Feedback in Dynamic Contests: Theory and Experiment

Sumit Goel Yiqing Yan Jeffrey Zeidel · 2025

Read Feedback in Dynamic Contests: Theory and Experiment by Sumit Goel Yiqing Yan Jeffrey Zeidel (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-23178.txt.

Introduction

Sumit Goel, Yiqing Yan, and Jeffrey Zeidel study how interim feedback changes bidding in a dynamic contest. Two players bid over two stages in an all-pay auction for a common-value prize, and the organizer chooses what each learns between stages. Theory characterizes outcomes as cheapest signal equilibria.

In those equilibria one player bids zero first while the other bids the cheapest amount matching some signal, and both earn zero expected payoff. Total bids sum to the prize value. The authors then run an experiment with four feedback policies, from full to cutoff rules, to see how real bidders compare with theory.

Catalog record

CREATORSumit Goel Yiqing Yan Jeffrey Zeidel
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE49 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-23178

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Feedback in Dynamic Contests: Theory and Experiment The experiment was approved by the IRB at NYU Abu Dhabi and pre-registered with OSF. The pre-registration is available here . We gratefully acknowledge financial support from Tamkeen under the NYU Abu Dhabi Research Institute Award CG005. Sumit Goel Yiqing Yan Jeffrey Zeidel Abstract We study the effect of interim feedback policies in a dynamic all-pay auction where two players bid over two stages to win a common-value prize. We show that sequential equilibrium outcomes are characterized by Cheapest Signal Equilibria, wherein stage 1 bids are such that one player bids zero while the other chooses a cheapest bid consistent with some signal. Equilibrium payoffs for both players are always zero, and the sum of expected total bids equals the value of the prize. We conduct an experiment with four natural feedback policy treatments— full, rank, and two cutoff policies—and while the bidding behavior deviates from equilibrium, we fail to reject the hypothesis of no treatment effect on total bids. Further, stage 1 bids induce sunk costs and head starts, and we test for the resulting sunk cost and discouragement effects in stage 2 bidding. 1 Introduction Contests are situations in which agents make costly investments to win valuable prizes. In many such settings, investments occur across multiple stages, often accompanied by feedback about the investments of others in earlier stages. For instance, in research and development (R&D) competitions, firms may learn about the progress of their rivals through public disclosures. In sports or programming tournaments, participants observe their interim standing through leaderboards. In classroom settings, students may receive feedback at intermediate points, such as after a midterm, about the distribution of scores or the proportion of peers who performed above a certain threshold. Across these environments, participants receive various forms of feedback, which may not only inform subsequent investments but also shape initial investments through strategic considerations such as signaling or deterrence. In this paper, we study how feedback policies influence investment behavior in a two-stage all-pay auction model with two players. Each player bids over two stages to win a common-value prize. The player with the higher total bid wins the prize, while both players pay their total bids. Before the auction begins, the auctioneer commits to a feedback policy, defined as a partition of the bid domain such that, after the first stage, each player learns the element of the partition containing their opponent’s stage 1 bid. To ensure existence of equilibrium, we restrict attention to feedback policies that admit a cheapest bid for every signal (i.e., for each element of the partition). We show that sequential equilibrium outcomes are characterized by Cheapest Signal Equilibria (CSE). In equilibrium (on path), stage 1 bidding is such that one player bids zero while the other chooses the cheapest bid corresponding to some signal, and stage 2 bidding then coincides with the (unique) Nash equilibrium of the single-stage all-pay auction with exogenous head starts. We analyze the rank feedback policy separately, as it falls outside the class of policies considered above, and show that both players must bid zero in stage 1 and then mix uniformly between zero and the prize value in stage 2. This equilibrium characterization yields an irrelevance result : the auctioneer’s equilibrium profit is zero, irrespective of the feedback policy. However, the set of equilibria itself depends on the feedback policy. Apart from the robust equilibrium in which both players bid zero in stage 1, the remaining equilibria are asymmetric and require players to coordinate on which one bids zero in stage 1. When such coordination fails, both players may bid positively in stage 1, thereby generating sunk costs : costs incurred in stage 1 that yield no strategic benefit to the players in stage 2. Stage 2 bidding may then result in a player’s total bid exceeding the value of the prize, a phenomenon we refer to as the sunk cost effect . Moreover, stage 2 bidding entails players dropping out with a probability proportional to the perceived difference in stage 1 bids (the head start ), and in general, stage 2 bids are lower when the head start is higher, an instance of the discouragement effect in our framework. We conduct a laboratory experiment to test these equilibrium predictions of the two-stage all-pay auction model. Our implementation focuses on four natural feedback-policy treatments: full feedback, rank feedback, and two cutoff feedback policies. While we observe overbidding, its magnitude is similar across treatments, and we therefore fail to reject the hypothesis of irrelevance of feedback policies for the auctioneer’s profits. For stage 2 bidding, we observe patterns that are partly consistent with, and partly deviate from, the equilibrium predictions. Higher sunk costs are associated with greater stage 2 bids, in line with the sunk cost fallacy, though the effect is somewhat guarded by the prize value. The discouragement effect of higher head starts kicks in when it is not too small, and is not as large as predicted. Literature review There is a vast literature on all-pay auctions. With multiple players and prizes, Barut and Kovenock 1998 establish an irrelevance of prize structure for expected equilibrium effort. Our result can be interpreted as extending this irrelevance to feedback policies, albeit in a simple two-player model. Siegel 2014 and Konrad 2002 characterize equilibria in models with exogenously fixed head starts, which we use in our own equilibrium characterization. Other related work incorporates private abilities ( Moldovanu and Sela 2001 ), arbitrary cost functions ( Fang et al. 2020 ), and noisy output ( Drugov and Ryvkin 2020 ) within the all-pay auction framework. This paper contributes to the literature on feedback design in dynamic contests. Much of the closely related theoretical work in two-stage all-pay auctions assumes noisy output, which guarantees the existence of a Perfect Bayesian Equilibrium (PBE) in pure strategies. With homogeneous agents, Aoyagi 2010 , Mihm and Schlapp 2019 identify conditions under which full feedback or no feedback is optimal. Other two-stage models consider asymmetric agents ( Hirata 2014 ), private abilities ( Ederer 2010 ), binary outputs ( Goltsman and Mukherjee 2011 ), noisy ranking technologies ( Gershkov and Perry 2009 ), stage prizes ( Klein and Schmutzler 2017 , Sela 2012 ), pre-contest investments ( Clark et al. 2024 , Clark et al. 2025 ), and Tullock contests ( Yildirim 2005 ). Related streams of literature examine feedback policies in elimination contests ( Zhang and Wang 2009 ), sequential contests ( Hinnosaar 2024 , Deng et al. 2023 ), and continuous time environments ( Ely et al. 2023 ). There is also a growing empirical and experimental literature on the effect of interim feedback on effort in contests. The work closest to ours is Ederer and Fehr 2007 , who study a two-stage all-pay auction with noisy output and compare biased feedback against full or no feedback. Fallucchi et al. 2013 highlight the differing effects of feedback in Tullock contests with share and lottery structures. Dechenaux and Mago 2023 study how information leakage, together with the possibility to revise bids in response, affects behavior in all-pay and Tullock contests. Azmat and Iriberri 2010 and Azmat et al. 2019 examine the role of relative performance

Read the complete text