Social preferences or moral concerns: What drives rejections in the Ultimatum game

Pau Juan-Bartroli, José Ignacio Rivero-Wildemauwe · 2025

Read Social preferences or moral concerns: What drives rejections in the Ultimatum game by Pau Juan-Bartroli, José Ignacio Rivero-Wildemauwe (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-22086.txt.

Introduction

Pau Juan-Bartroli and José Ignacio Rivero-Wildemauwe ask why people reject money in the Ultimatum Game, where a proposer splits a sum and a responder who says no leaves both with nothing. Rejections of positive offers have been blamed both on social preferences, such as spite toward an unfair partner, and on moral concerns about the split itself.

Their model combines the two motives and delivers a sharp answer. A pinch of spite turns out to be both necessary and sufficient for rejecting a positive offer, so social preference does the driving. Morality is not irrelevant: stronger moral concern raises the threshold at which people reject, acting as an amplifier on the social motive. Estimating both traits from earlier experimental data, the authors find two distinct types of rejecters, separable by how the same people behave in a second game with no rejection option.

Catalog record

CREATORPau Juan-Bartroli, José Ignacio Rivero-Wildemauwe
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE93 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-22086

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Social preferences or moral concerns: What drives rejections in the Ultimatum game? Thanks: We are grateful to Ingela Alger, Ernesto María Gavassa-Pérez, Emin Karagözoğlu, Enrico Mattia-Salonia, Esteban Muñoz-Sobrado and Juan Sebastián Pereyra for their valuable discussions. We thank Pablo Brañas-Garza and Antonio Espín for kindly sharing their data with us. Pau Juan-Bartroli acknowledges funding from the European Research Council (ERC) under the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme (grant agreement No 789111 - ERC EvolvingEconomics). Pau Juan-Bartroli, José Ignacio Rivero-Wildemauwe Abstract Rejections of positive offers in the Ultimatum Game have been attributed to different motivations. We show that a model combining social preferences and moral concerns provides a unifying explanation for these rejections while accounting for additional evidence. Under the preferences considered, a positive degree of spite is a necessary and sufficient condition for rejecting positive offers. This indicates that social preferences, rather than moral concerns, drive rejection behavior. This does not imply that moral concerns do not matter. We show that rejection thresholds increase with individuals’ moral concerns, suggesting that morality acts as an amplifier of social preferences. Using data from van Leeuwen and Alger 2024 , we estimate individuals’ social preferences and moral concerns using a finite mixture approach. Consistent with previous evidence, we identify two types of individuals who reject positive offers in the Ultimatum Game, but that differ in their Dictator Game behavior. JEL codes : C78, D64, D81, D91 Keywords: Bargaining, Social preferences, Morality, Ultimatum Game 1 Introduction In relevant economic interactions, individuals bargain over how to divide resources. Examples include a buyer and seller negotiating the price of an item, an employer and employee bargaining over wages, and team members determining how to allocate responsibilities. The simplest model to represent these interactions is the Ultimatum Game (UG) ( Güth et al. 1982 ). In this game, the proposer offers a division of an endowment to the responder . If the responder accepts this offer, the division is implemented. If the proposer rejects this offer, both individuals receive nothing. If both individuals maximize their material payoff, and this is common knowledge, then the unique Subgame Perfect Nash Equilibrium is one where the responder accepts any positive offer and the proposer offers the lowest possible positive amount. However, the evidence contradicts this prediction, as responders frequently reject positive offers ( Camerer 2003 ; Güth and Kocher 2014 ). As discussed below, several studies propose different explanations of these rejections ( Levine 1998 ; Fehr and Schmidt 1999 ; Xiao and Houser 2005 ; Çelen et al. 2017 ; Karagözoğlu and Keskin 2018 ; Aina et al. 2020 ) . In this paper, we show that combining social preferences with moral concerns can account for these behaviors while also explaining other observed patterns. Our analysis also provides insights into how social preferences interact with moral concerns. Understanding how different motives interact in shaping behavior remains an underexplored area of research ( Gavassa-Pérez 2022 ) . However, recent evidence suggests that prosociality is often driven by a general moral preference to “do the right thing” ( Capraro and Rand 2018 ) , and that deontological motives coexist with outcome-based concerns ( Chen and Schonger 2022 ) . By integrating both dimensions, our framework captures interactions that single-motive models fail to explain. Importantly, we do not treat social preferences and moral concerns in isolation. While both concerns have substantial empirical support on their own ( Miettinen et al. 2020 , e.g.) , evolutionary analysis suggests that it is their combination that is favored by natural selection, especially in small-stakes interactions ( Alger et al. 2020 ) . This prediction is consistent with recent experimental evidence ( van Leeuwen and Alger 2024 ; Alger and Rivero-Wildemauwe 2024 ) . To the best of our knowledge, this is the first theoretical paper to examine bargaining behavior under the joint presence of social preferences and moral concerns. We show that this interaction is crucial to explain the evidence. Before discussing our main results, we describe individuals’ utility function. Individuals exhibit social preferences when they attach some weight to their opponent’s material payoff, which may vary depending on whether the opponent’s material payoff exceeds or falls below the individual’s own payoff ( Becker 1976 ; Fehr and Schmidt 1999 ) . 1 1 1 In our setting, aversion to disadvantageous inequality is equivalent to spite (i.e., attaching a negative weight to others’ material payoff). This term is also referred to as envy ( Mui 1995 ; Levine 1998 ). Moral concerns are modeled through universalization reasoning, where individuals act as if they assign some weight to the scenario in which others adopt the same strategy as themselves. 2 2 2 This reasoning can be interpreted in several ways: the individual (i) considers what would happen if all other individuals followed his own course of action; (ii) believes that others are generally similar and will therefore make the same choices (similar to the false consensus effect , Ross et al. 1977 ; Dawes 1989 ; Butler et al. 2015 ); or (iii) thinks his action influences the likelihood that others will select it as well (similar to magical thinking , Shafir and Tversky 1992 ; Daley and Sadowski 2017 ). , 3 3 3 We acknowledge that morality cannot be reduced to universalization reasoning. We focus on this formulation due to its prominence in both theoretical and experimental work. Alger and Weibull 2013 and Alger et al. 2020 establish its evolutionary foundations, showing that universalization reasoning can emerge as an adaptive trait that promotes cooperation and group cohesion. For alternative moral concepts in economics, see Harsanyi 1955 , Sen 1977 , Roth 2007 , Roemer 2010 , Smith and Wilson 2019 , Gavassa-Pérez 2022 and Drouvelis and Gavassa-Pérez 2024 . Under this reasoning, individuals suffer a disutility when selecting a rejection threshold above their own offer. This occurs because in a hypothetical scenario where an individual is matched with someone mimicking their strategy, the resulting payoff is zero—as offers would be rejected. Our analysis relies on two features that depart from more standard treatments of the UG (see Section 2.1 for more details). First, instead of focusing on computing the game’s Nash equilibria, which we relegate to Appendix B , we consider the strategy that maximizes an individual’s utility given his (potentially incorrect) beliefs. We adopt this approach as the former results in (i) multiplicity of equilibria, (ii) no rejections in equilibrium, and (iii) the need to assume that all individuals hold correct beliefs. 4 4 4 Departing from equilibrium analysis aligns with the approach in Aina et al. 2020 , which considers a subjective rationality condition in which individuals maximize their utility given their beliefs and preferences. Second, we consider the UG with role uncertainty , where individuals select their offers and rejection thresholds without knowing their realized role and are assigned to each role with equal probability. 5 5 5 This approach is common in studies examining universalization reasoning in asymmetric games (e.g., Alger and Weibull 2013 ; Muñoz Sobrado 2022 ; Salonia 2023 ; van Leeuwen and Alger 2024 ; Rivero-Wildemauwe 2025 ). This assumption is essential for computing the universalization counterfactual—i.e., “what if others acted like me?”—and enables

Read the complete text