Network Intrusion Detection: Evolution from Conventional Approaches to LLM Collaboration and Emerging Risks
Yaokai Feng, Kouichi Sakurai · 2025
Read Network Intrusion Detection: Evolution from Conventional Approaches to LLM Collaboration and Emerging Risks by Yaokai Feng, Kouichi Sakurai (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-23313.txt.
Introduction
Yaokai Feng and Kouichi Sakurai survey network intrusion detection from classic methods to collaboration with large language models. Signature-based and neural network detectors each have known strengths and limits. Recent work adds language models to the mix, promising better reading of logs and alerts.
The survey summarizes current status and limits, then reviews language model integrations across conventional networks, autonomous vehicles, and Internet of Things settings. It also flags emerging risks that the models themselves bring. Security teams get a concise map of where AI help is real and where it creates new exposure.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Yaokai Feng, Kouichi Sakurai |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 98 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-23313
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Network Intrusion Detection: Evolution from Conventional Approaches to LLM Collaboration and Emerging Risks Yaokai Feng, Kouichi Sakurai Abstract This survey systematizes the evolution of network intrusion detection systems (NIDS), from conventional methods such as signature-based and neural network (NN)-based approaches to recent integrations with large language models (LLMs). It clearly and concisely summarizes the current status, strengths, and limitations of conventional techniques, and explores the practical benefits of integrating LLMs into NIDS. Recent research on the application of LLMs to NIDS in diverse environments is reviewed, including conventional network infrastructures, autonomous vehicle environments and IoT environments. From this survey, readers will learn that: 1) the earliest methods, signature-based IDSs, continue to make significant contributions to modern systems, despite their well-known weaknesses; 2) NN-based detection, although considered promising and under development for more than two decades, and despite numerous related approaches, still faces significant challenges in practical deployment; 3) LLMs are useful for NIDS in many cases, and a number of related approaches have been proposed; however, they still face significant challenges in practical applications. Moreover, they can even be exploited as offensive tools, such as for generating malware, crafting phishing messages, or launching cyberattacks. Recently, several studies have been proposed to address these challenges, which are also reviewed in this survey; and 4) strategies for constructing domain-specific LLMs have been proposed and are outlined in this survey, as it is nearly impossible to train a NIDS-specific LLM from scratch. I Structure of This Survey Paper This survey focuses on existing studies of Network Intrusion Detection Systems (NIDS), tracing its evolution from the earliest signature-based methods to neural network (NN)-based approaches, and finally to the latest developments involving cooperation with large language models (LLMs). The strengths, limitations, and current status of each type of method are clearly and concisely summarized, with references to representative studies. This survey also reviews recent studies that aim to mitigate the challenges of LLMs when utilized in NIDS. Additionally, it examines cases where LLMs have been exploited as offensive tools. Since the scope of this survey is broad, a structural outline of the contents is provided in Figure 1 to help readers grasp the overall organization. Fig. 1: Structure of This Survey Paper. II Signature-Based Network Intrusion Detection: Current Trends and Limitations Signature-based NIDSs remain one of the most fundamental and widely deployed approaches in network security. They rely on predefined rules or signatures that describe known attack patterns, allowing high-accuracy detection of previously observed threats. One of the most representative tools in this category is Snort [ 1 ] (1999), developed by Martin Roesch in 1998 and currently being maintained by Cisco. Its role has evolved from being a standalone IDS tool in the early 2000s to becoming a component within larger, integrated security solutions. As of 2025, it continues to be actively developed and maintained by Cisco Systems. The latest version, Snort 3 released around 2021, is now a standard feature of Cisco Secure Firewall Threat Defense (FTD) and serves as the engine for commercial firewall [ 2 ] . In other words, Snort remains not only a standalone tool but also a core technology within Cisco’s commercial security offerings. Two other well-known systems are Suricata [ 3 ] and Zeek (formerly Bro) [ 4 ] . Suricata was developed by OISF (the Open Information Security Foundation) in 2009 and its latest version 8.0.1 was released on September 16, 2025. It offers advantages such as multithreaded processing, automatic protocol detection, trying to enable higher throughput and scalability for modern high-speed networks. In contrast to the strictly signature-based operation of Snort and Suricata, Zeek was originally developed by Vern Paxson [ 5 ] (1999) and its latest version is 8.0.3 [ 4 ] , released on October 15, 2025. It adopts an event-driven and behavior-based approach, providing richer contextual information beyond simple signature matching. In addition, integrated frameworks such as Security Onion [ 6 ] combine multiple open-source components including Snort, Suricata, Zeek, and OSSEC (Open Source Security Event Correlator) to provide both network-based and host-based intrusion detection capabilities within a unified monitoring and incident response platform, in which OSSEC functions as a host-based IDS (HIDS), focusing on log analysis, file integrity monitoring, and rootkit detection. The primary strength of the signature-based IDS is their high accuracy and low false-positive rate when dealing with known threats. Although it has had a long history and still used in modern systems as mentioned above, many studies have mentioned its limitations [ 7 ] (2025), [ 8 ] (2022), [ 9 ] (2025), [ 10 ] (2025), [ 11 ] (2015) and [ 12 ] (2025). The main limitations are summarized as follows. II- 1 Inability to detect unknown (zero-day) attacks This is because it tries to find intrusions by simply matching. II- 2 Vulnerability to evasion and obfuscation techniques Attackers can evade signature matching by encrypting or encoding payloads; II- 3 High maintenance and operational costs (delayed signature updates) To remain effective, signature databases must be continuously updated and tested using threat intelligence. Delays or errors in updates can lead to security gaps or false detections [ 12 ] (2025); II- 4 High risk of false positives and false negatives Signature-based systems may generate false alerts by matching benign traffic with similar patterns (false positives), while failing to detect modified or variant attacks (false negatives); II- 5 Scalability and performance limitations Matching a large number of signatures in real time across large-scale networks imposes a heavy computational burden. In high-throughput environments, this can lead to delays or missed detections; II- 6 Difficulty in capturing attack context Attack chains or multi-phase attacks often form attack context. Because signature matching is based on isolated patterns, it is difficult to correlate and detect the full life-cycle of an attack, such as reconnaissance\to intrusion\to lateralmovement . Each stage may look benign in isolation [ 11 ] (2015) and [ 12 ] (2025). To overcome these limitations, hybrid and anomaly-based IDSs incorporating machine learning and deep learning models have emerged since the mid-2010s, combining the interpretability of rule-based systems with the adaptability of data-driven detection. Nonetheless, signature-based approaches remain a critical foundation for network defense infrastructures due to their transparency, stability, and operational maturity. III Neural Network-based Network Intrusion Detection: Capabilities and Limitations Due to the above-mentioned limitations of signature-based IDSs, NN-based detection has attracted significant research interest, with numerous models proposed over the past two decades. There also have been many survey papers on NN-based IDS technologies. Here, we provide a brief overview organized by categories such as single-model approaches, ensemble methods, temporal sequential models, and explainable models. III-A Single NN Model-Based Approaches In the early days of using neural network (NN)-based models, researchers attempted to implement intrusion detection systems (IDS) using single NN models, starting with a single MLP (Multi-Layer Perceptron) model. [ 13 ] (2001) trained a backpropagation neural network (of the MLP type) to detect novel attacks (anomaly detection)—they showed how to train neural networks to generalize to previously unseen attack patterns and discussed the issues of feature design and generalization in intrusion detection systems. [ 14 ] (2002) empirically compared NN models (MLP/backpropagation) and SVMs (Support Vector Machines) to achieve high accuracy on the KDD/DARPA benchmark; they