The causal interpretation of panel vector autoregressions

Raimondo Pala · 2025

Read The causal interpretation of panel vector autoregressions by Raimondo Pala (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-23540.txt.

Introduction

Raimondo Pala examines what causal claims economists can honestly draw from panel vector autoregressions, a standard tool for data tracked over time across many units. These models link each variable to past values of all the others, and researchers often read the results as cause and effect. Pala shows the honest reading depends on how the causing variable is spread across units.

Depending on that spread, the same model can recover average treatment effects, average causal responses, or a blend of the two. With one extra assumption — no leftover correlation in the errors — and some units serving as controls, the method can identify effects on the treated. Unlike difference-in-differences tools, it places its assumptions on the errors, not the outcomes, and handles units treated only sparsely. Pala illustrates the ideas with weekly data on natural disasters and economic activity in the United States.

Catalog record

CREATORRaimondo Pala
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE82 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-23540

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The causal interpretation of panel vector autoregressions Raimondo Pala Abstract This paper discusses the different contemporaneous causal interpretations of Panel Vector Autoregressions (PVAR). I show that the interpretation of PVARs depends on the distribution of the causing variable, and can range from average treatment effects, to average causal responses, to a combination of the two. If the researcher is willing to postulate a no residual autocorrelation assumption, and some units can be thought of as controls, PVAR can identify average treatment effects on the treated. This method complements the toolkits already present in the literature, such as staggered-DiD, or LP-DiD, as it formulates assumptions in the residuals, and not in the outcome variables. Such a method features a notable advantage: it allows units to be “sparsely” treated, capturing the impact of interventions on the innovation component of the outcome variables. I provide an example related to the evaluation of the effects of natural disasters economic activity at the weekly frequency in the US.I conclude by discussing solutions to potential violations of the SUTVA assumption arising from interference. JEL Classification : C32, C33. Keywords : Vector autoregressive models, panel data, identification, difference in differences. 1 Introduction Panel Vector Autoregressions (PVARs) are widely used across the social sciences because they provide an intuitive framework for estimating impulse response functions in large panel datasets. However, their use for causal inference remains limited, typically confined to notions of Granger causality. Recent advances at the intersection of time-series and causal inference show that traditional estimators can, under suitable conditions, admit causal interpretations in the Rubin causal framework ( Bojinov and Shephard, 2019 ; Menchetti and Bojinov, 2022 ). This paper extends that insight to PVARs. I show that PVARs possess a causal interpretation under the same independence conditions discussed in Rambachan and Shephard, 2021 , and I characterize how the identified causal estimands, such as an Average Treatment Effect (ATE) and Average Causal Response (ACR) depend on the distribution of the policy variable. The most important contribution of this paper is to show that Panel Vector Autoregressions (PVARs) can also be used to conduct causal inference in the presence of endogenous policies. By exploiting their panel structure, the estimation of a PVAR can be reframed as a dynamic comparison between treated and control units. In this sense, PVARs can serve as a useful and complementary tool to Difference-in-Differences (DiD) methods ( Card, 1990 ; Card and Krueger, 1994 ), as well as to their recent extensions such as staggered DiD ( Sun and Abraham, 2021 ) and local-projection DiD ( Dube et al., 2023 ). The key intuition is that if the autoregressive component of the model is capable of absorbing the dynamic effects of treatment, then previously treated units can act as valid controls in subsequent periods. This makes it possible to identify causal effects through the recursive estimation of a PVAR without the need for explicit orthogonality or independence assumptions typically required in other frameworks. This approach also highlights several advantages over conventional DiD estimators. Standard DiD designs usually assume that once a unit is treated, it remains treated forever, restricting the set of possible control observations. Local-projection DiD estimators allow units to re-enter the control group after a certain time, but they impose a specific treatment duration ex ante. PVARs offer a more flexible perspective. Because their identification focuses on the residuals rather than on mean outcome differences, it suffices to examine the distribution of the innovations to address residual autocorrelation. If treated and control units are comparable after controlling for the autoregressive component, the resulting contrasts can be interpreted as an Average Treatment effect on the Treated (ATT). Importantly, this ATT does not arise from direct comparisons of observed outcomes but from differences in the innovation components of treated and untreated units. The paper concludes with an application related to the evaluation of the effects of natural disasters and discussing possible solutions to violations of the SUTVA assumption. Narrative examples are constantly used through the paper to give a proper meaning to the theoretical results, and the discussion is organized as follows. Section 2 discusses a causal framework for PVARs. Section 3 defines different types of causal effects. Section 4 shows that PVARs can estimate an ATE if the policy is a dummy, an ACR if the policy is continuous, a mix of the two if it is continuous and non-negative. Section 5 shows that PVARs can estimate ATT if some units are extracted as controls and there is no residual autocorrelation. Section 6 provides an empirical example of this last result by discussing the causal effect of natural disasters on weekly economic activity in the US. Section 7 discusses non-compliance. Section 8 concludes. 2 Introduction to Panel Vector Autoregressions Consider a number of known interventions and outcomes, respectively indexed by k=1,...,K which could indicate fiscal and monetary policy, and j=1,..,J which could indicate output and employment. A PVAR is generally ran on the aggregation of processes x_{it}=(W_{k=1,it}^{\prime},W_{k=2,it}^{\prime},...,W_{k=K,it}^{\prime},Y_{j=1,it}^{\prime},Y_{j=2,it}^{\prime},..,Y_{j=J,it}^{\prime})^{\prime}, where W_{k,it} is a variable that indicates the treatment value for unit i by a treatment of type k at time t , Y_{j,it} is the outcome variable j for unit i at time t . Panel Vector Autoregressions are generally represented as a process that depends on its past, a series of unit-specific characteristics, and some random disturbances, hence: \displaystyle x_{it}=(I_{m}-\Phi)\mu_{i}+\Phi x_{i,t-1}+\tilde{x}_{it} \displaystyle i=1,..,N\quad t=1,..,T (1) where \Phi denotes an m\times m matrix of slope coefficients 1 1 1 This framework could be extended to random effects instead of fixed effects. However, this change would have no impact on the nature of the causal effects estimated. , \mu_{i} is an m\times 1 vector of individual-specific effects, \tilde{x}_{it} is an m\times 1 vector of disturbances, and I_{m} denotes the identity matrix of dimension m\times m . The model can be extended to include higher lags, but to keep the notation compact I will use a one lag representation. 2 2 2 Any VAR(p) for p>1 can always be represented as a VAR(1). Moreover, through the paper I will make the implicit assumptions that x_{it} is stationary and that the disturbances are assumed to be multivariate iid distributions with mean zero and not necessarily normal. This is because assuming the normality of the distributions could be in opposition to some of the conclusions that will be drawn on the paper. 3 3 3 I will show later that the normality of the distribution of the first variable in the policy column of \widetilde{x}_{it} is just one case over many possible. The focus of the following section will be on the disturbances \tilde{x}_{it}=(\widetilde{W}_{k=1,it}^{\prime},\widetilde{W}_{k=2,it}^{\prime},...,\widetilde{W}_{k=K,it}^{\prime},\widetilde{Y}_{j=1,it}^{\prime},\widetilde{Y}_{j=2,it}^{\prime},..,\widetilde{Y}_{j=J,it}^{\prime})^{\prime}, where the tilde represents the specific disturbance related to the original variable. I will assume that the policy variables go first, and the outcome variables follow. This system is in line with the conventional way of thinking about Vector Autoregressions. For this reason there exists one causal effect that is estimated per j=1,..,J that corresponds to every intervention variable k=1,..,K. Remark 1 . The results that follow can also be obtained from a different system in which the PVAR only includes the outcome variables and which residuals are regressed against a W_{k,it} which has the same distribution as \widetilde{W}_{k,it} . This system

Read the complete text