Unraveling vibronic interactions in molecules functionalized with optical cycling centers
Paweł Wójcik, Haowen Zhou, Taras Khvorost, Guo-Zhu Zhu, Guanming Lao, Justin R. Caram, Anastassia N. Alexandrova, Eric R. Hudson, Wesley C. Campbell, Anna I. Krylov · 2025
Read Unraveling vibronic interactions in molecules functionalized with optical cycling centers by Paweł Wójcik, Haowen Zhou, Taras Khvorost, Guo-Zhu Zhu, Guanming Lao, Justin R. Caram, Anastassia N. Alexandrova, Eric R. Hudson, Wesley C. Campbell, Anna I. Krylov (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-22388.txt.
Introduction
Pawel Wojcik, with nine co-authors, characterises how the first two excited states interact in a strontium phenoxide molecule and its deuterated form. Coupling between the states mixes one level with a close vibrational level of the other state, adding transition strength there. The mixing grows stronger in the deuterated form, where the gap between the levels is smaller.
The team models the mixing with a Hamiltonian fitted using coupled cluster calculations and finds the effect is second order, passed through a third state. From the spectra they estimate a coupling strength and warn cooling designs must count such effects.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Paweł Wójcik, Haowen Zhou, Taras Khvorost, Guo-Zhu Zhu, Guanming Lao, Justin R. Caram, Anastassia N. Alexandrova, Eric R. Hudson, Wesley C. Campbell, Anna I. Krylov |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 55 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-22388
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Unraveling vibronic interactions in molecules functionalized with optical cycling centers Paweł Wójcik, Haowen Zhou, Taras Khvorost, Guo-Zhu Zhu, Guanming Lao, Justin R. Caram, Anastassia N. Alexandrova, Eric R. Hudson, Wesley C. Campbell, Anna I. Krylov Abstract We report detailed characterization of the vibronic interactions between the first two electronically excited states, A ~ \tilde{A} and B ~ \tilde{B} , in SrOPh (Ph = phenyl, - C 6 H 5 \text{C}_{6}\text{H}_{5} ) and its deuterated counterpart, SrOPh-d 5 (- C 6 D 5 \text{C}_{6}\text{D}_{5} ). The vibronic interactions, which arise due to non-adiabatic coupling between the two electronic states, mix the B ~ , ν 0 \tilde{B},\nu_{0} state with the energetically close vibronic level A ~ , ν 21 ν 33 \tilde{A},\nu_{21}\nu_{33} , resulting in extra transition probability into the latter state. This state mixing is more prominent in the deuterated molecule because of the smaller energy gap between the interacting states. We model the mixing of the A ~ \tilde{A} and B ~ \tilde{B} states using the Köppel–Domcke–Cederbaum (KDC) Hamiltonian parametrized in the diabatic framework of Ichino, Gauss, and Stanton on the basis of equation-of-motion coupled-cluster calculations. The simulation attributes the observed mixing to a second-order effect mediated by linear quasi-diabatic couplings between the A ~ \tilde{A} - C ~ \tilde{C} and B ~ \tilde{B} - C ~ \tilde{C} states. Based on the measured spectra, we deduce an effective coupling strength of ∼ 0.5 \sim 0.5 cm -1 . Non-adiabatic couplings between different electronic states is an important factor that should be considered in the design of laser-cooling protocols for complex molecules. I Introduction Cold and ultracold molecules are essential for studying detailed molecular interactions and reactions carr_cold_2009 ; bohn_cold_2017 ; hu_direct_2019 ; gregory_moleculemolecule_2021 ; chen_ultracold_2024 , building new platforms for quantum information science bohn_cold_2017 ; yu_scalable_2019 ; hutzler_polyatomic_2020 ; holland_-demand_2023 ; demille_quantum_2024 ; cornish_quantum_2024 , and advancing precision measurements in search of new physics beyond the Standard Model isaev_laser-cooled_2010 ; augenbraun_molecular_2020 ; augenbraun_laser-cooled_2020 ; anderegg_quantum_2023 ; mitra_quantum_2022 . Laser cooling, which relies on the repeated scattering of photons to slow down the species, has been the vehicle for achieving such cold temperatures. However, compared to atoms, the many vibrational degrees of freedom of molecules create undesirable branching pathways, preventing the closure of a repeated optical cycle. Over the last two decades, tremendous efforts have been made to extend this technique to more complex species. The most successful accomplishments in laser cooling were based on a family of molecules—first proposed by Isaev and Berger isaev_polyatomic_2016 —supporting atomic-like states realized in alkaline earth metal atoms attached to electronegative scaffold containing oxygen or halogen fitch_laser-cooled_2021 ; aieta_efficient_2016 ; baum_1d_2020 ; collopy_3d_2018 ; mitra_direct_2020 ; lasner_magneto-optical_2025 . In these systems, one electron from the metal is donated to an ionic bond with the scaffold and the second electron, localized on the metal, gives rise to atomic-like states. Due to their localized character, the transitions between these states result in minimal changes to the molecular structure. Such alkaline earth (I)-oxygen groups can be attached to a variety of scaffolds and are commonly referred to as an optical cycling center (OCC). Functionalization with OCC is an effective way for developing versatile chemical platforms with the potential capability for laser cooling kozyryev_proposal_2016 ; klos_prospects_2020 ; dickerson_franck-condon_2021 ; zhu_functionalizing_2022 ; augenbraun_direct_2023 ; lao_bottom-up_2024 ; zhou2025vibronic . The most important criterion for successful optical cycling in molecules is the low branching ratios into excited vibrational modes. In the OCC-functionalized molecules, this criterion is satisfied owing to the similar structures of the ground and excited electronic states, which results in nearly “diagonal” Franck–Condon factors (FCFs, the overlaps between the vibrational levels)—that is, only the transitions that do not change the vibrational quantum number are allowed isaev_polyatomic_2016 ; Ivanov:MFOCC:19 , as illustrated in Fig. 1 . Figure 1: Low-lying electronic states in OCC-functionalized molecules illustrated by the Dyson orbitals in SrOH and a cartoon illustrating vibrational wavefunction overlaps between two electronic states. Reproduced from Ref. 30 with permission from the Royal Society of Chemistry. Within the Born–Oppenheimer framework, calculations of FCFs quantify the vibrational branchings, providing a useful guide in the search of suitable molecular candidates for optical cycling Herzberg:Diatomic ; isaev_polyatomic_2016 ; Tarbutt:laser:18 ; Ivanov:MFOCC:19 ; klos_prospects_2020 ; Maxim:PCCPCations:2020 ; Cheng:accurateFCFs:20 ; Maxim:CoolingLarge:20 ; Maxim:CoolingLarge:20err ; dickerson_franck-condon_2021 ; Dickerson:OCCarenes:2021 ; Wojcik:Cations:2022 ; Mitra:OCCarenes:2022 ; zhu_functionalizing_2022 ; Dickerson:saturatedOCC:2022 ; Augenbraun:directPolyatomic:2023 ; Khvorost:dualOCC:2024 ; Pawel:AB:2025 . However, higher-order terms and additional interactions beyond the Born–Oppenheimer approximation can change the predicted vibrational branching ratios. This can be especially problematic for larger molecules with many vibrational modes. Figure 2: Non-adiabatic coupling mixes vibrational levels from different electronic states, which are non-interacting within Born–Oppenheimer approximation. The mixed vibronic states lead to more decay pathways. Vibronic effects originate in the non-adiabatic couplings (NACs) between the Born–Oppenheimer electronic states, as illustrated in Fig. 2 . In the Born–Oppenheimer approximation, each electronic state supports its manifold of vibrational states, and the vibrational states from the different electronic states do not interact. The NACs couple these zero-order states, resulting in the manifold of vibronic states that have contributions from different electronic states. NACs, often referred to as derivative couplings, arise because the electronic wavefunctions change their character upon nuclear motions—they are zero if the electronic wavefunctions do not change upon nuclear displacements. The electronic states that do not change their character upon nuclear displacements are called diabatic states. In the basis of diabatic states, the derivative couplings are zero, but these states—which are no longer are eigenstates of the electronic Hamiltonian—are coupled by the off-diagonal elements called diabatic couplings. Although the diabatic framework is not uniquely defined, it has advantages in the context of computational modeling of vibronic effects—it avoids the problem of diverging couplings (common in the calculations of NACs) and facilitates effective parameterization of vibronic Hamiltonians. Here we use the quasi-diabatic framework of Ichino, Gauss and Stanton Stanton:EOMIPdeg:09 , which is particularly well-suited for setting up vibronic Hamiltonians. In this framework, illustrated in Fig. 3 , the diabatic states correspond to the adiabatic states computed at a reference geometry and coupled by non-adiabatic coupling force (the main ingredient of the NAC) computed at this geometry; these couplings are equated to diabatic couplings. Since the derivative couplings are not fully removed, the framework is called quasi-diabatic Stanton:EOMIPdeg:09 ; Shirin:NAC:17 . This framework was designed to enable parameterization of the Köppel-Domcke-Cederbaum (KDC) Hamiltonian—a molecular Hamiltonian expressed in the basis of diabatic states coupled by off-diagonal matrix elements. Cederbaum:LVC:84 ; KDC:81 ; Koppel:CIbookCh7:04 The diagonalization of the KDC Hamiltonian yields coupled vibronic states, such as those shown in Fig. 2 , facilitating the calculations of the transitions between these levels. The details of the KDC Hamiltonians and the way of their parameterization are described below. Figure 3: Schematic illustration of molecular Hamiltonian in the adiabatic (or Born–Oppenheimer) basis, naive diabatic (here, static Born–Huang) basis, and quasi-diabatic basis. T_{N} represents the nuclear kinetic energy operator and H_{e} is the electronic Hamiltonian. In the quasi-diabatic basis, the states are close to the adiabatic states and the small derivative couplings remain, but the dominant couplings are now appear as off-diagonal terms in the electronic Hamiltonian. Reproduced from Ref. 44 , with the permission of AIP Publishing. In a recent