Delayed Charged Lepton Yukawa Equilibration and Thermal Leptogenesis
Rishav Roshan, Sudipta Show · 2025
Read Delayed Charged Lepton Yukawa Equilibration and Thermal Leptogenesis by Rishav Roshan, Sudipta Show (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-23712.txt.
Introduction
Rishav Roshan and a co-author revisit the minimal type-I seesaw, the standard story for why neutrinos have tiny masses. Most studies drop the heaviest right-handed neutrino from the model, assuming it decouples and adds nothing to masses or to leptogenesis, the early-universe process that may explain the matter surplus. The authors show that assumption can mislead when the particle lives long.
A long-lived heavy neutrino changes the temperature at which charged lepton Yukawa interactions come into balance in the hot early universe. That shift forces a fresh look at flavor effects in thermal leptogenesis and can move the borders between flavor regimes. The paper also points to probes: neutrino oscillation data and gravitational wave observations could test the scenario. Beyond leptogenesis, the altered expansion history touches dark matter production and the primordial gravitational wave spectrum.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Rishav Roshan, Sudipta Show |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 21 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-23712
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Delayed Charged Lepton Yukawa Equilibration and Thermal Leptogenesis Rishav Roshan, Sudipta Show Abstract While most studies of the minimal type-I seesaw neglect the heaviest decoupled right-handed neutrino, assuming negligible contributions to neutrino masses and leptogenesis, we demonstrate that its cosmological role can be significant. When long-lived, this particle substantially modifies the charged lepton Yukawa equilibration temperature in the early universe, necessitating reassessment of lepton flavor effects in thermal leptogenesis and potentially shifting flavor regime boundaries. We identify experimental probes through neutrino oscillation measurements and gravitational wave observations. Understanding the origin of the observed matter-antimatter asymmetry Aghanim et al. 2020 represents a fundamental challenge in modern cosmology. Several studies have proposed mechanisms for dynamically generating baryon asymmetry that adhere to Sakharov’s conditions Sakharov 1967 . Among these, the type I seesaw mechanism Minkowski 1977 ; Yanagida 1979a ; Yanagida 1979b ; Gell-Mann et al. 1979 ; Mohapatra and Senjanovic 1980 ; Schechter and Valle 1980 ; Schechter and Valle 1982 ; Datta et al. 2021 is particularly compelling. It offers a minimal extension of the Standard Model (SM) by introducing three heavy right-handed neutrinos (RHNs) N_{i} , which simultaneously explain neutrino masses and generate lepton asymmetry through their out-of-equilibrium decays into SM lepton ( \ell_{L}^{T}=(\nu_{L},e_{L}) ) and Higgs ( H ) doublets. The corresponding Lagrangian is given by: \displaystyle-\mathcal{L}=\overline{\ell}_{L_{\alpha}}(Y_{\nu})_{\alpha i}\tilde{H}N_{i}+\frac{1}{2}\overline{N_{i}^{c}}(M_{R})_{i}N_{i}+h.c., (1) (in the charged lepton diagonal basis) with \alpha=e,\mu,\tau and i=1,2,3 , and interestingly, these RHNs have strong theoretical motivation beyond phenomenology. They naturally arise in grand unified theories (GUTs) such as SO(10) or E_{6} and are crucial for anomaly cancellation in extensions of the SM that include additional gauge symmetries like U(1)_{\rm B-L} or SU(2)_{R} . Once the universe is reheated, gauge interactions, including U(1)_{\rm B-L} and SU(2)_{R} , rapidly establish thermal equilibrium with the RHNs in the plasma. Subsequently, the decay of these RHNs produces a lepton asymmetry that is ultimately converted into a baryon asymmetry through electroweak sphalerons at temperatures above approximately T\sim 130 GeV Kuzmin et al. 1985 ; Bento 2003 ; D’Onofrio et al. 2014 in a radiation-dominated universe. It is well known that both the observed neutrino oscillation pattern and successful leptogenesis can be accommodated with just two RHNs, representing a limiting case of three RHN models where one neutrino decouples from the seesaw mechanism via either extremely heavy mass or vanishingly weak Yukawa couplings. This framework inherently predicts one massless active neutrino and has been widely studied for its minimality King 2000 ; Antusch et al. 2012 ; Li and Ding 2017 ; King 2025 (and the references therein). However, most studies of these constructions have neglected the role of the heaviest (decoupled) RHN, say N_{3} , assuming it contributes negligibly to neutrino mass generation and leptogenesis. In this letter, we investigate the cosmological implications of the otherwise neglected heavy RHN. Though initially in thermal equilibrium 1 1 1 As mentioned earlier, this can be naturally achieved in SO(10) or E_{6} GUT theories. , N_{3} later decouples due to its extremely weak (but non-zero) interaction with the SM lepton and Higgs doublet. These suppressed couplings simultaneously ensure N_{3} is long-lived, allowing it to dominate the cosmic energy density and drive an epoch of matter domination (MD), while also yielding a tiny but non-zero mass ( m_{\ell} ) for the lightest active neutrino. To achieve this, we consider the following structure of the neutrino Yukawa matrix at the leading order \displaystyle Y_{\nu}=\left(\begin{array}[]{ccc}y_{e1}&y_{e2}&\epsilon_{1}\\ y_{\mu 1}&y_{\mu 2}&\epsilon_{2}\\ y_{\tau 1}&y_{\tau 2}&\epsilon_{3}\\ \end{array}\right), where \epsilon_{i=1,2,3}\ll 1 2 2 2 A similar structure of Yukawa was also considered in Datta et al. 2021 but in the context of dark matter. . While the nearly vanishing right column of the Yukawa matrix ensures that N_{3} remains effectively decoupled, the N_{1,2} along with the first two columns of Y_{\nu} generate light neutrino mass to explain the neutrino oscillation data via the seesaw mechanism. The entries of Y_{\nu} can be written using the Casas-Ibarra (CI) parametrization Casas and Ibarra 2001 : \displaystyle Y_{\nu}=UD_{\sqrt{m}}R^{T}D_{\sqrt{M}}/\sqrt{2}v, (5) where v=246 GeV, U is the PMNS Zyla et al. 2020 mixing matrix diagonalizing m_{\nu}=Y_{\nu}M^{-1}_{R}Y^{T}_{\nu}v^{2}/2 , D_{m}~(D_{M}) is the diagonal active neutrino (RHN) mass matrix and R is a complex orthogonal matrix chosen to be of the form, \displaystyle R=\left(\begin{array}[]{ccc}1&0&0\\ 0&\cos\theta_{R}&\sin\theta_{R}\\ 0&-\sin\theta_{R}&\cos\theta_{R}\\ \end{array}\right), where \theta_{R}=a+ib is a complex angle in general. We employ the best fitted values Fogli et al. 2006 of mixing angles, CP phase, as well as mass-square differences to define the U and D_{\sqrt{m}} . The smallness of \epsilon_{i} can arise from three sources: a tiny m_{\ell} (lightest active neutrino mass), an additional rotation angle \varphi applied to R , or both effects combined. For concreteness and without loss of generality, we focus on the small m_{\ell} scenario in our analysis, noting that equivalent results are obtained in the \varphi rotation approach. Following Eq.( 5 ), this choice yields \epsilon_{i}\propto\sqrt{m_{\ell}M_{3}} . We emphasize that N_{3} phenomenology is largely insensitive to the left two columns of Y_{\nu} . We now proceed to investigate the cosmological evolution leading to early MD driven by the long-lived heavy neutrino N_{3} under the assumption that this species was in thermal equilibrium at the time of its production. The relevant dynamics are governed by the following coupled Boltzmann equations (BE): \displaystyle a\frac{d\rho_{N_{3}}}{da}+F\rho_{N_{3}}=-\frac{\Gamma_{N_{3}}}{\mathcal{H}}\rho_{N_{3}} \displaystyle a\frac{d\rho_{R}}{da}+4\rho_{R}=+\frac{\Gamma_{N_{3}}}{\mathcal{H}}\rho_{N_{3}} (9) where \rho_{R} represents the energy density of SM radiation and \rho_{N_{3}} and \Gamma_{N_{3}}=\frac{(Y_{\nu}^{\dagger}Y_{\nu})_{33}}{8\pi}M_{3} refer to the the energy density and decay width of N_{3} respectively. \mathcal{H}=\sqrt{\rho_{N_{3}}+\rho_{R}}/3M_{P}^{2} denotes the expansion rate of the universe with M_{P}(=2.4\times 10^{18}~\text{GeV}) being the reduced Planck mass. The factor F dictates the behaviour of \rho_{N_{3}} ’s evolution where F=4~(3) when N_{3} is relativistic (non-relativistic). For illustration, in Figure 1 , we present a numerical solution to the above BEs showing how N_{3} induces an era of early matter domination. The plot is obtained using m_{\ell}=5\times 10^{-12} eV and M_{3}=10^{14} GeV. The red (black) line shows the evolution of the N_{3} (radiation) energy density with the scale factor a (normalized with respect to a_{\text{RH}} defined at reheating temperature ( T_{\rm RH}=10^{16} GeV), assuming an instantaneous reheating after the end of inflation as an initial condition). Initially, N_{3} behaves as radiation with energy density scaling as \rho_{N_{3}}\propto a^{-4} . Once the universe temperature ( T ) drops to T\sim M_{3} , the N_{3} becomes non-relativistic and its energy density starts following matter-like scaling, \rho_{N_{3}}\propto a^{-3} . Consequently, the universe enters an early matter-dominated era that persists until N_{3} decays completely. Figure 1: Evolution of the various energy densities as a function of the relative scale factor, a/a_{\text{RH}} . One immediate consequence of this early matter dominated era is a shift in the equilibration temperature (ET) T^{*} of the SM charged Yukawa interactions 3 3 3 A similar analysis was done in Datta et al. 2024 ; Datta et al. 2023 but in the context of extended reheating. . The equilibration of these interactions plays a non-trivial role when studying the effect of different lepton flavors in leptogenesis Barbieri et al. 2000 ; Nardi et al. 2006a ; Abada et al. 2006 ; Nardi et al. 2006b ; Blanchet and Di Bari 2007 ; Dev et al. 2018 ; Datta et al. 2022 . Specifically, when a given charged lepton Yukawa interaction is in equilibrium at