Global sonde datasets do not support a mesoscale transition in the turbulent energy cascade

Thomas D. DeWitt, Timothy J. Garrett · 2025

Read Global sonde datasets do not support a mesoscale transition in the turbulent energy cascade by Thomas D. DeWitt, Timothy J. Garrett (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-23625.txt.

Introduction

Thomas D. DeWitt and Timothy J. Garrett test a textbook picture of the atmosphere against global weather balloon data. The standard view splits the air into layers of behavior by scale. Broad flows act like flat turbulence, mid-size motions ride gravity waves, and the smallest scales churn in three dimensions. If true, energy spectra should show clear breaks where one regime hands off to the next.

Using dropsonde and radiosonde wind records, the authors compute structure functions across vertical gaps from two hundred meters to eight kilometers, and horizontal gaps up to eighteen hundred kilometers. The measured scaling exponents match none of the three classic regimes. Instead, the data fit a less famous model by Lovejoy and Schertzer, where one anisotropic cascade runs across all scales. The authors argue this single framework could replace the traditional patchwork of scale-by-scale mechanisms.

Catalog record

CREATORThomas D. DeWitt, Timothy J. Garrett
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE51 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-23625

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Global sonde datasets do not support a mesoscale transition in the turbulent energy cascade Thomas D. DeWitt, Timothy J. Garrett Abstract Conceptual and theoretical models describing the dynamics of the atmosphere often assume a hierarchy of dynamic regimes, each operating over some limited range of spatial scales. The largest scales are presumed to be governed by quasi-two-dimensional geostrophic turbulence, mesoscale dynamics by gravity waves, and the smallest scales by 3D isotropic turbulence. In theory, this hierarchy should be observable as clear scale breaks in turbulent kinetic energy spectra as one physical mechanism transitions to the next. Here, we show that this view is not supported by global dropsonde and radiosonde datasets of horizontal winds. Instead, the structure function for horizontal wind calculated for vertical separations between 200 m and 8 km has a Hurst exponent of H v ≈ 0.6 H_{v}\approx 0.6 , which is inconsistent with either gravity waves ( OPEN H v = 1 ) H_{v}=1) or 3D turbulence ( OPEN H v = 1 / 3 ) H_{v}=1/3) . For horizontal separations between 200 km and 1800 km, the Hurst exponent is H h ≈ 0.4 H_{h}\approx 0.4 , which is inconsistent with quasi-geostrophic dynamics ( OPEN H h = 1 ) H_{h}=1) . We argue that sonde observations are most consistent with a lesser known “Lovejoy-Schertzer” model for stratified turbulence where, at all scales, the dynamics of the atmosphere obey a single anisotropic turbulent cascade with H v = 3 / 5 H_{v}=3/5 and H h = 1 / 3 H_{h}=1/3 . While separation scales smaller than 200 m are not explored here due to measurement limitations, the analysis nonetheless supports a single cohesive theoretical framework for describing atmospheric dynamics, one that might substitute for the more traditional hierarchy of mechanisms that depends on spatial scale. Keywords: Atmospheric turbulence, stratified turbulence, structure functions, anisotropic scaling, radiosonde observations, mesoscale dynamics 1 Introduction The dynamics of Earth’s atmosphere are commonly characterized as being governed by three-dimensional Kolmogorov turbulence at the smallest dynamical scales, gravity waves at the mesoscale, and quasi-geostrophic turbulence at the largest scales ( Charney 1971 ; Gage and Nastrom 1986 ; Lindborg 1999 ) . Combined, this “transition” paradigm partitions these regimes according to their respective wavenumber spectra for kinetic energy, where an isotropic -5/3 exponent at small scales (e.g. E\left(k\right)\propto k^{-5/3} ; Kolmogorov 1941 ) gives way to a two-dimensional -3 exponent at large scales (e.g. E\left(k\right)\propto k^{-3} ; Charney 1971 ) . Schertzer and Lovejoy 1985a proposed a very different paradigm that represents the full range of atmospheric scales, from the millimeter to the planetary, as being governed by a single theory of anisotropic turbulence. Here, motions are separable according to the direction of the flow, given that the gravitational force acts in only one direction, rather than the scale of the flow. The spectral exponents were theoretically predicted to be -5/3 in the horizontal and -11/5 in vertical. The challenge observationally has been that aircraft measurements are most easily performed along isobars where the exponents may differ from their isoheight counterparts. When calculated along isobars, both paradigms predict a transition in the spectral exponent from -5/3 to some larger value at scales of hundreds of kilometers. For quasi-geostrophic turbulence, the large-scale isobaric exponent is -3 ( Charney 1971 ) , while for Lovejoy-Schertzer turbulence, it is -2.4 ( Lovejoy et al. 2009 ) . The question of which paradigm is best supported by observed isobaric spectra has been the subject of considerable debate ( Lovejoy et al. 2009 ; Lindborg et al. 2010 ; Frehlich and Sharman 2010 ; Schertzer et al. 2012 ) . Although there is a consensus that some type of transition is present ( Nastrom and Gage 1983 ; Nastrom et al. 1984 ; Nastrom and Gage 1985 ; Gao and Meriwether 1998 ; Cho and Lindborg 2001 ; Wiin-Nielsen 1967 ; Julian et al. 1970 ; Boer and Shepherd 1983 ) , a quantitative analysis that includes a statistical fit to observations is rarely performed, and so it is not possible to conclusively discriminate which theory more closely reflects the true nature of turbulence. Beyond this isobaric debate, the Lovejoy-Schertzer paradigm has been almost entirely overlooked. Setting aside studies by the authors who originated the idea ( Lovejoy et al. 2007 ; Pinel et al. 2012 ) , the key prediction of the directional dependence of the exponent has not been tested – despite it having been proposed 40 years ago. Fundamentally, the dichotomy is between two very different conceptual understandings of how air moves in the atmosphere. The commonly assumed transition paradigm argues that the dynamics are governed by physics that depends on spatial scale, whereas the Lovejoy-Schertzer paradigm proposes a single dynamical mechanism that governs atmospheric dynamics regardless of spatial scale. If the atmosphere can be shown to obey Lovejoy-Schertzer scaling, the tantalizing possibility is offered that observations at one scale and a simple scaling transformation may be all that is necessary to model atmospheric motions at all scales. Determining which paradigm is most closely reflected by observations is the goal of the study presented here. Because the details are not widely known, in Sect. 2 we provide an overview of the theory behind Lovejoy-Schertzer turbulence as well as the various scale-dependent alternatives. Using multiple dropsonde and radiosonde datasets described in Sect. 3 , we test the theoretical predictions made by both paradigms in Sect. 4 . We consider a wide range of scales ranging from 200\,\mathrm{m} to 20,000\,\mathrm{km} with emphasis placed on careful examination of spectra calculated along both the horizontal and vertical directions, the directional dependence being the distinctive prediction of Lovejoy-Schertzer turbulence. 2 Theories of isotropic and anisotropic atmospheric turbulence In general, turbulence laws serve to constrain how kinetic energy is distributed across spatial scales. Although these laws are most commonly represented through the power spectrum E(k) of wind velocities as a function of the wavenumber k , there are other methods for performing a scale decomposition. Here, we consider the “structure function” as it is more robust to irregularly spaced sonde data ( Lovejoy et al. 2007 ) . The structure function may be thought of as a real space version of the wavenumber spectrum where k is replaced by a separation vector \mathbf{\Delta r} of variable length and direction. Turbulence laws often hold for individual components of the wind vector \mathbf{v} , but for simplicity here we only consider the squared magnitude of the vector differences \displaystyle\Delta v^{2}\equiv\left(\mathbf{v}(\mathbf{r})-\mathbf{v}(\mathbf{r}+\mathbf{\Delta r})\right)^{2}. (1) Equation 1 is very general and it points to two basic questions. 1 1 1 A third basic question is how do the statistics of \Delta v^{2} depend on the spatial location \mathbf{r} ? The turbulence theories considered in Table 1 assume translational invariance, i.e. that any statistics do not depend on location. Translational invariance is unlikely in the atmosphere due to, for example, the altitude and latitude dependence of large scale dynamic features such as the jet stream. Here, we only consider velocity increments averaged over many spatial locations. First, how do the statistics of \Delta v^{2} depend on the length of the separation vector \mathbf{\Delta r} ? Second, how do the statistics of \Delta v^{2} depend on the

Read the complete text