Equivalence of Discrete and Continuous Otto-Like Engines assisted by Catalysts: Mapping Catalytic Advantages from the Discrete to the Continuous Framework
Marcin Łobejko, Tanmoy Biswas, Michał Horodecki · 2025
Read Equivalence of Discrete and Continuous Otto-Like Engines assisted by Catalysts: Mapping Catalytic Advantages from the Discrete to the Continuous Framework by Marcin Łobejko, Tanmoy Biswas, Michał Horodecki (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-24253.txt.
Introduction
Marcin Łobejko and two co-authors prove that discrete and continuous heat engines assisted by a catalyst behave equivalently. In a discrete two stroke engine, a catalyst is an auxiliary system that returns to its start, does no work, and never touches the heat baths, yet boosts power and efficiency. Such engines are easy to analyze but hard to build, since each stroke needs precise control.
Continuous engines, driven externally while coupled to both baths at once, are easier to realize in the lab. The authors map the discrete strokes onto continuous processes, with and without a catalyst. The equivalence carries catalytic advantages from the discrete framework into the continuous one, guiding real designs.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Marcin Łobejko, Tanmoy Biswas, Michał Horodecki |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 95 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-24253
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Equivalence of Discrete and Continuous Otto-Like Engines assisted by Catalysts: Mapping Catalytic Advantages from the Discrete to the Continuous Framework Marcin Łobejko, Tanmoy Biswas, Michał Horodecki Abstract The catalytic extension of a discrete two-stroke engine employs a cyclic auxiliary system—the catalyst—that remains decoupled from the baths and performs no work, yet enhances power and efficiency beyond the corresponding non-catalytic counterpart. Theoretical models of discrete engines are relatively easy to analyze but remain challenging for experimental implementation due to the required control over individual strokes. In contrast, externally driven engines that are simultaneously coupled to both heat baths — the so-called continuous engines — are more experimentally feasible. Here, we establish an equivalence between discrete and continuous machines, both with and without a catalyst, by mapping the discrete unitary processes and thermalization steps onto an interaction Hamiltonian and a Markovian model of dissipation. As a result, by replacing probability flows with probability currents, we construct an analogous continuous machine corresponding to previously demonstrated catalytic schemes that generalize Otto engines. We illustrate this mapping for the simplest catalytic extension of the Otto engine, demonstrating catalytic enhancement in the continuous regime. Figure 1: The upper panel illustrates a discrete Otto-like heat engine with a qudit catalyst. The left subpanel (A1) shows the work stroke, where the engine extracts work, while the right subpanel (A2) depicts the heat stroke, during which the qubits rethermalize to their initial temperatures, completing the cycle. The catalyst is chosen so that its marginal state remains unchanged after the work stroke, and correlations with the system are erased during the heat stroke, ensuring the engine is re-initialized. The lower panel (B) shows a continuous Otto-like engine assisted by a qudit catalyst. Unlike the discrete engine, it operates without distinct strokes, remaining continuously coupled to the driving field for work extraction and to the heat baths for thermalization. Dissipative interactions drive the engine toward a stationary state, resulting steady heat currents J_{h} , J_{c} , and power P . Introduction: A microscopic Otto engine can be conceptualized as a machine operating at two distinct frequencies, say \omega_{h} and \omega_{c} , such that the work extraction process is separated from the thermalization of the energy levels at the corresponding temperatures ( \beta_{h} and \beta_{c} ) Scovil and Schulz-DuBois 1959 ; Geusic et al. 1967 ; Alicki 1979 ; Kosloff and Rezek 2017 ; Zhang et al. 2014a ; Zhang et al. 2014b ; Xiao et al. 2023 ; Quan et al. 2007 ; Quan 2009 ; Deffner 2018 ; Kosloff 2013 ; Quan et al. 2007 ; Quan 2009 ; Geva and Kosloff 1992 ; Feldmann and Kosloff 2004 ; Kosloff 2013 ; Feldmann and Kosloff 2003 . In other words, the Otto engine consists of two types of strokes: the work stroke and the heat stroke. In this scenario, it can be shown that the optimal performance of the engine is given by the Otto efficiency Solfanelli et al. 2020 ; Campisi et al. 2015 ; Biswas et al. 2024 : \eta_{\rm Otto}=1-\frac{\omega_{c}}{\omega_{h}}. (1) Recent works Łobejko et al. 2024 ; Biswas et al. 2024 ; Fu et al. 2025 ; Henao and Uzdin 2021 ; Henao and Uzdin 2023 have extended the simplest Otto setup by introducing an ancillary system that acts as a catalyst , a well-established concept in quantum information and quantum thermodynamics Brandão et al. 2015 ; Wilming 2021 ; Shiraishi and Sagawa 2021 ; Datta et al. 2023 ; Lipka-Bartosik et al. 2024 . In the context of thermal machines, a catalyst must satisfy two key conditions: (i) it does not introduce any new energy scale into the machine and can, in principle, have a degenerate spectrum; (ii) it is restored to its original state after the completion of the thermodynamic cycle without thermal intervention, i.e., it remains thermally uncoupled. Within this generalized catalytic Otto-like framework, it is possible to design protocols that achieve any efficiency value between the Otto efficiency \eta_{\text{Otto}} and the Carnot efficiency \eta_{\text{Carnot}}=1-\beta_{h}/\beta_{c} , which constitutes a catalytic advantage in efficiency Łobejko et al. 2024 ; Biswas et al. 2024 . In particular, with the aid of a catalyst, we can design a protocol whose efficiency represents a generalization of the Otto formula, given by \eta=1+\frac{\sum_{i}\Delta\varepsilon_{i}^{c}}{\sum_{i}\Delta\varepsilon_{i}^{h}}. (2) As for the standard Otto scenario, \eta depends solely on the ratio of the energy differences \Delta\varepsilon_{i}^{h} and \Delta\varepsilon_{i}^{c} associated with degrees of freedom coupled to the two distinct heat baths. If only a single energy difference is associated with each heat bath, the expression for \eta naturally reduces to the Otto efficiency \eta_{\text{Otto}} . Previous studies on the Otto-like engines, including catalytic advantages, were derived using the simplest theoretical model: an engine operating in discrete strokes that alternate between work extraction and thermalization Kosloff 1984 ; Kosloff and Levy 2014 ; Mitchison 2019 ; Allahverdyan et al. 2010 ; Henao and Uzdin 2023 ; Kosloff and Rezek 2017 ; Antonio Marín Guzmán et al. 2024 . While this discrete framework is highly convenient for analytical treatment Brunner et al. 2014 ; Clivaz et al. 2019a ; Clivaz et al. 2019b ; Łobejko et al. 2020 ; Biswas et al. 2022 ; Biswas and Datta 2024 , it is not necessarily the most natural choice for experimental implementation: discrete engines require external control to coordinate the sequence of strokes, which can be technically demanding Dann and Kosloff 2023 ; Linden et al. 2010a ; Linden et al. 2010b . In contrast, a more experimentally realistic setup involves engines that are continuously coupled to both heat baths (for thermalization) and a driving field (for work extraction), commonly referred to as continuous engines (see, e.g., Alicki 1979 ; Gelbwaser-Klimovsky, D. et al. 2013 ; Kosloff and Levy 2014 ; Cangemi et al. 2024 ; Linden et al. 2010b ; Linden et al. 2010a ; Popescu 2010 ; Clivaz et al. 2019a ; Brunner et al. 2014 ). Since these engines do not involve discrete strokes, they can operate without external control to manage the sequence of operations, making them more practical and easier to implement in a laboratory. This raises an important question: To what extent do the results obtained for discrete models of Otto-like engines remain valid for continuous engines that are more realistic? In particular, can such models accurately predict the same efficiency, and how do the two approaches compare in terms of power/work output? Addressing this question naturally leads to an important follow-up: to what extent do the catalytic advantages observed in the discrete Otto-like scenario translate to the continuous case? These questions point to a broader issue in the field. Much of the theoretical work has concentrated on recovering the dynamics of a continuous engine as the limiting case of a discrete engine, achieved by taking the cycle duration to be infinitesimally small. Most of these studies have focused on Otto engines (without a catalyst) Uzdin et al. 2015 ; Chiara et al. 2018 ; Molitor and Landi 2020 ; Melo et al. 2022 ; Dann and Kosloff 2023 ; Campbell and Vacchini 2021 ; Strasberg 2019 ; Bettmann et al. 2023 ; Piccione et al. 2021 ; Saha et al. 2024 ; Cusumano and De Chiara 2024 ; Ciccarello et al.