The Tonogenesis Continuum in Tibetan: A Computational Investigation
Siyu Liang, Zhaxi Zerong · 2025
Read The Tonogenesis Continuum in Tibetan: A Computational Investigation by Siyu Liang, Zhaxi Zerong (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-22485.txt.
Introduction
Speech sounds can slowly turn into word tones over centuries, a change called tonogenesis. Siyu Liang and Zhaxi Zerong study that change in Tibetan languages in a 2025 paper, using computer speech recognition instead of only older comparison methods and sound measurements.
Liang and Zerong flatten pitch in recordings and watch how badly recognition suffers in related Tibetan varieties. Fully tonal U-Tsang varieties suffer most, atonal Amdo dialects suffer least, and Kham dialects fall between them. The graded result supports a continuum of change, and it suggests simple word-pair counts may overstate how much pitch matters during transition.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Siyu Liang, Zhaxi Zerong |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 25 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-22485
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The Tonogenesis Continuum in Tibetan: A Computational Investigation Siyu Liang, Zhaxi Zerong Abstract Tonogenesis—the historical process by which segmental contrasts evolve into lexical tone—has traditionally been studied through comparative reconstruction and acoustic phonetics. We introduce a computational approach that quantifies the functional role of pitch at different stages of this sound change by measuring how pitch manipulation affects automatic speech recognition (ASR) performance. Through analysis on the sensitivity to pitch-flattening from a set of closely related Tibetan languages, we find evidence of a tonogenesis continuum: atonal Amdo dialects tolerate pitch removal the most, while fully tonal Ü-Tsang varieties show severe degradation, and intermediate Kham dialects fall measurably between these extremes. These gradient effects demonstrate how ASR models implicitly learn the shifting functional load of pitch as languages transition from consonant-based to tone-based lexical contrasts. Our findings show that computational methods can capture fine-grained stages of sound change and suggest that traditional functional load metrics, based solely on minimal pairs, may overestimate pitch dependence in transitional systems where segmental and suprasegmental cues remain phonetically intertwined. 1 Introduction Tonogenesis refers to the emergence of lexical tone from earlier consonantal or laryngeal contrasts such as voicing and aspiration ( Hombert 1977 ; Haudricourt 1954 ) . Over time, secondary pitch perturbations can become the primary cue for distinguishing words, turning a formerly atonal language into a tonal one. This process unfolds along a continuum: within a language family or group, some varieties maintain complex onset clusters and show little reliance on pitch (e.g. varieties of Amdo Tibetan), whereas others develop robust tone contrasts (e.g., Lhasa Tibetan) ( Sun 2015 ) . Fully tonal languages (at later stages of tonogenesis) exhibit a strong dependence on fundamental frequency ( f_{0} ) for lexical contrasts, which can pose significant challenges for automatic speech recognition (ASR) if pitch information is removed ( Zhang and Kirby 2020 ; Fu et al. 1998 ) . Recent work has established that pitch-flattening—systematically removing f_{0} contours while preserving spectral information—provides a computational method for quantifying tonal dependence in ASR systems ( Liang and Levow 2025 ) . Across typologically diverse languages, fully tonal systems suffer dramatic performance degradation when pitch is removed, while non-tonal languages show minimal impact. Building on this validated methodology, we extend the investigation to multiple Tibetan languages representing distinct stages of tonogenesis. We hypothesize that flattening f_{0} contours will cause a larger performance drop for languages with established tonal contrasts than for those that rely more on consonantal cues. By quantifying the impact of pitch loss on ASR using word error rate and character error rate, we offer computational evidence that captures more granular information than text-based functional load measures in the context of tonogenesis. Our findings demonstrate that dialects at different points in the tonogenesis continuum exhibit correspondingly distinct degrees of pitch dependence, providing new empirical support for understanding how languages transition from consonant-based to tone-based lexical systems. 2 Literature Review 2.1 Tone and tonogenesis Tonal languages use pitch ( f_{0} ) as a primary cue for lexical contrasts, as exemplified by languages like Cantonese, where different pitch patterns on the same segment sequence produce entirely distinct words ( Yip 2002 ; Matthews and Yip 2013 ) . In contrast, non-tonal languages like English employ pitch mainly for intonation and stress ( Edwards and Beckman 1988 ) . Crucially, tonogenesis can arise when older segmental cues (e.g., voicing or coda consonants) induce pitch perturbations that eventually become the main phonemic signal for lexical differentiation ( Haudricourt 1954 ; Hombert et al. 1979 ) . In Vietnamese, for instance, the loss of final stops led to newly phonologized tones ( Thurgood 2002 ) , while other Southeast Asian languages display partial or incomplete shifts ( Matisoff 1973 ) . 2.2 Tibetan languages More than fifty distinct varieties have been identified as part of the Tibetic branch of the Sino-Tibetan language family ( Tournadre 2014 ) . Among these, the three most widely discussed groups are Central, Amdo, and Khams, illustrated in Figure 1 ( Gesang and Gesang 2002 ) . The longstanding debate over whether these varieties constitute separate languages or dialects remains relevant ( Haugen 1966 ) . From a strictly linguistic standpoint, many varieties are only marginally mutually intelligible ( Driem 2001 ) , suggesting that they could be treated as separate languages. Nevertheless, socio-political and cultural factors often motivate their classification as “Tibetan dialects,” highlighting a shared literary heritage (based on Classical Tibetan) and a unified Tibetan ethnic identity ( Tournadre 2014 ; Gesang and Gesang 2002 ) . In this work, we use the term Tibetan languages , while acknowledging the nuanced nature of the debate. Tibetan languages exhibit a diverse range of tonogenesis outcomes. Central (Ü-Tsang) varieties such as Lhasa Tibetan have developed robust tonal distinctions from historical voicing contrasts: modern Lhasa has two phonemic tones that yield four different pitch contours depending on syllable structure ( DeLancey 2017 ; Lim 2018 ) . Khams varieties occupy an intermediate position, relying partially on pitch while retaining residual segmental cues such as voicing contrasts or breathiness ( Sun 2015 ; Suzuki 2011 ) . For instance, Dege Khams preserves historically voiced consonants alongside four emerging tonal categories ( Gesang and Gesang 2002 ) . At the opposite end of the spectrum, Amdo varieties remain primarily atonal, retaining a rich inventory of consonantal clusters in lieu of pitch-based contrasts ( Gesang and Gesang 2002 ; Sun 1986 ) . Figure 1: Approximate distribution of major Tibetan dialect groups. Ü-Tsang (red), Khams (green), and Amdo (purple) show distinct historical trajectories in tonogenesis. 2.3 Tone and ASR Although pitch variations occur in all spoken languages for prosodic or paralinguistic reasons, tone languages uniquely depend on fundamental frequency ( f_{0} ) as a primary lexical contrast. As a result, failing to model pitch cues in automatic speech recognition (ASR) can lead to frequent confusions among words that differ only in tone ( Fu et al. 1998 ; Patel et al. 2010 ; Wang et al. 2013 ; Zhang and Kirby 2020 ) . In practice, researchers typically address tone modeling in two broad ways. Some approaches add time-aligned pitch or voice-quality features directly into the acoustic model ( Lei et al. 2006 ; Li et al. 2011 ) , allowing it to learn the correlations between pitch contours and word identities. Other approaches explicitly encode tonal information in the transcript by assigning diacritics or numeric labels to otherwise identical syllables or phonemes ( Yuan et al. 2021 ; Coto-Solano 2021 ) . Regardless of the chosen method, extensive evidence shows that removing or flattening pitch severely degrades ASR performance in tonal languages, mirroring the disruption that human listeners experience with f_{0} suppression ( Fu et al. 1998 ; Niu et al. 2019 ) . In other words, in fully (or partly) tonal systems, capturing pitch movements becomes essential for correctly mapping acoustic signals to lexical items. Recent work has demonstrated that systematically removing pitch through flattening provides a computational method for quantifying how heavily languages rely on f_{0} for lexical disambiguation: fully tonal systems suffer severe ASR degradation when pitch is removed, while non-tonal languages show minimal impact ( Liang and Levow 2025 ) . This methodology