Drivers of Variation in the Optimal Spatial Structure of Collective Information Gatherers

Ross S. Walker, Gabriel Ramos-Fernandez, Denis Boyer, Sandra E. Smith-Aguilar, Xander O’Neill, Matthew J. Silk · 2025

Read Drivers of Variation in the Optimal Spatial Structure of Collective Information Gatherers by Ross S. Walker, Gabriel Ramos-Fernandez, Denis Boyer, Sandra E. Smith-Aguilar, Xander O’Neill, Matthew J. Silk (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-23297.txt.

Introduction

R S Walker and five co-authors study how groups that gather and share information should spread out in space. Such collectives thrive in nature, from animal groups to swarm robots, when conditions vary across space and time. The best spatial layout depends on how information is found and passed along.

The authors develop a mathematical model of collective information gatherers and ask which structure maximizes group performance. Their results link environmental variation to optimal spacing and connection. Designers of robot swarms and ecologists alike can use the findings to predict when groups should cluster, disperse, or form networks.

Catalog record

CREATORRoss S. Walker, Gabriel Ramos-Fernandez, Denis Boyer, Sandra E. Smith-Aguilar, Xander O’Neill, Matthew J. Silk
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE57 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-23297

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Drivers of Variation in the Optimal Spatial Structure of Collective Information Gatherers Ross S. Walker, Gabriel Ramos-Fernandez, Denis Boyer, Sandra E. Smith-Aguilar, Xander O’Neill, Matthew J. Silk Abstract Collective systems that self-organise to maximise the group’s ability to collect and distribute information can be successful in environments with high spatial and temporal variation. Such organisations are abundant in nature, as sharing information is a key benefit of many biological collective systems, and have been influential in the design of many artificial collectives such as swarm robotics. Understanding how these systems may be spatially distributed to optimise their collective potential is therefore of importance in both ecology and in collective systems design. Here, we develop a mathematical model which uses an optimisation framework to determine the higher-order spatial structure of a collective that optimises group-level knowledge transfer. The domain of the objective function is a set of weighted simplicial sets, which can fully represent the spatial structure from a topological perspective. By varying the parameters within the objective function and the constraints, we determine how the optimal spatial structure may vary when individuals differ in their information gathering ability and how this variation differs in the context of resource constraints. Our key findings are that the amount of resources in the environment can lead to specific subgroup sizes being optimal for the group as a whole when individuals are homogeneous in their information gathering abilities. Further, when there is variation in information gathering abilities, our model implies that the sharing of space between smaller subgroups of the population, rather than the whole population, is optimal for collective knowledge sharing. Our results have applications across diverse contexts from behavioural ecology to bio-inspired collective systems design. Key words: Collective intelligence, quadratic integer optimisation, spatial structure, higher-order structure, foraging, swarm robotics \DeclareSourcemap \maps [datatype=bibtex] \map \step [fieldset=issn, null] \step [fieldset=isbn, null] \step [fieldset=month, null] \step [fieldset=language, null] \step [fieldset=number, null] 1 Introduction Diverse natural and artificial systems are organised to optimise the transfer and distribution of information across a group of individuals. Collectively intelligent systems such as robot swarms, characterised by a lack of central control, simple movement rules and local interaction patterns, are increasingly used across multiple complex applications [ 1 ] , such as environmental monitoring [ 2 ] , targeted drug delivery [ 3 ] and space exploration [ 4 ] . Many of these artificial systems, designed for collection and distribution of information in complex, heterogeneous environments, are directly inspired by animal systems (such as eusocial insects; [ 1 , 3 , 5 ] ). In these animal systems, information sharing is one of the key drivers of group-living [ 6 , 7 ] . While group-living comes with a variety of associated costs, such as increased competition for resources [ 8 ] and risk of pathogen transmission [ 9 , 10 ] , these costs are mitigated through the many benefits of group-living [ 11 , 12 , 13 ] , one of which is the sharing of foraging information [ 14 , 15 ] . The sharing of foraging knowledge among conspecifics is an especially significant benefit of group-living for species living in highly heterogeneous environments with a high degree of spatial and temporal variation in the quality of feeding sites [ 15 , 16 , 17 , 18 , 19 , 20 ] (e.g. tropical forests for frugivorous species [ 21 ] ). In such systems, the pooling of knowledge between conspecifics facilitates a more complete tracking of the current foraging environment than what individuals could manage on their own [ 20 , 22 , 23 ] . Information sharing between individuals in a collective system can take a variety of forms. In swarm robotics, for example, individuals transmit their current knowledge through short-distance signals, requiring spatial proximity [ 1 ] . In animal systems, information sharing can take a wide variety of forms, such as vocalisations (e.g. in meerkats ( Suricata suricatta ); [ 24 ] ), observation (e.g. in guppies ( Poecilia reticulata ) [ 25 ] ) or following (e.g. in hooded crows ( Poecilia reticulata ); [ 26 ] ), and can be either active/intentional or passive/involuntary. In each of these cases, information transfer could potentially be costly to individuals in the short-term (due to resource sharing), but this cost can be tolerated for future reciprocity [ 27 , 28 ] (depending upon total resource availability, which may determine the effective benefit of less cooperative strategies; we may expect weaker kin selection in systems with high within-group competition for resources). Spatial proximity is typically required for information sharing in many animal species, which suggests that the spatial distribution of the collective is of intrinsic importance in the efficiency of such sharing. Therefore, some spatial structures may promote more effective information processing than others in collective systems. Given that there is a relationship between space sharing and information processing, it is reasonable to suggest that different spatial structures may promote more effective information processing in collective systems. Key pre-existing ecological hypotheses relating spatial structure and information processing are the recruitment centre hypothesis [ 6 ] and information centre hypothesis [ 6 , 29 ] , which both propose that spatial congregations, typically including all group members in a shared central area, allow for effective collective information processing, in turn allowing the group to be more adaptive to ecological and environmental variation. However, to the best of our knowledge, it is currently an open question which spatial structures are optimal for collective information processing. One important aspect of natural collectives is within-group heterogeneity in group foraging abilities, which we may expect particularly in an ecological context (although see [ 30 ] ). In animal systems, there may be variation in individual abilities to move [ 31 ] , or willingness to gather or provide information [ 32 ] , which translate to variation in abilities to forage or gather other kinds of information. Many factors may influence this variation, such as differences in metabolic rate [ 33 ] , cognitive ability [ 34 , 35 ] , social position [ 36 , 37 , 38 ] , social affinities [ 31 ] , personality [ 39 ] , age [ 40 , 41 ] or sex [ 42 , 43 ] . If the group is to organise to maximise their collective potential for information sharing, then these heterogeneities should be accounted for. Such an optimal organisation might be expected when the individual benefits of information sharing outweigh the costs [ 44 , 45 , 46 ] , with the importance of this (specifically collective) optimisation enhanced when multilevel selection acts on group-level benefits and we expect kin selection [ 47 , 48 ] . For example, under the optimal strategy for the group as a whole, a forager with greater foraging abilities than the rest of the group may share more information than others, possibly leading to the costs of this behaviour outweighing the benefits for said individual. In such a scenario, we may not expect the (group-level) optimal structure to evolve due to unequal distribution of individual-level costs, and the forager with greater foraging abilities may even seek out a different group, or

Read the complete text