel Parrochia examines the meeting of cosmology and philosophy, working alone. Scientific cosmology now has a standard model of an expanding universe, but big questions remain open. Did the expansion begin in a singularity that marks an absolute start, or is our universe one among many, spread across space or time?

Parrochia also revisits the old theological point, held since Thomas Aquinas, that a beginning is not the same as creation. After a brief history of recent scientific cosmology, the article weighs these options and clarifies what science can and cannot settle about the origin of the universe.

Catalog record

CREATORDaniel Parrochia
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE101 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-24296

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Cosmology and philosophy Daniel Parrochia Abstract Figure 1: Black cloud Barnard 68 (ESO) Abstract. Scientific cosmology has now reached its period of maturity with the establishment of a standard model, which is the theory of an expanding universe. The question of whether this expansion resolves itself, in the past, into a singularity identifiable with an absolute beginning, or whether the universe in which we are is only one of the multiple possible universes existing either in space or in time, is still under debate. Moreover, the assimilation of the beginning of the universe to a "creation" has often been contested by theology, which, since Thomas Aquinas, if not since the Fathers of the Church, tends to carefully distinguish the two. In the following article, after briefly summarizing some points in the recent history of scientific cosmology, we will attempt to present in broad outline the standard model that scientists have arrived at. Then, we will undertake to study some of the problems it raises as well as the alternative theories that can be opposed to it. Finally, we will discuss the problematic links that scientific cosmology continues to maintain with philosophy and theology, notably the thorny question of creation from nothing ( creatio ex nihilo ). Key words. Cosmology, standard model, initial singularity, cyclical universe, Hawking, Penrose, creatio ex nihilo. 1 The Contribution of Scientific Cosmology While classical Newtonian physics, derived from Galileo, did not, strictly speaking, have a cosmology -- in the sense that it did not imply, in its equations, any particular consequences for the shape of the world or its mathematical-mechanical representation (other than an infinite and eternal space) -- the physics derived from the theory of general relativity 1 1 1 General relativity, as a theory of gravitation, remained, until recent years, one of the very solid foundations of cosmology. While, on small scales, it has long been questioned – due to its fundamental incompatibility with quantum mechanics – it was nevertheless considered, until recently, a good description of the Universe on a large scale. Only recently has a 1% attenuation of gravity been demonstrated at the cosmological ”super-horizon,” that is, at scales much larger than the current Hubble radius. If this were true, it would require a slight modification of Einstein’s theory for these scales, probably involving cold dark matter \Lambda ; this ”codicil” does not, for the moment, lead to an overhaul (see [ Wen et al. 24 ] ). – Einstein’s theory led, quite naturally, to cosmologies that were often finitist, thus reconnecting with pre-Socratic speculations or mythological concerns in general. However, unlike the latter, it developed on the basis of essentially mathematical and physical considerations, and according to the usual scientific methodology, namely that any theoretical construction must be validated or refuted by observations. The notion of "universe" has, as a result, become much more refined. In cosmology, we speak of a very particular universe, a universe that is directly or indirectly "observable," and therefore subject to scientific, theoretical, and experimental investigation. In the first half of the 20th century, however, the possibility of thinking about the universe as a whole was still contested by certain epistemologists such as G. Bachelard (see [ Bachelard 72 ] and our comments in [ Barrau-Parrochia 10 ] , 235-247), probably due to excessive uncertainty about the possible models of the universe, which were quite numerous at the time, and at a time when no consensus had yet emerged in favor of the expansion theory. But progress in the adjustment of theories and data has been such that it is no longer possible today to dispute the relevance of this bold transgression, which consisted of scientifically considering the universe as a whole. 1.1 From Pioneers of Expansion to Inflation Theory Scientific cosmology developed in the 20th century through a series of theories, which Jacques Merleau-Ponty (see [ Merleau-Ponty 65 ] ) surveyed up until the 1960s. However, it owed its emergence, as he wrote, essentially to the conjunction of a genius physicist (Einstein) and a gigantic telescope (the 2.5-meter aperture telescope on Mount Wilson), which enabled Hubble, an astronomer "in his own right," to derive his famous law of recession of galaxies V=H_{0}D , which showed that their speed of receding was proportional to their distance. The law, difficult to establish in 1929, is currently well verified (see Fig. 2). The only remaining problem – but it may have significant consequences in the long term – is the question of evaluating the Hubble constant H_{0} . Estimates based on standard candle methods (Cepheid stars, etc.) are concentrated around 73 or 74 km/s/Mpc. In contrast, values derived from observations of the cosmic microwave background using the Lambda CDM model seem to agree more closely around 67 km/s/Mpc. The difference exceeds the margins of error by about 6 sigma. Figure 2: Hubble’s law in 1929 (a) and in 1996 (b) The study of the universe as a whole was therefore able to develop on this basis, and initially as a typically relativistic cosmology, in the wake of Einstein and De Sitter. Friedman and Lemaître (see the collection of their main articles introduced by J.-P. Luminet ( [ Friedman-Lemaìtre 97 ] ) were the first to find non-static solutions to the equations of General Relativity, while Robertson interpreted the Doppler effect in terms of distance. Then the English school made major contributions with Gamow, Eddington, Hoyle, sometimes including philosophical considerations (as with Tolman, Milne or Whitrow). Specific variants were then explored (theory of large numbers of Eddington, Dirac or Jordan, rotating universe of Gödel, non-homogeneous isotropic models or lattice universe of Lindquist and Wheeler). The great opposition of the time was between the theories of an expanding universe and the so-called stationary state theories defended by Sciama and Hoyle, more skeptical about the interpretation of the redshift of the spectra of distant galaxies, and less inclined to admit without discussion Hubble’s law, the data still remaining quite limited. Gamow and his colleagues – even though they did not initially believe in the "Big Bang" theory – were soon to confirm it. By interpreting the formation of the Universe in the Hebrew fashion, that is, not as a "creatio ex nihilo" but as a creation from a prior matter, they showed that the assumption of an initial mixture called Ylem made it possible to account for the formation of the nuclei of the lightest elements (deuterium, helium and lithium) during the first three minutes of the universe, at a time when the temperature was around 10 billion degrees. They also predicted that once the Universe had cooled, it must have become transparent, and Alpher and Hermann calculated that an echo of the Big Bang in the form of blackbody radiation should now be found at a temperature of around 5 K. This background radiation, which Penzias and Wilson discovered by chance in 1956 while listening to the first Russian Sputnik using a large antenna, was interpreted by Peebles, Roll, and Wilkinson in 1965 as being precisely the residue predicted by Gamow and his colleagues. From both observational and theoretical physical data, a completely precise model of the universe gradually emerged, whose predictions now correspond perfectly with experimental data, particularly satellite

Read the complete text