Observation of a pronounced Hebel-Slichter peak in the spin-lattice relaxation rate and implications for gap and pairing symmetry in LaNiGa 2
P. Sherpa, R. Hingorani, A. Menon, I. Vinograd, C. Chaffey, A. P. Dioguardi, R. Yamamoto, M. Hirata, F. Ronning, J. R. Badger, P. Klavins, R. R. P. Singh, V. Taufour, N. J. Curro · 2025
Read Observation of a pronounced Hebel-Slichter peak in the spin-lattice relaxation rate and implications for gap and pairing symmetry in LaNiGa 2 by P. Sherpa, R. Hingorani, A. Menon, I. Vinograd, C. Chaffey, A. P. Dioguardi, R. Yamamoto, M. Hirata, F. Ronning, J. R. Badger, P. Klavins, R. R. P. Singh, V. Taufour, N. J. Curro (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-23800.txt.
Introduction
P. Sherpa and thirteen co-authors report a sharp Hebel-Slichter coherence peak in the superconductor LaNiGa2, and use it to test what kind of pairing the material hosts. This crystalline superconductor was thought to pair electrons in an internally antisymmetric non-unitary triplet state, with two gaps tied to different spins. Nuclear quadrupolar resonance measurements of the spin-lattice relaxation rate give a check.
The peak's temperature dependence fits the triplet model only if the two gaps are equal and the state is unitary. Slight non-unitarity with unequal gaps shrinks the peak fast and breaks the fit. By contrast, a two-band singlet BCS-like pairing with two gaps fits the data well and matches earlier measurements. The authors argue the result casts doubt on the claimed time-reversal-breaking triplet state in this material. Gap symmetry, it turns out, can be read from one peak.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | P. Sherpa, R. Hingorani, A. Menon, I. Vinograd, C. Chaffey, A. P. Dioguardi, R. Yamamoto, M. Hirata, F. Ronning, J. R. Badger, P. Klavins, R. R. P. Singh, V. Taufour, N. J. Curro |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 24 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-23800
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Observation of a pronounced Hebel-Slichter peak in the spin-lattice relaxation rate and implications for gap and pairing symmetry in LaNiGa 2 P. Sherpa, R. Hingorani, A. Menon, I. Vinograd, C. Chaffey, A. P. Dioguardi, R. Yamamoto, M. Hirata, F. Ronning, J. R. Badger, P. Klavins, R. R. P. Singh, V. Taufour, N. J. Curro Abstract We report a pronounced Hebel-Slichter coherence peak in the zero field nuclear quadrupolar resonance (NQR) spin-lattice relaxation rate of the topological crystalline superconductor LaNiGa 2 in the superconducting state. Previously, a two-band internally antisymmetric non-unitary triplet pairing (INT) state was proposed for this system, with equal spin-pairing and two distinct gaps associated with different spins. A detailed examination of the temperature dependence of the NQR data shows that the data best fit an INT model if the two gaps are equal and the model is unitary. Even a tiny non-unitarity with two unequal gaps causes the coherence peak to diminish rapidly and deviate from the data. On the other hand, the data are well-fit by a two-band singlet BCS-like pairing with two distinct gaps consistent with previous measurements. This raises doubts on the identification of non-unitary triplet-pairing with time-reversal symmetry breaking in this material. Superconductors that exhibit spontaneous magnetic fields are unusual because the most energetically favorable state generally involves spin-singlet pairing between Cooper pairs of opposite momentum electrons. Spin triplet pairing can emerge in rare cases, such as in the well-known candidates UPt 3 and UTe 2 , where triplet pairing has been observed, and, in case of UPt 3 there is further evidence of a finite magnetization and time-reversal symmetry breaking (TRSB) Ran et al. 2019 ; Schemm et al. 2014 . TRSB has been recently observed via muon spin resonance ( \mu SR) experiments in the superconducting state of the topological crystalline superconductor LaNiGa 2 with T_{c}=2.1 K Hillier et al. 2012 ; Ghosh et al. 2020a . This material has a non-symmorphic orthorhombic crystal structure ( C_{mcm} ) that gives rise to a non-trivial band topology with band-degeneracies at the Fermi level Badger et al. 2022 ; Quan et al. 2022 . This degeneracy can give rise to multi-band superconductivity involving both intra- and inter-band pairing. It has been proposed that the condensate wavefunction may be described as an internally antisymmetric, nonunitary, triplet (INT) state that is fully gapped with s-wave symmetry in momentum space, antisymmetric in the band channel, and symmetric in spin space with equal-spin triplet ( S=1 ) pairing Ghosh et al. 2020b . In this case, there are two components to a superconducting pair wavefunction corresponding to either both spins up or both spins down Weng et al. 2016 ; Ghosh et al. 2020b . If the order parameter is nonunitary, there will be two distinct superconducting gaps with different magnitudes, and the corresponding superfluid densities will also differ leading to a finite internal magnetization. Support for this interpretation has emerged from specific heat Weng et al. 2016 , penetration depth Ghimire et al. 2024 , and \mu SR Sundar et al. 2024 measurements in LaNiGa 2 that revealed the presence of two superconducting gaps. However, such measurements are mostly sensitive to the density of states and cannot probe the spin structure of the superconducting condensate. Figure 1: 139 La T_{1}^{-1} versus inverse temperature in the superconducting state of LaNiGa 2 (with T_{c}=1.83 K). The solid and dashed lines are calculations as discussed in the text, and the gap values, ( \Delta_{1} , \Delta_{2} ) and nuclear resonance frequency, \omega_{N} , are given in units of k_{B}T_{c} . The data are well fit by a two-gap singlet-pairing model as well as by an INT triplet-pairing model with two equal gaps, but not with the INT model with two different gaps. The inset shows the unit cell of LaNiGa 2 . Zero field nuclear quadrupolar resonance (NQR) can shed light on the spins of Cooper pairs because the spin lattice relaxation rate, T_{1}^{-1} , of nuclear spins is driven by spin-flip scattering with the Bogoliubov excitations. The Hebel-Slichter coherence peak is an increase in T_{1}^{-1} below T_{c} that arises due to a temperature-dependent build up of a sharp peak in the density of states and the particular quantum mechanical superposition of holes and electrons describing the excitations Hebel and Slichter 1957 ; Hebel and Slichter 1959 ; Arovas and Wu 2019 . The coherence peak generally emerges in conventional superconductors MacLaughlin 1976 ; Kiefl et al. 1993 ; Kotegawa et al. 2001 , but is suppressed, apart from extrinsic impurity scattering, for several intrinsic reasons in unconventional superconductors. These include an anisotropic gap that can suppress the peak in the density of states or a change in the symmetry of the pair-wave functions and excitations that can alter coherence factors Statt 1990 ; Brandow 1998 . Here we find that in an equal-spin pairing triplet state the peak can also be suppressed by having two different gaps for different spin components. At lower temperatures, the temperature dependence of T_{1}^{-1} reflects the superconducting gap, exhibiting either activated behavior in superconductors with a full gap Nakai et al. 2005 ; Ding et al. 2016 , or power law behavior in unconventional superconductors with nodes in the gap Imai et al. 1988 ; Curro et al. 2005 . Less is known about the behavior of T_{1}^{-1} for the INT state. In this case, there are four types of Bogoliubov excitations involving superpositions of electrons and holes with parallel spins in different bands. Because they involve parallel spins, one might expect spin-flip scattering by nuclear spins would be suppressed, and that T_{1}^{-1} may depend on the orientation of the \mathbf{d} -vector that describes the triplet order parameter Tanaka et al. 2016 ; Tanaka et al. 2018 . Here we present 139 La ( I=7/2 ) NQR T_{1}^{-1} data in the superconducting state of LaNiGa 2 that exhibits a Hebel-Slichter coherence peak as well as activated behavior at low temperatures. We show that a robust coherence peak can only emerge for the INT state if the two gaps are equal in magnitude, with no TRSB. When the equal spin pairing axis is different from the nuclear quantization axis, a weak HS peak arises with TRSB with two distinct gaps, but it is too weak to fit the data. Comparison of the observed HS peak in LaNiGa 2 with other materials shows that the peak in LaNiGa 2 is quite robust. Our experimental results are well described by a two-band singlet model with different gap magnitudes consistent with the previously reported heat capacity and penetration depth experiments. 139 La NQR measurements of the spin lattice relaxation rate were carried out on a finely powdered sample of LaNiGa 2 ( T_{c}=1.83 K) down to 240 mK, as discussed in the supplemental materials sup . This material has a single La site (see inset of Fig. 1 ), and the quantization axis of the I=7/2 nuclear spins lies along the principal axis of the electric field gradient (EFG) tensor, \nu_{\alpha\beta} . This axis corresponds to the crystalline b axis with \nu_{bb}=1.65 MHz, and asymmetry parameter \eta=(\nu_{aa}-\nu_{cc})/\nu_{bb}=0.04 Sherpa et al. 2024 . T_{1}^{-1} measurements were carried out at the 3\nu_{Q}\approx 5.060 MHz transition by inversion recovery, and