On the choking mechanism in supersonic ejectors: a one-dimensional analysis of Reynolds-Averaged Navier Stokes simulations

Jan Van den Berghe 1,2, Miguel A. Mendez 1,3,4, Yann Bartosiewicz 2 · 2025

Read On the choking mechanism in supersonic ejectors: a one-dimensional analysis of Reynolds-Averaged Navier Stokes simulations by Jan Van den Berghe 1,2, Miguel A. Mendez 1,3,4, Yann Bartosiewicz 2 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-23385.txt.

Introduction

Jan Van den Berghe, Miguel A Mendez, and Yann Bartosiewicz analyze choking inside supersonic ejectors with a one-dimensional framework checked against detailed simulations. Ejectors are passive devices that compress a secondary stream with no moving parts, used in refrigeration and propulsion. Two rival mechanisms, Fabri and compound choking, have been proposed.

The authors build both in one model and compare with simulation data averaged across sections. The compound form includes wall and inter-stream friction and local pressure balance. Settling the mechanism improves design rules for these simple, reliable compressors.

Catalog record

CREATORJan Van den Berghe 1,2, Miguel A. Mendez 1,3,4, Yann Bartosiewicz 2
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE96 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-23385

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

On the choking mechanism in supersonic ejectors: a one-dimensional analysis of Reynolds-Averaged Navier Stokes simulations Jan Van den Berghe 1,2, Miguel A. Mendez 1,3,4, Yann Bartosiewicz 2 Abstract Ejectors are passive devices used in refrigeration, propulsion, and process industries to compress a secondary stream without moving parts. The engineering modeling of choking in these devices remains an open question, with two mechanisms—Fabri and compound choking—proposed in the literature. This work develops a unified one-dimensional framework that implements both mechanisms and compares them with axisymmetric Reynolds-Averaged Navier Stokes (RANS) data processed by cross-sectional averaging. The compound formulation incorporates wall and inter-stream friction and a local pressure-equalization procedure that enables stable integration through the sonic point, together with a normal-shock reconstruction. The Fabri formulation is assessed by imposing the dividing streamline extracted from RANS, isolating the sonic condition while avoiding additional modeling assumptions. The calibrated compound model predicts on-design secondary mass flow typically within 2% with respect to the RANS simulations, rising to 5% for a strongly under-expanded primary jet due to the equal-pressure constraint. The Fabri analysis attains less than 1% error in on-design entrainment but exhibits high sensitivity to the dividing streamline and closure, which limits predictive use beyond on-design. Overall, the results show that Fabri and compound mechanisms can coexist within the same device and operating map, each capturing distinct aspects of the physics and offering complementary modeling value. Nevertheless, compound choking emerges as the more general mechanism governing flow rate blockage, as evidenced by choked flows with a subsonic secondary stream. keywords shear layers, gas dynamics † † affiliation: 1 von Karman Institute for Fluid Dynamics, 1640 Sint-Genesius-Rode, Belgium 2 Institute of Mechanics, Materials, and Civil Engineering (iMMC), Université catholique de Louvain (UCLouvain), 1348 Louvain-la-Neuve, Belgium 3 Aero-Thermo-Mechanics Laboratory, Université Libre de Bruxelles, Elsene, Brussels, 1050, Belgium 4 Aerospace Engineering Research Group, Universidad Carlos III de Madrid,Leganés, 28911, Spain 1 Introduction Ejectors are fluid dynamic devices that utilize a high-speed primary jet to entrain and compress a secondary flow without moving parts. These are widely used in refrigeration, propulsion and chemical processes because of their simplicity and robustness (see for example the review by Aidoun et al. 2019 ). The maximum achievable entrainment of the secondary stream for a given set of inlet conditions is defined by the choked operating regime, which is thus of particular importance. This regime is characterized by the critical back pressure—a threshold below which the secondary mass flow rate becomes insensitive to further reductions in downstream pressure. Ejectors are usually designed to operate in these choked conditions to maximize entrainment efficiency, prevent flow reversal, and ensure stable and robust performance against fluctuations in back pressure. The choked behavior is analogous to that of a converging-diverging nozzle, where choking occurs when the flow reaches unitary Mach at the throat. Unlike a nozzle, however, the presence of entrainment and mixing complicates the identification of a geometric location or a single Mach number criterion for the onset of choking. Instead, choking in ejectors arises from the complex interaction between the primary and secondary streams and the evolving flow within the mixing chamber and diffuser. Two main theories have been proposed to explain the choking mechanism by postulating different sonic conditions in the two streams: the Fabri theory and the compound theory. The Fabri theory, introduced in the seminal work of Fabri & Siestrunck 1958 , treats the sonic conditions of the primary and secondary streams as independent. According to this theory, an ejector is considered choked when each stream individually attains Mach 1 at its respective throat, while accounting for the expansion of the primary stream within the mixing section. In contrast, the compound choking theory, originally proposed by Pearson et al. 1958 and subsequently refined by Hoge & Segars 1965 and Bernstein et al. 1967 , defines choking as a compound sonic condition in which the two streams are dynamically coupled. Under this framework, choking may occur even if one of the streams remains subsonic throughout the mixing chamber. To date, neither theory has been definitively proven superior or more general than the other. Computational fluid dynamics (CFD) has made it possible to reproduce the mass-flow limitations observed in ejectors (e.g., the simulations of Bartosiewicz et al. 2005 and Hemidi et al. 2009 ), but these simulations have not provided conclusive evidence in favor of one choking mechanism over the other. In fact, both types of behavior have been reported in the literature: Lamberts et al. 2018a ; Lamberts et al. 2018b documented cases consistent with Fabri choking as well as cases exhibiting compound choking. The sonic line clearly penetrates the core of the secondary stream in the first case, while it stays within the shear layer between the streams in the latter case. These results suggest that the compound theory can be overruled depending on the operating conditions and that both mechanisms may even be active simultaneously. The works of Hoge & Segars 1965 and Debroeyer et al. 2025 show that higher ratios of primary to secondary total pressures tend to favor Fabri choking. A possible explanation is the increasingly under-expanded nature of the primary stream, which results in stronger expansion within the mixing chamber and thus a restriction of the secondary stream akin to the throat of a converging–diverging nozzle. On the other hand, lower inlet pressure ratios tend to produce over-expanded primary flows, which contract in the mixing channel and hence leave more space for the secondary stream, which then remains subsonic throughout. Wall friction has also been shown to play an important role: Kracik & Dvorak 2023 numerically showed that smooth walls led to Fabri choking, while rough walls resulted in compound choking under the same operating conditions. However, the mechanism behind this switch remains poorly understood. Historically, the Fabri condition has been the most widely used in integral 0D models, with a long lineage of developments from the 1940s to recent years (see Keenan & Neumann 1942 ; Fabri & Siestrunck 1958 ; Huang et al. 1999 ; Chen et al. 2013 , to name but a few). In contrast, the compound flow theory has only gained attention more recently (see Metsue et al. 2021 ; Croquer et al. 2021 ; Zhu et al. 2024 ). Notably, Croquer et al. 2021 reported a reduction in prediction error from 17% with the Fabri theory to 5% using the compound theory. While this might suggest a superiority of the compound theory, it is important to note that 0D models rely heavily on the calibration of efficiency coefficients. A comprehensive analysis of the choking mechanism requires, at minimum, one-dimensional models capable of capturing the underlying wave propagation phenomena. These models formulate the conservation of mass, momentum, and energy for cross-section–averaged flow quantities, with the objective of reproducing their streamwise distribution under prescribed ejector operating conditions. However, as discussed in section 2 , such models are not intrinsically closed: either the static pressures or the cross-sectional areas of the two streams must be specified at each station. A traditional approach to render the compound choking theory predictive is to assume equal static pressure in both streams throughout the mixing region. This assumption implies planar pressure waves and equal propagation velocities in the two streams,

Read the complete text