Aeroelastic Reduced-Order Model Differential Equations in Transonic Buffeting Flow

Michael Candon, Pier Marzocca, Earl Dowell · 2025

Read Aeroelastic Reduced-Order Model Differential Equations in Transonic Buffeting Flow by Michael Candon, Pier Marzocca, Earl Dowell (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-22216.txt.

Introduction

Michael Candon, Pier Marzocca, and Earl H. Dowell shrink one of aeronautics' nastiest simulations into a pocket model. In transonic flight, shock waves on a wing can begin to buffet, oscillating violently and shaking the structure. The coupled air-and-structure problem is so nonlinear and unsteady that three-dimensional studies have mostly been out of reach.

Their reduced-order model blends nonlinear oscillator dynamics with Volterra theory, an input-output description of systems with memory. Produces an integro-differential equation whose terms are picked out of data by a sparse matching algorithm. Applied to a standard test airfoil, the compact model reproduces the aeroelastic buffet response that full simulations struggle to deliver. A trustworthy stand-in of this kind lets engineers sweep designs and flight conditions quickly, reserving heavy computation for the cases that deserve it.

Catalog record

CREATORMichael Candon, Pier Marzocca, Earl Dowell
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE79 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-22216

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Aeroelastic Reduced-Order Model Differential Equations in Transonic Buffeting Flow Michael Candon, Pier Marzocca, Earl Dowell Abstract Numerical simulation of the transonic shock buffet phenomenon remains a formidable challenge due to its inherent nonlinear and unsteady characteristics. These difficulties are further compounded in three-dimensional configurations and when aeroelastic coupling is considered. Consequently, computational studies of aeroelastic shock buffet interactions have largely been confined to two-dimensional systems. This limitation underscores the need for reduced-order models (ROMs) capable of efficiently and accurately capturing the aeroelastic response of structures subjected to shock buffet oscillations. This paper presents a novel nonlinear unsteady aerodynamic ROM that integrates nonlinear oscillator dynamics with Volterra theory to model aeroelastic shock buffet phenomena. The coefficients and terms of the resulting Integro-Differential Equation ROM (IDE-ROM) are identified using the Orthogonal Matching Pursuit (OMP) algorithm. Application of the IDE-ROM to an OAT15A airfoil demonstrates that the compact and computationally efficient formulation can reproduce key nonlinear behaviors, including aeroelastic lock-in, with a high degree of accuracy. The limitations and potential extensions of the proposed approach are also critically examined. Nomenclature b Semi-chord [m] c Chord [m] c_{a_{h}} , c_{a_{\alpha}} Aerodynamic damping in heave [N \cdot m/s] and pitch [N \cdot m \cdot s/ ∘ ] \bm{c} Vector containing identified ODE coefficients C_{L} , C_{M} , C_{p} Lift, moment and pressure coefficient \Delta C_{L} Lift coefficient peak-to-peak amplitude \bm{d_{j}} Vector containing j^{th} -order pruned Volterra series coefficients \hat{f} Frequency ratio, \omega/\omega_{sb} h , \dot{h} , \ddot{h} Heave displacement, velocity and acceleration [m], [m/s], [m/s 2 ] \hat{h} Amplitude of forced harmonic excitation in heave [m] H_{1} Frequency response estimator I_{\alpha} Airfoil moment of inertia [kg m 2 ] k_{a_{h}},k_{a_{\alpha}} Aerodynamic stiffness in heave [N/m] and pitch [N \cdot m/ ∘ ] K Effective coupling gain in Adler equation L Lift force [N] \bm{L} Lower left triangular circulant matrix M_{c/4} Moment about the quarter-chord [N \cdot m M_{\infty} Freestream Mach number m Airfoil mass [kg] N_{O} , N_{I} Number of candidate differential and integro-differential equation terms N_{L} Number of time lags N_{T} Total number of training samples p Pruned Volterra series order p_{O} Polynomial expansion order Q , \dot{Q} , \ddot{Q} Generalized aerodynamic force, velocity and acceleration [m], [m/s], [m/s 2 ] Re_{\infty} Freestream Reynolds number t Time [s] u , \dot{u} , \ddot{u} Generalized displacement, velocity and acceleration u_{\infty} Freestream velocity [m/s] W Aerodynamic work per cycle y^{+} Non-dimensional first cell height Greek Symbols \alpha , \dot{\alpha} , \ddot{\alpha} Pitch rotation, rotational velocity and rotational acceleration [ ∘ ], [ ∘ /s], [ ∘ /s 2 ] \hat{\alpha} Amplitude of forced harmonic excitation in pitch [ ∘ ] \alpha_{0} Freestream angle-of-attack [ ∘ ] \epsilon Nonlinearity parameter in the Rayleigh oscillator \kappa Pre-defined number of non-zero coefficients to be identified by OMP \zeta_{h} , \zeta_{\alpha} Heave and pitch structural damping ratio \mu Structural-to-fluid mass ratio, m/\pi\rho_{\infty}b^{2} \rho_{\infty} Freestream fluid density [kg/m 3 ] \tau , \Delta\tau Non-dimensional time and time step tu_{\infty}/c \bm{\Phi} , \bm{\Phi_{NL}} Linear and nonlinear state matrix \psi Phase difference between buffet and structural oscillations \omega_{h} . \omega_{\alpha} Heave and pitch natural frequency [rad/s] \omega_{B} Shock buffet frequency [rad/s] \Delta\omega Frequency detuning ( \omega_{B}-\omega_{h} or \omega_{B}-\omega_{\alpha} ) 1 Introduction Transonic shock buffet is a nonlinear unsteady aerodynamic phenomenon, characterized by large amplitude self-sustained periodic shock oscillations that result from shock wave boundary layer interactions [ 1 ] . Shock buffet is a global flow instability, meaning that it occurs even in the absence of structural motion (referred to as a fluid-only limit cycle oscillations (LCO) throughout this paper). Although shock buffet occurs only within a narrow window of the transonic regime, the aeroelastic instabilities it induces make it a primary contributor to fatigue life degradation, while also limiting the flight envelope and adversely affecting pilot handling qualities and comfort [ 2 ] . While a major driver for transonic buffet research comes from the defense sector ( e.g. , the F-16 is renowned for its issues with the phenomenon [ 3 ] ), the civil aviation sector also requires careful consideration of its effects. For instance, the sustainable aviation sector is seeing a demand for novel light weight and aerodynamically efficient aircraft designs, requiring that practitioners pay very close attention to dynamic aeroelastic effects in the transonic regime - as exemplified in Boeing’s work on the Transonic Truss-Braced Wing [ 4 ] . The aerodynamic aspects of shock buffet on a rigid body have been widely studied, with experimental campaigns dating back to the 1980’s [ 5 ] , and more recent campaigns considering the two-dimensional (2D) [ 6 ] and three-dimensional (3D) [ 7 ] buffet mechanism. In the last two decades, exponential growth in computing power and broader access to high performance computing (HPC) have enabled researchers to study the phenomenon numerically, using computational fluid dynamics (CFD) codes. Such research was initially dominated by 2D Unsteady Reynolds-Averaged Navier-Stokes (URANS) simulations with mixed success. On one hand, researchers have demonstrated that URANS codes can capture 2D buffet with good accuracy while, on the other hand, generalization largely remains problematic. In particular, different turbulence models can produce vastly different results. Most recently, numerical modeling of 3D buffet has seen major interest on wings or half-span aircraft models. In such cases, it seems that the limitations of URANS codes are more prevalent [ 8 ] . As a result, scale resolving codes, including variants of Large Eddy Simulation (LES), have seen increasing use for buffeting flows, albeit at a massive computational cost. Understanding the interaction between shock buffet and an elastic structural model is also a critical aspect of this field of research that has made rapid progression in the last 15 years. Before examining this body of literature, the frequency ratio, \hat{f}_{n} , is defined as: \hat{f}_{n}=\frac{\omega_{n}}{\omega_{B}} (1) where \omega_{n} could be the structural natural frequency or forced oscillation frequency of mode n , and \omega_{B} is the shock buffet frequency. One of the earliest studies of Raveh [ 9 ] demonstrates that frequency lock-in can occur when an airfoil in transonic buffeting flow undergoes forced sinusoidal motion at frequency ratios in the vicinity of one, i.e. , the unsteady shock oscillations synchronize with the airfoils structural motion. This lock-in to forced harmonic motion was confirmed experimentally by Hartmann [ 10 ] who also investigated the two-degree-of-freedom (2-DOF) heave-pitch aeroelastic response. The heave and pitch frequency ratios investigated by Hartmann were much less one ( \hat{f}_{h}<<1 , \hat{f}_{\alpha}<<1 ), and lock-in was not observed, but rather the system was shown to respond at the buffet frequency. Subsequent numerical investigations of 2D elastically suspended airfoils in transonic buffet [ 11 , 12 , 13 ] have shown that the aerodynamic forces can exhibit lock-in to a single-degree-of-freedom (s-DOF) pitching mode, within the approximate range 1\leq\hat{f}_{\alpha}\leq 2 , causing significant amplification of the structural response amplitude. Outside this range, much lower amplitude structural oscillations are observed at the buffet frequency. These studies also assess sensitivities of lock-in to structural damping and to the structural-to-fluid mass ratio. Gao et al. [ 14 ] proposed a carefully designed linearized reduced-order model (ROM) to study lock-in, showing that it is in fact driven by a coupled mode flutter, rather than a form of resonance as previously

Read the complete text