The Generalized Second Law and the Spatial Curvature Index
Diego Pavón · 2025
Read The Generalized Second Law and the Spatial Curvature Index by Diego Pavón (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-23248.txt.
Introduction
Diego Pavon applies the generalized second law of thermodynamics to the apparent horizon of a smooth, isotropic universe. He requires that the equation of state stays no less than minus one, ruling out phantom energy. Combined with the dominant energy condition, the law sorts universes by their spatial shape.
Flat and closed cosmos models pass both the law and the dominant energy condition together. Open models with hyperbolic space, he finds, do not. The argument uses only broad thermodynamic and energy principles, not a named gravity model. It gives cosmologists a simple check on the global shape the cosmos can take.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Diego Pavón |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 12 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-23248
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The Generalized Second Law and the Spatial Curvature Index Diego Pavón Abstract By applying the generalized second law to the apparent horizon of a homogeneous and isotropic universe and imposing that the equation of state is no less than − 1 -1 , it is seen that universes with either flat or closed spatial sections are consistent with the joint consideration of the aforesaid law and the dominant energy condition, but not so universes with hyperbolic spatial sections. 1 I Introduction Modern cosmology is mostly based on the cosmological principle; it asserts that our universe is homogeneous and isotropic in the large scale average. By “large scale” we mean scales larger than the biggest galaxy superclusters. Nearly a century ago, Robertson robertson and Walker walker derived the most general line element that satisfies the aforesaid principle and does not depend on any gravity theory. In comoving polar coordinates it takes the form ds^{2}=-dt^{2}+a^{2}(t)\left[\frac{dr^{2}}{1-kr^{2}}+r^{2}(d\theta^{2}+\sin^{2}\theta d\phi^{2})\right], (1) where a(t) is the scale factor and k the curvature index. The latter is either -1 , 0 or +1 depending on whether the spatial sections of our universe are hyperbolic, flat or closed, respectively. Tests of the cosmological principle have been carried out for many years using different observational techniques, on the isotropy side, see e.g. ellis1984 ; kitching2014 ; bengaly2019 ; guandalin2023 ; dinda2025 , and on the homogeneity side as well, see for instance clarkson2008 ; clarkson2010 ; zhang2011 ; camarena2021 . Nowadays, according to the general consensus, the aforesaid principle is, at large scales, a very good approximation to the real universe; see, however, pietronero1998 and references therein. As for the spatial curvature, evaluated by the dimensionless curvature parameter \Omega_{k}=-k/(a^{2}H^{2}) where H=\dot{a}/a is the Hubble factor, the overall agreement is that its absolute value is very small, if not nil (see, e.g. denissenya2018 ; divalentino2020 ; handley2021 ; bel2022 ; yang2023 ). This is very reasonable since measurements of the present value of the spatial curvature, based on specific, reasonable, cosmological models, suggest that today its absolute value is of the order of \;10^{-2} or even less, i.e. \;\Omega_{k0}\simeq 0 1 1 1 A sub-zero attached to any quantity refers to its present value. . It is natural given the evolution of \Omega_{k} with accelerated expansion since \Omega_{k} and {\Omega}^{\prime}_{k} (where a prime means d/da ) bear opposite signs. Consequently, its present value, whatever the initial one was at the beginning of the acceleration, is bound to be close to zero and it will more so at later times. This implies that observationally it is very difficult to discard any of the three possible values of the curvature index. The aim of this short paper is precisely to eliminate one of them by means of theoretical arguments only. These just involve Einstein gravity, the dominant energy condition (DEC) and and the generalized second law (GSL). Therefore our reasoning does not rest on any particular model. As it turns out, universes with hyperbolic spatial sections, i.e. k=-1 , should be discarded. We present our arguments in the next section and discuss them in the last one. In our units c=G=1 . II Combining the DEC and GSL Let us begin by considering an ever-expanding, homogeneous and isotropic universe that obeys Einstein gravity. Thus we can write, 3H^{2}+3\frac{k}{a^{2}}=8\pi\rho (2) and \dot{\rho}+3H(\rho+p)=0, (3) where \rho is the total energy density, i.e., radiation, matter (luminous and dark) and dark energy, and p the total pressure. The cosmic equation of state is defined as w=p/\rho and depends on the scale factor only. Now the question arises: Which are the limits, from above and from below of w ? The first one is given by the requirement that the speed of sound, \sqrt{\partial p/\partial\rho} , does not exceed the speed of light. So, w\leq 1 . Unfortunately a parallel reasoning cannot be applied to derive the lower limit since it can be negative, as it is the case when the universe is dominated by dark energy. Here we recall how straightforwardly the lower limit of w can be determined with the help of the DEC wald1984 ; eric2004 . In the present context the latter boils down to \rho>0 alongside \rho+p\geq 0 . Thus, the lower bound w\geq-1 (4) on the cosmic equation of state readily emerges. Next, we will see that the GSL alone does not restrict the sign of k . We proceed as follows. Equations ( 2 ) and ( 3 ) taken together produce w=-\frac{1}{1-\Omega_{k}}\left[1+\frac{2}{3}\frac{\dot{H}}{H^{2}}+\frac{1}{3}\Omega_{k}\right], (5) where \mid\Omega_{k}\mid<1 . Note that this expression is valid regardless the various matter-energy species interact with each other or not. Clearly w will be as low as -1 whenever H remains constant and \Omega_{k}=0 . Now, we may ask: Will w also have a lower limit when k\neq 0 ? The answer is yes provided that the GSL for cosmic horizons Davies1987 ; dpc ; dpc1 ; dpc2 holds. To see this recalls that the deceleration parameter is given by q=-1-(\dot{H}/H^{2}) , Then we can express ( 5 ) in terms of the said parameter w=-\frac{1-2q+\Omega_{k}}{3(1-\Omega_{k})}. (6) The GSL implies that the area of the apparent horizon 2 2 2 The boundary hyper-surface of the space-time anti-trapped region. , {\cal{A}}=4\pi/[H^{2}+ka^{-2}] , never decreases in a expanding universe bak-rey2000 . That is to say, {\cal{A}^{\prime}}=-({\cal{A}}^{2}/2\pi)(HH^{\prime}-ka^{-3})\geq 0 . This readily translates into 1+q\geq\Omega_{k} npd2023a ; npd2023b . Using this in Eq. ( 6 ) it follows w\geq\zeta , where \zeta=\frac{\textstyle{1\over{3}}\Omega_{k}-1}{1-\Omega_{k}} (7) is the lower limit of the cosmic equation of state, w , valid at any redshift. Notice that for flat universes with De Sitter expansion \zeta reduces to -1 , as it should, and that for \Omega_{k}>0 this limit gets less than -1 (while w\geq-1 ) and diverges for \Omega_{k}\rightarrow 1 . This leads us to suspect that \Omega_{k} may not be positive even though it is compatible with the GSL and DEC when taken separately. This prompt us to combine one with the other to see whether there is nothing wrong with \,\Omega_{k}>0 , nonetheless. To this end we proceed as follows. The simplest linear combination of w\geq-1 and w\geq\zeta is, (1+\lambda)w\geq-1+\lambda\left(\frac{\textstyle{1\over{3}}\Omega_{k}-1}{1-\Omega_{k}}\right) (8) with \lambda a continuous parameter satisfying \lambda>-1 . The latter inequality follows from careful inspection of ( 8 ) and bearing in mind that that -1<\Omega_{k}<1 . Introducing the expression ( 6 ) for w in ( 8 ), we obtain after a short algebra 1+q\geq g(\lambda)\,\Omega_{k}, (9) where g(\lambda)=\frac{3}{2}\left[\frac{1+\frac{\lambda}{3}}{1+\lambda}+\frac{1}{3}\right] (10) is an ever decreasing function. First, we note that the deceleration parameter lies in the range -1+\Omega_{k}\leq q\leq 1 3 3 3 The upper bound on q corresponds at early times when the universe was dominated by massless radiation. The lower bound, corresponds at late times when the universe is accelerating and one uses the DEC, under the form \dot{H}\leq k/a^{2} , alongside the expression for \Omega_{k} . . On the other hand, the above constrain on \lambda implies g(\lambda)\geq 1 , which fully agrees with the GSL, 1+q\geq\Omega_{k} (which is satisfied whatever the sign of \Omega_{k} ). Hence, the physically meaningful range of the parameter \lambda is -1<\lambda<\infty . (The other range, -\infty<\lambda<-1 , is not to be considered because there g(\lambda)<1 ). Note, by passing, that g(\lambda) is not bounded from