Estimating and decoding coherent errors of QEC experiments with detector error models

Evangelia Takou, Kenneth R. Brown · 2025

Read Estimating and decoding coherent errors of QEC experiments with detector error models by Evangelia Takou, Kenneth R. Brown (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-23797.txt.

Introduction

Evangelia Takou and a co-author show that the data stream of a quantum error correction run already reveals coherent errors. Decoders rely on a detector error model: a list of likely error events and their rates. Coherent errors build up like waves and can interfere, unlike random noise. They are normally hunted with separate benchmarking runs on the device.

The authors show that syndrome histories alone can both flag and size up coherent errors, with no benchmarking first. Error models fitted this way work just as well under coherent noise as under random noise. Simulations on repetition and surface codes capture the interference, which can raise or lower error rates versus the random case. New hyperedge patterns also appear, missing from simpler twirled models. Decoding with the right model shifts the error threshold, a practical warning for experiment design.

Catalog record

CREATOREvangelia Takou, Kenneth R. Brown
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE32 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-23797

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Estimating and decoding coherent errors of QEC experiments with detector error models Evangelia Takou, Kenneth R. Brown Abstract Decoders of quantum error correction (QEC) experiments make decisions based on detected errors and the expected rates of error events, which together comprise a detector error model. Here we show that the syndrome history of QEC experiments is sufficient to detect and estimate coherent errors, removing the need for prior device benchmarking experiments. Importantly, our method shows that experimentally determined detector error models work equally well for both stochastic and coherent noise regimes. We model fully-coherent or fully-stochastic noise for repetition and surface codes and for various phenomenological and circuit-level noise scenarios, by employing Majorana and Monte Carlo simulators. We capture the interference of coherent errors, which appears as enhanced or suppressed physical error rates compared to the stochastic case, and also observe hyperedges that do not appear in the corresponding Pauli-twirled models. Finally, we decode the detector error models undergoing coherent noise and find different thresholds compared to detector error models built based on the stochastic noise assumption. I Introduction A promising route towards realizing large-scale fault-tolerant quantum architectures is by utilizing quantum error correction (QEC). QEC encodes logical information redundantly on several physical qubits, and by carefully correcting physical errors, it can suppress the error rate on the logical level. For incoherent errors, which are modeled as stochastic Pauli errors, the logical error rate decays exponentially with the code distance, as long as the physical errors are below threshold Aharonov and Ben-Or 1996 ; Dennis et al. 2002 . Similarly, for coherent errors it has been shown that a threshold also exists Iverson and Preskill 2020 ; Bravyi et al. 2018 ; Márton and Asbóth 2023 ; Pato et al. 2025 . Coherent errors on the physical level are often more complicated to understand than stochastic errors, since they introduce coherent errors on the logical level Greenbaum and Dutton 2017 ; Bravyi et al. 2018 , and they lead to different failure distributions compared to stochastic models Barnes et al. 2017 . Coherent noise which can arise from miscalibration of gates Debroy et al. 2018 , spectator qubits Krinner et al. 2020 , measurement Di Giovanni et al. 2025 or state preparation errors, is of concern for QEC codes as it is typically more detrimental to the performance of QEC codes than stochastic errors Beale et al. 2018 ; Suzuki et al. 2017 . Further, the Pauli-twirled coherent channel underestimates the impact of coherent noise on the logical error rate Gutiérrez et al. 2016 ; Bravyi et al. 2018 . The impact of coherent noise on QEC codes has only been studied in specific setups as it is generally not easy to simulate it efficiently on large QEC codes. In particular, Bravyi et al . Bravyi et al. 2018 , showed that coherent noise along a single-axis can be efficiently simulated on surface codes in a code-capacity setup, using Majorana simulators. This formalism has been applied to repetition codes Suzuki et al. 2017 , surface codes and other topological planar codes Pataki et al. 2024 ; Pato et al. 2025 ; Venn et al. 2023 ; Venn and Béri 2020 ; Behrends and Béri 2024 , and extended to the case where measurements experience classical readout errors Márton and Asbóth 2023 . Recently, Ref. Miller et al. 2025 developed efficient simulation methods to simulate approximately small Markovian errors, including coherent errors, to study the impact of more complex noise models for near-term devices. These works have opened interesting avenues for further exploration of coherent noise effects on QEC experiments. For example, it is still unclear what type of decoding graphs or hypergraphs coherent noise generates, and how this structure compares to stochastic detector error models (DEMs) that can be generated efficiently by Stim Gidney 2021 . In terms of decoding performance, previous works have mainly assumed uniform weights to decode coherent noise via MWPM Higgott 2022 ; Higgott and Gidney 2025 . This may not be the optimal decoding choice for DEMs undergoing coherent noise, since interference of coherent errors may occur, and further, circuit-level DEMs might also exhibit hyperedges. Finally, although arbitrary coherent errors cannot be simulated both efficiently and exactly, a more important question is: can these errors be estimated efficiently from the syndrome data from QEC experiments so as to configure a DEM, and how important is the impact of coherent noise on the decoding performance? In this paper, we attempt to address those questions by estimating coherent noise from syndrome data, which reveals the true structure of the DEM, and allows us to observe interference of coherent errors. We perform code-capacity, phenomenological, and finally circuit-level simulations of coherent noise, for repetition and surface codes. Already from the code-capacity simulation of surface codes, we find coherent enhancement of certain error rates for boundary qubits. Remarkably, such enhancement factors can be estimated from syndrome data, without changing our noise estimation methods which hold for Pauli noise, and we can inform the decoder about such features. We also find that the estimated DEM of a rotated surface code undergoing coherent data qubit errors and readout errors leads to suppressed logical error rate compared to a uniform-weight DEM. For coherent noise on data and ancilla qubits for a repetition code, we find a threshold of \sim 8\% , which is smaller compared to the threshold of 10.3\% obtained from the corresponding stochastic model. When gates additionally suffer from coherent errors, we find that the repetition code DEM contains hyperedges, making decoding more challenging. Such hyperedges do not appear in the corresponding Pauli-twirled models. We find a threshold of 2.5\% if those hyperedges are ignored and a uniform-weight decoder is used. Finally, the presence of hyperedges complicates the estimation of edge error-rates, since we have to subtract from the statistics the effect of higher-order correlations. By doing so, we obtain a DEM which leads to the same threshold as the uniform-weight DEM, but achieves a reduced logical error rate. The paper is structured as follows. In Sec. II , we give an overview of noise-learning methods from syndrome measurements executed during a QEC experiment. In Sec. III , we apply our estimation method to learn coherent noise for code-capacity, phenomenological or circuit-level noise on repetition or surface codes, and study the decoding performance of the estimated DEMs. II Overview of detector error model estimation from syndrome history To decode errors optimally, a decoder needs to be informed about the error rates of several components failing, as well as time or spatial correlations of errors. This information is usually captured by a DEM Gidney 2021 ; Derks et al. 2024 , which lists the detectors that are triggered by an error mechanism and the corresponding probabilities. A DEM can also be represented as a weighted decoding graph or hypergraph, where the nodes are the detectors and the (hyper-)edges are weighted based on the error rates according to w=\log((1-p)/p) Higgott and Gidney 2025 . One way to construct the DEM of a QEC experiment, is to first characterize the device and obtain experimental error rates of the circuit-level model, i.e., the Pauli-error rates of qubits, gates and measurements and feed such imperfect circuit

Read the complete text