A Neuro-Symbolic Multi-Agent Approach to Legal–Cybersecurity Knowledge Integration

Chiara Bonfanti, Alessandro Druetto, Cataldo Basile, Tharindu Ranasinghe, Marcos Zampieri · 2025

Read A Neuro-Symbolic Multi-Agent Approach to Legal–Cybersecurity Knowledge Integration by Chiara Bonfanti, Alessandro Druetto, Cataldo Basile, Tharindu Ranasinghe, Marcos Zampieri (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-23443.txt.

Introduction

Chiara Bonfanti, Alessandro Druetto, Cataldo Basile, Tharindu Ranasinghe, and Marcos Zampieri propose a neuro-symbolic multi-agent approach to joining legal and cybersecurity knowledge. Law and cyber security meet in a complex space of cases, statutes, and technical flaws. Standard legal research tools struggle with the nuanced links between them, hindering collaboration between lawyers and security experts.

Their system aims to navigate the cyber-legal domain, combining neural methods with symbolic structure and multiple agents. First results on multilingual tasks are promising. Better integration could speed incident response where legal duties and technical facts collide.

Catalog record

CREATORChiara Bonfanti, Alessandro Druetto, Cataldo Basile, Tharindu Ranasinghe, Marcos Zampieri
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE14 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-23443

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A Neuro-Symbolic Multi-Agent Approach to Legal–Cybersecurity Knowledge Integration Chiara Bonfanti, Alessandro Druetto, Cataldo Basile, Tharindu Ranasinghe, Marcos Zampieri Abstract The growing intersection of cybersecurity and law creates a complex information space where traditional legal research tools struggle to deal with nuanced connections between cases, statutes, and technical vulnerabilities. This knowledge divide hinders collaboration between legal experts and cybersecurity professionals. To address this important gap, this work provides a first step towards intelligent systems capable of navigating the increasingly intricate cyber-legal domain. We demonstrate promising initial results on multilingual tasks. keywords Cybersecurity, Legal Informatics, NLP, European Digital Law, Case Retrieval, Hybrid Architectures Introduction As cyber threats become more sophisticated, a significant knowledge gap emerges between two essential domains: legal experts who lack a deep technical understanding of cybersecurity mechanisms, and technical professionals who are unfamiliar with legal doctrine and jurisprudential reasoning [ 1 , 2 ] . This divide impedes compliance and raises operational risk. Automated approaches are therefore needed to bridge legal and technical domains in a way that is both reliable and interpretable. Existing methods remain limited: keyword-based retrieval often fails to capture the semantic links between legal norms and attack patterns, while neural models such as large language models (LLMs) provide richer semantics but lack transparency and may introduce errors through hallucination [ 3 ] . Recent work has advanced the extraction of deontic obligations from EU regulations [ 4 ] , yet the technical dimensions of cybersecurity remain largely unaddressed. We propose a neuro-symbolic multi-agent framework that explicitly links legal obligations to technical documentation, including, but not limited to, the NIST Special Publications and the MITRE resources, which are widely de facto standards in cybersecurity [ 5 ] . These mappings are integrated into a knowledge graph that supports retrieval and reasoning through reinforcement learning and Belief–Desire–Intention (BDI) agents [ 6 ] . By combining knowledge graph reasoning with rule-based classification, the framework achieves a level of explainability and auditability often absent in purely neural approaches. To our knowledge, this work is among the first systems to make machine-readable the connections between legal obligations and cybersecurity concepts, enabling transparent and traceable reasoning for both legal practitioners and technical experts. Background The CEPS-ZENNER dataset. Within the landscape of European legal resources, the CEPS–Zenner dataset occupies a distinctive position [ 7 ] . Earlier corpora, such as EUR-Lex and the JRC-Acquis [ 8 ] , and MetaLex [ 9 , 10 ] , have primarily concentrated on legislative texts and multilingual access. At the same time, initiatives such as Akoma Ntoso [ 11 ] , the European Legislation Identifier (ELI) [ 12 ] , and LegalRuleML [ 13 ] have focused on machine-readable representations of statutes. Within AI & Law, a rich body of work has explored legal ontologies and structured knowledge representation [ 10 , 14 ] , argumentation-based reasoning [ 1 ] , and normative multi-agent systems [ 15 ] , demonstrating the importance of modelling institutions and their rules. CEPS-Zenner systematically maps digital policy measures enacted, proposed, and planned with the governance bodies responsible for implementation. This institutional and temporal perspective is critical for domains such as cybersecurity, where regulatory obligations intersect with technical enforcement. While originally curated for policy analysis and lacking alignment with semantic standards, CEPS-Zenner provides a challenging and valuable substrate for multilingual, neuro-symbolic, multi-agent experiments. While CEPS-Zenner was curated for policy analysis rather than computational use, and lacks alignment with semantic standards such as Akoma Ntoso or LegalRuleML, these very limitations make it a challenging yet valuable field for experiments with our multilingual, neuro-symbolic multi-agent framework. Cybersecurity technical documentation. The cybersecurity roles that usually interface with legal informatics are Chief Information Security Officers, senior cybersecurity designers, and analysts. Legal frameworks, especially those that focus on compliance (e.g., the EU GDPR and NIS2), require that the cybersecurity risks are kept under a tolerable level. One fundamental step these roles must perform is to map the high-level legal constraints to the threats that can increase the risks and the mitigations that could lower them again to acceptable levels. To this purpose, the most relevant and structured results have been produced by the Mitre Corporation, ATT&CK 1 1 1 https://attack.mitre.org/resources/attack-data-and-tools/ , which describes adversary tactics and techniques, and D3FEND 2 2 2 https://d3fend.mitre.org/resources/ , which details defensive techniques and technologies to counter malicious cyber threats. AI and Automation in Legal Informatics. Integrating AI into legal informatics has seen significant advancements, particularly in automating tasks such as contract analysis, compliance monitoring, and case prediction. However, challenges persist in bridging the gap between legal reasoning and technical processes. Recent studies highlight the potential of AI agents to enhance legal workflows, though human oversight remains essential due to concerns over AI errors and “hallucinations” [ 1 , 3 ] . This underscores the necessity for AI systems that are both effective and interpretable within legal contexts. Knowledge Representation and Reasoning. Traditional knowledge representation in legal informatics has focused on formalizing legal norms using frameworks such as LegalRuleML and Akoma Ntoso, but these often lack integration with real-world data and dynamic reasoning capabilities [ 13 , 11 , 10 , 14 ] . Recent approaches leverage reinforcement learning, e.g., information-gain-based rewards in LLMs, to enable more flexible and robust legal reasoning [ 16 ] . Reinforcement Learning. RL has been applied to various aspects of legal information retrieval. For example, the Reinforced-IR framework employs a self-boosting mechanism to adapt pre-trained retrievers and generators for precise cross-domain retrieval [ 17 ] . Additionally, beam search techniques have been utilized in legal case retrieval to efficiently generate relevant case identifiers, accommodating the hierarchical nature of legal structures [ 18 ] . These methods enhance the accuracy and efficiency of legal information retrieval systems. Beam Search. Beam search [ 19 ] is a heuristic search algorithm widely used for approximate decoding in sequence generation tasks, such as machine translation [ 20 ] and speech recognition. It extends the greedy search strategy by maintaining a fixed number of the most promising partial hypotheses, rather than committing to the single best candidate. By exploring multiple alternatives simultaneously, beam search balances search efficiency and output quality, enabling models to capture better global structures without incurring the computational cost of exhaustive search. Explainable AI and Agentic AI in legal informatics. Explainability is a central concern in legal AI, given judicial demands for transparent and interpretable decisions [ 21 ] . Agent-based architectures enhance transparency and accountability in legal reasoning [ 15 ] , supporting explainable decision-making in line with legal requirements for fairness. The pipeline Figure 1: Illustration of the pipeline. The input legal document is first processed by a classification layer (RAG with Chroma DB embeddings) using MITRE labels. A BDI agent evaluates the classification, and the results are used to construct an inference graph. An RL agent with beam search performs information retrieval, which is further assessed by the Judge agent. Light-blue arrows indicate data flow, while red highlights the Judge agent’s evaluations. Our approach is summarized in Figure 1 . Dataset Webscraping The CEPS-Zenner PDF [ 7 ] was processed to extract EUR-Lex legal document links using PyMuPDF. The pipeline automatically downloads language-specific PDFs via HTML parsing with BeautifulSoup, organizes them in a

Read the complete text