Implications for the formation of Oort cloud-like structures and interstellar comets in dense environments
Santiago Torres · 2025
Read Implications for the formation of Oort cloud-like structures and interstellar comets in dense environments by Santiago Torres (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-23653.txt.
Introduction
Santiago Torres simulates how debris disks around young solar-system-like setups evolve inside dense star clusters, where close flybys can reshape a planetary system. Most stars are born in such crowds, and our own system's far comet cloud may be a scar of that era. Using the LonelyPlanets framework, which pairs two established simulation codes, he follows four giant planets plus either a compact or an extended debris disk.
Compact disks mostly built Kuiper belt and scattered disk populations through their own planets' gravity. Extended disks were sculpted by passing stars instead, forming Oort cloud-like reservoirs and flinging out interstellar comets at one to three kilometers per second. Flybys at shallow angles worked best, creating Sedna-like bodies and inner cloud analogues, while polar flybys puffed the outer disk toward a round cloud. The results tie comet reservoirs to the birthplaces of their stars.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Santiago Torres |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 80 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-23653
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Implications for the formation of Oort cloud-like structures and interstellar comets in dense environments Santiago Torres Abstract Most stars form in dense stellar environments, where frequent close encounters can strongly perturb and reshape the early architecture of planetary systems. The solar system, with its rich population of distant comets, provides a natural laboratory to study these processes. We perform detailed numerical simulations using the LonelyPlanets framework that combines NBODY6++GPU and REBOUND , to explore the evolution of debris disks around solar system analogues embedded in stellar clusters. Two initial configurations are considered: an Extended and a Compact model, each containing four giant planets and either an extended or compact debris disk. We find that compact disks primarily form Kuiper belt and scattered disk–like populations through planet–disk interactions, while extended disks are more strongly shaped by stellar encounters, producing Oort cloud–like structures and interstellar comets with ejection velocities of 1–3 km s -1 . Stellar perturbations are most effective for encounter inclinations between 0 ∘ 0^{\circ} and 30 ∘ 30^{\circ} , giving rise to distinct dynamical populations, like Sednoids, and inner Oort cloud analogues, and a characteristic tail in semi-major axis-eccentricity space. In coplanar encounters, the disk remains largely flattened, whereas polar flybys redistribute angular momentum vertically, producing nearly isotropic outer populations that resemble an emerging Oort cloud. Our results suggest that cometary reservoirs and interstellar objects are natural byproducts of planet–disk interactions and stellar flybys in dense clusters, linking the architecture of outer planetary systems to their birth environments. 1 Introduction Oort 1950 proposed the existence of a cloud of comets that surrounds the solar system, which was subsequently named after him. The Oort cloud is thought to contain about 10^{11} – 10^{12} comets ( Brasser & Morbidelli 2013 ) , with a total mass of around 2–3 M_{\oplus} ( Francis 2005 ; Morbidelli 2005 , e.g.,) . Its shape is conjectured to be nearly spherical, with the cloud extending up to 0.5 pc from the Sun, limited by the Hill sphere of the solar system ( Oort 1950 ; Chebotarev 1965 ) . Because these estimates of the Oort cloud properties are highly uncertain (mainly because of the lack of observations of the long-period comets), the creation, evolution, and even the existence of the Oort cloud remains a puzzle today. One of the main open questions is related to the moment of its formation. Several works have explored the origin and evolution of the Oort cloud, mainly by performing numerical simulations. These studies follow two main ideas of formation: a primordial or a late formation. The primordial model occurs in the early stages of the solar system when the Sun was still in its birth cluster ( Oort 1950 ; Hills 1981 ; Heisler & Tremaine 1986 ; Duncan et al. 1987 ; Weissman 1996 ; Wiegert & Tremaine 1999 ; Dones et al. 2004 ; Levison et al. 2010 , see e.g.,) . In this scenario, the planetesimals were scattered due to the interaction with the growing giant planets and started populating the Oort cloud. The late model assumes that the Sun has already left its birth cluster. In this alternative scenario the Oort cloud was created in the later stages of the solar system formation possibly due to gravitational instabilities when the giant plants experienced an oribtal resonance, which caused the minor bodies to be ejected onto almost unbound orbits ( Levison et al. 2004 ; Brasser et al. 2006 ; Fouchard et al. 2006 ; Kaib & Quinn 2008 ; Morbidelli 2005 ; Duncan 2008 ; Brasser & Morbidelli 2013 ; Shannon et al. 2014 ; Dones et al. 2015 ; Nesvorný 2018 ; Shannon et al. 2019 ; Vokrouhlický et al. 2019 ; Wu et al. 2023 ; Wu et al. 2024 , see e.g.,) . It is now widely accepted that the solar system was born within a stellar cluster ( Portegies Zwart 2009 ; Adams 2010 ) , and that the Sun remained a member of this cluster during the formation of the planets ( Pichardo et al. 2012 ; Portegies Zwart & Jílková 2015 ; Martínez-Barbosa et al. 2016 ) . Given that the typical lifetime of an open cluster is approximately 100 Myr and that stellar clusters are inherently dense environments, the likelihood of close stellar encounters during this period is significantly higher than it would be for a star evolving in isolation ( Portegies Zwart & Jílková 2015 ) . Consequently, the Oort cloud probably experienced gravitational interactions with the Sun’s stellar siblings during the early stages of its formation. Several studies have investigated the evolution of the solar system within dense stellar environments. For instance, Nordlander et al. 2017 examined the fate of a primordial Oort cloud across different models of the Sun’s birth cluster (low-, intermediate-, and high-mass). They considered the long-term evolution of the cloud, beginning at 100 Myr and extending through the late heavy bombardment phase ( \sim 500 Myr). Their findings suggest that a primordial Oort cloud is unlikely to survive in any of the modelled clusters, with the low-mass cluster providing the most favourable conditions for solar system survival. This supports the hypothesis of a delayed Oort cloud formation ( Brasser & Morbidelli 2013 , e.g.,) . Other authors ( Levison et al. 2010 ; Jílková et al. 2016 ; Pfalzner et al. 2018 ; Hands et al. 2019 , e.g.,) have proposed that portions of the Oort cloud may have been captured through interactions with passing stars while the Sun remained in its birth cluster. Such stellar encounters have also been suggested as a possible origin for distant objects like Sedna. More recently, Wajer et al. 2024a ; Wajer et al. 2024b explored the dynamical evolution of planetesimals initially located in the Jupiter–Saturn region. Their work examined how stellar interactions in the birth cluster could lead to the formation of Sedna-like objects. Their simulations predict the existence of previously undetected classes of sednoids, including very small bodies and retrograde orbiters. The similarities and differences among these studies highlight a central challenge: the uncertainty in the initial conditions of the Sun’s birth cluster and the poorly constrained history of stellar encounters experienced by the early solar system. Table 1: Initial conditions for the Extended and compact models. The first column indicates the model type. The second column lists the initial disk size. The third column shows the initial orbital configuration of the giant planets (Jupiter (J), Saturn (S), Uranus (U), and Neptune (N)). The following columns represent the integration time, the number of stellar encounters ( N_{Enc} ), and the perturber’s distance at closest approach ( q_{\star} ), respectively. Model Disk [au] Planetary configuration [au] Time N_{Enc} q_{\star} [au] Extended 1 40-1000 J:5.2, S:9.5, U:19.2, N:30.1 20 000 yr Single 70 – 400 Extended N 40-1000 J:5.2, S:9.5, U:19.2, N:30.1 100 Myr Multiple Random Compact 1 16–35 J:5.5, S:8.1, N:11.5, U:14.2 20 000 yr Single 70 – 400 Compact N 16–35 J:5.5, S:8.1, N:11.5, U:14.2 100 Myr Multiple Random In their detailed numerical study, Portegies Zwart et al. 2021 provided a comprehensive picture of the chronology underlying the formation and evolution of the Oort cloud. Their simulations indicate that particles with semi-major axes ranging