Symmetry principles of gravitational perturbations in thermal environments
Atsuhisa Ota · 2025
Read Symmetry principles of gravitational perturbations in thermal environments by Atsuhisa Ota (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-22346.txt.
Introduction
Atsuhisa Ota asks whether hot radiation can dress gravity the way a plasma dresses electric fields. In a thermal plasma, soft gauge fields reorganize into collective modes. They gain a gap and Landau damping. For gravity, the thermal scale lands on the Hubble rate. Any such effect lives at the horizon, where the background cannot be treated as still.
Radiation is modeled as a conformal scalar field on an expanding flat universe. Ota computes the linear response to metric ripples on that moving background. The answer is checked against the diffeomorphism Ward identities. The spectrum yields a gapped collective mode set by the expansion rate. Its apparent damping turns out to be the expansion itself, not Landau damping. Tensor modes obey a memory-laden equation. It reproduces Weinberg's classic damping result.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Atsuhisa Ota |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 43 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-22346
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Symmetry principles of gravitational perturbations in thermal environments Atsuhisa Ota Abstract The instantaneous elastic response of gravitational perturbations to the thermal plasma can modify their dynamics near the horizon scale in the early universe. The obstacle is that there are several seemingly reasonable ways to introduce this contact term, reflecting an ambiguity in how one specifies the thermal initial state on a perturbed FLRW background. Diffeomorphism and Weyl invariance allow the (grand) canonical ensemble, defined in the decoupling limit of gravitational interactions, while excluding ensembles that break the Weyl identity, including those perturbed by the metric. With this consistent choice, primordial tensor modes exhibit stable damping, in agreement with Weinberg’s kinetic theory analysis, providing a nontrivial consistency check and a robust basis for quantum-field-theoretic treatments of gravitational perturbations in thermal environments. In quantum field theory in curved spacetime, Ward identities, in particular those of diffeomorphisms and, for conformal theories, Weyl rescalings, constrain how initial data enter the linear response. This principle underlies the effective dynamics of cosmological perturbations during the radiation era after inflation. We work in the linear response framework on a flat Friedmann Lemaître Robertson Walker (FLRW) background, where thermal matter fields couple to metric perturbations. An initial thermal ensemble \hat{D} fixes the instantaneous elastic response of the gravitational perturbation and thereby governs the subsequent evolution of the perturbation variables. The only subtlety concerns the choice of the initial ensemble \hat{D} . We first clarify what we mean by a thermal ensemble for the environment. In this work, we expand the metric as \displaystyle g^{\mu\nu}=a^{-2}(\eta^{\mu\nu}+\kappa\,h^{\mu\nu}), (1) with a the isotropic scale factor of flat FLRW and h^{\mu\nu} the perturbation. We regard h^{\mu\nu} as a tensor field on the background spacetime and expand the interaction in powers of the gravitational coupling \kappa=\sqrt{32\pi G} . Within this setting one defines the (grand) canonical ensemble in the decoupling limit \kappa\to 0 . The density operator in this construction is independent of metric perturbations. This is the global ensemble, \hat{D}_{G} . Evaluating the stress tensor with this ensemble leaves it unperturbed by the metric; metric perturbations enter only through interaction corrections. Alternatively, one may use the vierbein and define the thermal ensemble in a local inertial frame. Once \kappa\neq 0 , this ensemble is perturbed by the metric. We refer to this as the local ensemble, \hat{D}_{L} . A schematic illustration of \hat{D}_{G} and \hat{D}_{L} is shown in Fig. 1 . The central question is whether, in the interaction theory for the metric perturbation h^{\mu\nu} , the environmental ensemble should be taken to be local or global. We show that enforcing the Ward identities of diffeomorphism and Weyl invariance with retarded boundary conditions rules out the locally weighted ensemble \hat{D}_{L} and, under our assumptions, fixes the global thermal ensemble \hat{D}_{G} as the consistent choice in a radiation dominated universe. This matters for upcoming cosmological observations CMB-S4:2016ple ; LISA:2017pwj ; NANOGrav:2023gor ; ET:2019dnz and for foundational quantum mechanical aspects of gravitational waves, including environments that are dynamical during inflation Berera:1995ie ; Berera:2008ar ; Lyth:1995ka and the quantum to classical transition through decoherence in the primordial plasma Polarski:1995jg ; Lombardo:2005iz ; Burgess:2022nwu ; deKruijf:2024ufs ; Takeda:2025cye . Figure 1: Schematic illustration of the initial environmental ensembles \hat{D}_{G} and \hat{D}_{L} . Panel (a) depicts the uniform ensemble \hat{D}_{G} on an FLRW background, shown as a plane, whereas panel (b) shows the ensemble \hat{D}_{L} perturbed by the metric. We show that the left panel (i.e., \hat{D}_{G} ) is consistent with the symmetries of general relativity. Linear response theory. If one treats a graviton mode as a test field propagating in a homogeneous and isotropic thermal environment, the choice of ensemble is straightforward: it must be the global one and it is unique. The early universe is different. Inflation generates metric fluctuations on cosmological scales Mukhanov:2005sc ; Weinberg:2008zzc , and spacetime is not asymptotically flat. More generally, fluctuations of matter and of the gravitational field are not trivially separable. In the interaction picture, the matter stress tensor evolves as Kubo:1957mj \displaystyle\hat{T}_{\mu\nu}=\hat{T}^{\rm I}_{\mu\nu}+i\int^{\tau}_{\tau_{0}}d\tau_{1}\left[\hat{H}_{\rm int}(\tau_{1}),\hat{T}^{\rm I}_{\mu\nu}\right]+\mathcal{O}(\kappa^{2}), (2) where the superscript “I” denotes interaction picture operators defined on the background spacetime and \tau is conformal time. This is the Kubo formula of linear response theory, equivalently, the leading order in the in-in formalism Weinberg:2005vy , and it makes causality explicit. From a hydrodynamic perspective, one expects the stress tensor to take a local equilibrium form at the initial time. Also, for a conformal field, we expect g^{\mu\nu}{\rm Tr}[\hat{D}\hat{T}_{\mu\nu}]=0 . One might therefore suppose that the initial ensemble should itself be perturbed by the metric, so that \hat{D}_{L} would be the proper choice. In Refs. Ota:2023iyh ; Frob:2025sfq ; Ota:2024idm ; Ota:2025yeu this setup was analyzed quantum mechanically for a real massless scalar field, and the retarded response was computed. Its characteristic timescale is of order \beta , the inverse temperature, which is much shorter than the cosmological timescale \tau , so the retarded kernel already contains the instantaneous elastic response. In addition, the Kubo formula generally must contain a contact term that arises from the explicit source dependence of T_{\mu\nu} . Therefore, the expectation value of the stress tensor at the initial time can be perturbed without modifying the ensemble. Equivalently, perturbing \hat{D} would double count the contact contribution. The instantaneous part of the response is not an artifact but a generic feature of linear response. As established in condensed matter contexts, omitting such contributions, for example in optical conductivity PhysRevB.71.104511 or Hall viscosity PhysRevB.86.245309 , violates gauge invariance and leads to inconsistencies. Our case is the gravitational analogue. In what follows, we show that \hat{D}_{L} is incompatible with the symmetry constraints of general relativity and that \hat{D}_{G} is the natural choice. Our strategy is to use the Ward identities for diffeomorphism and Weyl invariance to constrain the initial ensemble. Ward identities. Ward identities are standard in self-energy analyses in QFT, but their application to gravitons carries subtleties. First, the background geometry is essential to the thermal response of gravitons, whereas much of the literature takes the thermal Minkowski limit Rebhan:1990yr ; Frenkel:1990dw ; Brandt:1993bj ; Nachbagauer:1995wn . This produces a mismatch between the self-energy that appears in the Ward identities and the one that enters the effective equation of motion. The identities should therefore be imposed on the off-shell stress tensor before solving the background dynamics for a . Second, the nonlocal Ward identity is usually stated in general form, but its reduction to FLRW requires care. For a given environmental ensemble \hat{D} , define the generating functional of connected thermal Green functions, W[g^{\mu\nu}] , with the metric acting as an external source. As only the thermal fields are integrated out, W[g^{\mu\nu}] can be regarded as the one particle irreducible thermal correction \Gamma[g^{\mu\nu}] to the gravitational action S_{\rm EH}[g^{\mu\nu}] , so in the remaining path integral over g_{\mu\nu} it enters as an additive contribution to the effective action. In what follows we assume that \Gamma is diagonal, although it may be nonlocal; we then write the perturbative expansion of \Gamma as \displaystyle\Gamma=-\frac{1}{2}\int d^{4}x\,\Big[\kappa a^{2}\tau_{\mu\nu}h^{\mu\nu}+\kappa^{2}a^{4}h^{\mu\nu}\pi_{\mu\nu\rho\sigma}h^{\rho\sigma}\Big]. (3) In general, \pi_{\mu\nu\rho\sigma} acts on h^{\rho\sigma} as an operator. This form of \Gamma is, for instance, realized in graviton hard thermal loop (HTL) analysis, which will be addressed shortly. Third, ( 3 ) depends