Revisiting the Structure of Trend Premia: When Diversification Hides Redundancy

Alban Etienne, Jean-Jacques Ohana, Eric Benhamou, Béatrice Guez, Ethan Setrouk, Thomas Jacquot · 2025

Read Revisiting the Structure of Trend Premia: When Diversification Hides Redundancy by Alban Etienne, Jean-Jacques Ohana, Eric Benhamou, Béatrice Guez, Ethan Setrouk, Thomas Jacquot (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-23150.txt.

Introduction

Alban Etienne and five co-authors revisit how trend-following returns are built across time horizons. Traders often blend trend signals from several lookback windows, with six months to one year seen as the sweet spot. Equal weighting assumes every asset gains equally from every horizon, an assumption the authors challenge.

Using Bayesian optimization, they reallocate exposure across horizons separately for each asset, learning weights from data. The results suggest diversification across horizons can hide redundant signals. Allocations tuned per asset may earn the trend premium more cleanly, a practical lesson for systematic funds that blend many lookback periods.

Catalog record

CREATORAlban Etienne, Jean-Jacques Ohana, Eric Benhamou, Béatrice Guez, Ethan Setrouk, Thomas Jacquot
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE93 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-23150

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Revisiting the Structure of Trend Premia: When Diversification Hides Redundancy Alban Etienne, Jean-Jacques Ohana, Eric Benhamou, Béatrice Guez, Ethan Setrouk, Thomas Jacquot Abstract Recent work has emphasized the diversification benefits of combining trend signals across multiple horizons, with the medium-term window—typically six months to one year—long viewed as the “sweet spot” of trend-following. This paper revisits this conventional view by reallocating exposure dynamically across horizons using a Bayesian optimization framework designed to learn the optimal weights assigned to each trend horizon at the asset level. The common practice of equal weighting implicitly assumes that all assets benefit equally from all horizons; we show that this assumption is both theoretically and empirically suboptimal. We first optimize the horizon-level weights at the asset level to maximize the informativeness of trend signals before applying Bayesian graphical models—with sparsity and turnover control—to allocate dynamically across assets. The key finding is that the medium - term band contributes little incremental performance or diversification once short - and long - term components are included. Removing the 125-day layer improves Sharpe ratios and drawdown efficiency while maintaining benchmark correlation. We then rationalize this outcome through a minimum-variance formulation, showing that the medium-term horizon largely overlaps with its neighboring horizons. The resulting “barbell” structure—combining short- and long-term trends—captures most of the performance while reducing model complexity. This result challenges the common belief that more horizons always improve diversification and suggests that some forms of time-scale diversification may conceal unnecessary redundancy in trend premia. 1 Introduction 1.1 Motivations Trend-following strategies are among the most persistent and well-documented sources of excess returns in financial markets. Managed futures funds, or Commodity Trading Advisors (CTAs), systematically exploit directional persistence in prices across equities, bonds, commodities, and currencies through long–short positions in liquid futures. These strategies have been shown to deliver returns that are largely uncorrelated with traditional risk premia and that tend to perform strongly during equity market drawdowns, a property often described as “crisis alpha” ( Moskowitz et al. 2012 ; Hurst et al. 2017 ). As a result, CTAs have become a cornerstone of institutional portfolios and a central object of study in the literature on alternative risk premia and dynamic asset allocation. A defining feature of most trend-following systems is the use of multiple lookback horizons to estimate and trade price trends. Combining short-, medium-, and long-term signals is widely viewed as a form of time-scale diversification that improves robustness to different market environments ( Baltas and Kosowski 2013 ; Baz et al. 2015 ; Lempérière et al. 2014 ). The medium-term component—typically corresponding to three to six months—has long been regarded as one of the most effective horizons, balancing responsiveness to new information with resilience to noise. Indeed, both academic research and practitioner studies have historically identified this range as the “sweet spot” of trend-following efficiency ( Fung and Hsieh 2001 ; Winton 2013 ; Hurst et al. 2017 ). However, the conventional practice of assigning equal weights to trend horizons implicitly assumes that all assets benefit equally from each horizon. This assumption overlooks the heterogeneity of asset-specific trend dynamics: certain instruments exhibit stronger persistence at short or long horizons, while others display limited predictability across intermediate scales. As a result, equal weighting across horizons may dilute informative signals and reduce overall efficiency. In this paper, we address this limitation by dynamically allocating the weights assigned to each trend horizon through Bayesian optimization. The objective is to identify, at the asset level, the combination of horizons that maximizes the informativeness of the trend signals used in the decoding process. This pre-decoding optimization aims to make the input layer itself more predictive, rather than relying solely on post-decoding model adjustments. The Bayesian framework provides a natural mechanism for balancing exploration and regularization, while the inclusion of sparsity and persistence constraints ensures stability through time and prevents overfitting. After optimizing the weights dynamically across horizons (20, 60, 125, 250 and 500 days), we find that the medium-term layer (125 days) contributes very little to performance or diversification once short- and long-term components are included. Excluding this layer consistently improves Sharpe ratios and drawdown-adjusted performance while maintaining benchmark correlation. The optimal configuration thus takes a “barbell” form: short-term horizons provide convexity and reactivity, while long-term horizons capture persistent macroeconomic trends. The medium-term component, by contrast, appears redundant—largely explained by adjacent horizons—and can be removed without loss of performance. These findings challenge the traditional view that adding more horizons necessarily enhances robustness. Instead, our results suggest that excessive layering across similar time scales may conceal structural redundancy, creating the illusion of diversification while introducing unnecessary complexity. By systematically testing this hypothesis through a Bayesian dynamic allocation framework, we provide empirical evidence that true diversification arises from combining distinct, complementary horizons rather than overlapping ones. A stylized toy model further illustrates the intuition behind this redundancy: the medium-term component can be interpreted as a linear combination of short- and long-term trends. Consequently, its inclusion contributes little incremental alpha and may even impair performance, as shown in the model assuming a symmetric Toeplitz correlation structure among horizons. 1.2 Structure of the Paper The remainder of the paper is organized as follows. Section 2 reviews the empirical and theoretical literature on trend premia, emphasizing the historical role of the medium-term horizon and the debate between diversification and redundancy across time scales. Section 3 develops the theoretical framework for optimal allocation across trend horizons, formalizing the problem as a mean–variance optimization among correlated horizon-specific factors and deriving analytical conditions under which the medium-term horizon becomes redundant, leading to a barbell structure between short and long horizons. Section 4 introduces the Bayesian graphical model that links portfolio returns to asset-level trend scores, and presents the decomposition of each trend score across multiple horizons. This section establishes the two-layer structure distinguishing the estimation of time-varying asset exposures from the construction of horizon-level inputs. Section 5 details the methodology and out-of-sample results of the dynamic optimization of horizon weights, which replaces the naive equal-weighting scheme by an adaptive, data-driven allocation. Section 6 examines the empirical performance of a model that excludes the medium-term horizon and equally weights the remaining four horizons, providing a robustness check on the contribution of intermediate time scales. Section 7 discusses the broader implications of these results for diversification theory and systematic trend allocation, highlighting how the findings challenge the assumption that including more horizons necessarily enhances robustness. Finally, Section 8 concludes by summarizing the main insights and outlining directions for future research on the dynamic structure of trend premia and cross-horizon dependencies. 2 Background and Literature Review 2.1 Empirical Foundations of Trend Premia A large body of work has examined the performance of trend-following strategies across different time horizons. Early studies established that price trends represent a pervasive and persistent feature of financial markets ( Fung and Hsieh 2001 ; Hurst et al. 2017 ). Within this literature, the medium-term horizon—typically spanning six months to one year—has long been viewed as the most effective range for capturing the trend premium. Empirical evidence supports this view. For instance, Winton 2013 reports that between 1984 and 2013, an “intermediate-speed” strategy with a lookback of several months achieved a Sharpe ratio of 1.12, compared with 0.87 and

Read the complete text