Refinement of a Poroelastic Model for Zero Porosity: Finite Element Implementation and Investigation of Fluid Mechanics in the Perivascular Space
Mohammad Jannesari, Beatrice Ghitti, Bruce J. Gluckman, Francesco Costanzo · 2025
Read Refinement of a Poroelastic Model for Zero Porosity: Finite Element Implementation and Investigation of Fluid Mechanics in the Perivascular Space by Mohammad Jannesari, Beatrice Ghitti, Bruce J. Gluckman, Francesco Costanzo (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-23683.txt.
Introduction
Mohammad Jannesari and three co-authors fix a breakdown in poroelastic modeling, the theory of fluid moving through a spongy solid. When porosity drops to zero in part of a material, the standard equations collapse to solid-only form. The fluid velocity then cannot be determined, even though the fluid still matters nearby. Such vanishing can happen briefly in real tissues and engineered media.
The authors reformulate the model from mixture theory so it stays valid at zero porosity. They verify the fix with the method of manufactured solutions and show it survives an extreme test case. As an application, they simulate pulsing flow in the perivascular space around a penetrating arteriole in the brain. Some parameter values suggested in the literature push the model to extreme, non-physical predictions. Letting the surrounding brain tissue deform softened those extremes, a warning for future modeling of brain fluid flow.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Mohammad Jannesari, Beatrice Ghitti, Bruce J. Gluckman, Francesco Costanzo |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 136 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-23683
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Refinement of a Poroelastic Model for Zero Porosity: Finite Element Implementation and Investigation of Fluid Mechanics in the Perivascular Space Mohammad Jannesari, Beatrice Ghitti, Bruce J. Gluckman, Francesco Costanzo Abstract In conventional formulations of poroelasticity, when the porosity approaches zero or vanishes in some parts of the poroelastic domain, if only temporarily, the governing equations degenerate to those for the solid phase thereby inhibiting a suitable determination of the fluid velocity field. To address this challenge, we reformulated a poroelastic model based on mixture theory to accommodate scenarios with zero porosity. We verified our model using the method of manufactured solutions and demonstrated its ability to handle extreme conditions in a sample test problem. As an application of our framework, we investigated peristaltic flow in the perivascular space of a penetrating arteriole in brain. Our analysis revealed that some literature-suggested parameters can drive the model to predict extreme non-physiological conditions. We further demonstrated that these extreme conditions can be somewhat mitigated by accounting for the deformation of the surrounding brain tissue. 1 Introduction The brain is housed within the skull and immersed in CSF ( CSF ), which circulates around the brain and spinal cord Kucewicz2007Functional-tiss , TarasoffConway2015Clearance-syste , Abbott2018The-Role-of-Brain-0 , Hladky2018Elimination-of- , Hladky2022The-glymphatic- . The brain deformation is hypothesized to assist in this circulation by promoting the removal of metabolic waste products from the CNS ( CNS ) Sloots2020CardiacAndRespi . In addition to the large-scale circulation of CSF , evidence suggests that IF ( IF ) also flows through the brain tissue itself and exchanges metabolites and other solutes with the broader CSF system (cf. Iliff2012A-Paravascular-0 , Iliff2013Brain-wide-Path0 , Iliff2013Is-There-a-Cere-0 , Iliff2013Cerebral-Arteri-0 , Nedergaard2013Garbage-Truck-o , Rasmussen2022Fluid-transport ). Understanding these fluid flows is critical to gaining insights into both normal brain physiology and the development of pathological conditions such as neurodegenerative diseases Abbott2018The-Role-of-Brain-0 , Nedergaard2013Garbage-Truck-o , Hladky2022The-glymphatic- . However, directly observing and quantifying these flows in vivo is extraordinarily challenging via currently available experimental techniques. For example, the pressure differences driving CSF through PVS ( PVS ) can be as small as \numprint[mmHg]{0.01} — \numprint{100} times smaller than the approximately \numprint[mmHg]{1} resolution of current instruments Oshio2004ReducedCerebros , Uldall2017AcetazolamideLo —and are further disrupted by invasive skull access Mestre2018Aquaporin4Depen . As a result, physics-based mathematical modeling has become an attractive tool to evaluate competing hypotheses about the drivers and pathways of brain fluid flow Hladky2022The-glymphatic- . Our group has been actively engaged in this field, especially in exploring the dynamics of fluid flow and exchange between the brain parenchyma and the SAS ( SAS ). In particular, CSF flow and exchange in the PVS have been investigated using computational modeling techniques, showing that, under idealized conditions, arterial pulsations alone may not suffice to drive flow within the arterial PVS Kedarasetti2020Arterial-Pulsat , Kedarasetti2020Functional-Hype . A crucial insight from our work is the importance of accounting for the deformability of brain tissue when modeling these processes. In fact, we have shown that mechanical deformations affect the effective permeability of the brain parenchyma and influence how fluids can move through it Kedarasetti2022ArterialVasodil , Garborg2025Gut- , Costanzo2025Por . In the course of our modeling effort, we encountered scenarios in which numerical methods struggled to adequately represent the physics. Specifically, under the action of periodic compressive loads, numerical experiments showed that deformation can strongly affect porosity so as to drive fluid out of some regions of the simulation’s domain, thereby leaving these regions nearly or entirely depleted of fluid. These results revealed a limitation in our poroelastic models when dealing with extreme cases of near-zero porosity, pointing out the need for a more refined model that can handle and accurately represent an extreme condition like vanishing porosity. Pursuing the creation of such a model is not motivated merely by numerical considerations. We believe that a stronger rationale stems from the role of computational modeling in testing physiological hypotheses through the lens of physics. Since some of these hypotheses may initially be incomplete or oversimplified, it is valuable to identify when and why a model prediction departs significantly from physiologically relevant conditions. This allows us to correct or discard any nonphysical assumptions. Motivated by these considerations, in this work we reformulate our poroelastic framework, previously adopted in several publications Kedarasetti2020Arterial-Pulsat , Kedarasetti2020Functional-Hype , Kedarasetti2022ArterialVasodil , Garborg2025Gut- , to handle situations where deformation completely expels the fluid out from parts of a poroelastic body, resulting in regions of vanishing porosity. We implement the model numerically, verify it using the method of manufactured solutions, and identify stable finite element spaces suitable for these cases. Although this study does not focus primarily on modeling brain physiology, here we revisit a flow problem simulating fluid flow in the PVS surrounding a cerebral vessel, caused by peristaltic motion of the arterial walls, to demonstrate the relevance of our approach. This problem illustrates how assumptions and parameter values in a model can yield predictions that diverge from physiological expectations. In addition, our findings further reinforce our belief that accounting for tissue deformability and the physics of porosity dynamics are essential to reach consistent and meaningful conclusions. In Section 2 , we revisit the traditional formulation of poroelasticity based on mixture theory. The modifications to capture the vanishing-porosity behavior are introduced in Section 3 . The weak form of the refined model is presented in Section 4 , where a verification test via the method of manufactured solutions and a local compression benchmark problem are also performed (Sections 4.2 and 4.3 , respectively). Finally, in Sections 5 we apply our model to the analysis of fluid flow in the PVS by peristalsis. 2 Traditional formulation: definitions and governing equations Here we report the governing equations of a poroelastic body starting from mixture theory Bowen1976TheoryOfMixture . 2.1 Constituent phases and mixture We consider a saturated binary mixture of a solid and a fluid phase. At the current time t , the mixture occupies the subset B_{t} (Fig. 1 ) Figure 1 : Current configuration B_{t} of a biphasic mixture, along with the reference configurations of solid and fluid components, B_{\mathrm{s}} and B_{\mathrm{f}} , respectively. Positions within B_{\mathrm{s}} and B_{\mathrm{f}} will be labeled as \bm{\mathbf{X}}_{\mathrm{s}} and \bm{\mathbf{X}}_{\mathrm{f}} , respectively, while \bm{\mathbf{x}} signifies the position within B_{t} . The boundaries of B_{\mathrm{s}} , B_{\mathrm{f}} , and B_{t} are \partial B_{\mathrm{s}} , \partial B_{\mathrm{f}} , and \partial B_{t} , respectively. These boundaries are oriented by their respective outward unit normal fields \bm{\mathbf{n}}_{\mathrm{s}} , \bm{\mathbf{n}}_{\mathrm{f}} , and \bm{\mathbf{n}} . of an all-containing Euclidean point space \mathcal{E}^{d} , with d=1,2 or 3 . The constituents of the mixture can coexist at each spatial point \bm{\mathbf{x}}\in B_{t} . Subscripts \mathrm{s} and \mathrm{f} will be used to denote quantities pertaining to the solid and fluid phases, respectively. As shown in Fig. 1 , we posit that there exists a diffeomorphism \bm{\mathbf{\chi}}_{a}:B_{a}\times[0,T]\rightarrow B_{t}\subset\mathcal{E}^{d} which maps the reference configuration B_{a} of component a ( a=\mathrm{s},\mathrm{f} ) to the mixture’s current configuration B_{t} . The position of points in B_{a} will be denoted by \bm{\mathbf{X}}_{a} . For simplicity, the initial configurations of the components are assumed to coincide with their respective reference configurations and with B_{t}|_{t=0} , and therefore with the initial configuration of the porous structure as a whole. We regard \mathcal{E}^{d} as covered by