Conformally symplectic Chaplygin reduction in rubber rolling of surfaces of revolution over the plane
Jair Koiller · 2025
Read Conformally symplectic Chaplygin reduction in rubber rolling of surfaces of revolution over the plane by Jair Koiller (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-22032.txt.
Introduction
Jair Koiller writes about a rolling puzzle: a convex body rolling on a flat plane without slipping or twisting, like a rubber ball that also refuses to spin in place. Such rubber rolling under gravity forms a classic nonholonomic system, one whose constraints involve motion itself. For bodies shaped as surfaces of revolution the problem collapses onto a sphere of special vectors.
Koiller revisits an observation by Borisov, Mamaev, and Bizyaev that this revolution case is unusually kind. Its extra conserved quantity has a simple elementary form, unlike ordinary marble rolling, where no such simple integral exists. He connects their finding to newer work showing that reduced systems of this Chaplygin type carry a conformally symplectic structure, a geometric frame that explains why the special case behaves so well.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jair Koiller |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 67 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-22032
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Conformally symplectic Chaplygin reduction in rubber rolling of surfaces of revolution over the plane Departimento di Matematica “Tulio Levi-Civita”, Università di Padova ([email protected]) Jair Koiller Abstract To the memory of Alexey V. Borisov 1 1 1 This paper was submitted to special volume of Regular and Chaotic Dynamics dedicated to the legacy of A. V. Borisov with the title “Comments on a paper about rubber rolling by A. V. Borisov, I. S. Mamaev and I. A. Bizyaev”. . Alexey did Poetry through Mathematics and Music. Poetry is not easy. Abstract Rubber rolling (no-slip and no-twist) of a convex body on the plane under the influence of gravity is a SE(2) Chaplygin system, that reduces to T^{*}S^{2} , the sphere of Poisson vectors. I comment upon an observation by A.V Borisov and I.S. Mamaev ( [ 1 ] , 2008) for the case of surfaces of revolution [also in A. V. Borisov, I. S. Mamaev and I. A. Bizyaev ( [ 2 ] , 2013)]. They show that this case is quite special: the additional integral of motion is elementary, while for marble rolling it is not elementary. I call by “Nose” function their expression N(\theta)=(I_{1}\,\cos^{2}\theta+I_{3}\,\sin^{2}\theta+m\,z_{C}^{2}(\theta))^{1/2} where \theta is the nutation and z_{C}(\theta) is the center of mass height. N(\theta) appears somewhat miraculously in the process of the almost symplectic reduction. I work in space frame using the Euler angles \phi\,\text{(yaw)},\,\theta\, . The reduction to 1 DoF is done in two stages: first, reduction by the group SE(2)=\{(x,y,\,\phi)\} to the Poisson sphere T^{*}S^{2}=\{(\theta,\,\psi)\} with almost symplectic 2-form \Omega_{NH}=dp_{\theta}\,\wedge d\theta+dp_{\psi}\,\wedge d\psi+J\cdot K . The semi-basic term is J\cdot K=-p_{\psi}\,(d\log(N(\theta))\wedge d\psi . It follows that \Omega_{NH} is conformally symplectic in the sense that d(\frac{1}{N}\,\Omega_{NH})=0. The conserved quantity due to the S^{1} symmetry about the body axis is \ell=N(\theta)\,\sin^{2}\theta\,\dot{\psi} , yielding the desired reduction to (\theta,p_{\theta}) . Further simplification results by taking the new time dt=\sqrt{B(\theta)}\,d\tau,\,\,\text{with}\,\,B=I_{1}+m\,|CP|^{2} where P=(x,y) is the point of contact. One gets finally H=\frac{1}{2}\tilde{p}^{2}_{\theta}+V(\theta),\,V(\theta)=\ell^{2}/2\sin^{2}\theta+mg\,z_{C}(\theta)\,\,\text{with}\,\,\tilde{p}_{\theta}=p_{\theta}/\sqrt{B} and usual symplectic form d\tilde{p}_{\theta}\wedge d\theta . The moments of inertia I_{1},I_{3} reappear in the reconstruction. Some initial observations are presented for the torus. Full reconstruction is in order. Key words: Nonholonomic mechanics, Reduction, Chaplygin systems AMS MSC(2020) ; 37J60, 70F25, 58A15, 58A30 . 1 Introduction In choosing this theme for this submission I wanted to honor the living legacy of Alexey Borisov, by revisiting with a different method (the almost symplectic reduction for Chaplygin systems ) a very nice result appearing (almost in passing) in the fundamental work [ 1 ] , section 5 by A. V. Borisov, I. S. Mamaev and also with I. A. Bizyaev in [ 2 ] , section 3.1, about rubber rolling of solids of revolution over the plane and the sphere . I guess the first “rubber paper” by Alexey was [ 3 ] , in 2007, with I. S. Mamaev. Solids of revolution were suggested in [ 4 ] , section 4.4. No new results appear here, however relations with current studies are given in the appendix (by Luis García-Naranjo) and the final section points some research directions (besides a few queries along the text). I I present an extended bibliography. I hope that the the almost symplectic reduction could be useful also for higher dimensions, see [ 5 ] , [ 6 ] . The example of the ellipsoid of revolution over the plane was settled by Alexander Kilin and Elena Pivovarova [ 7 ] . I asked them about the status for the torus, since they had already done similar problems in [ 8 , 9 , 10 ] . They told me that the torus was not considered in detail yet, but they have preliminary results about bifurcation diagrams. I look forward for their study. The no-slip constraint for the torus appears in the very beginning of the treatise by Neimark-Fufaev [ 11 ] , Chapter II-2. The marble case was recently analyzed from the Engineering perspective in [ 12 ] , [ 13 ] . Actually it is easier to work out the general surface of revolution and then particularize for the rubber torus - certainly one of the simplest examples. The simplest is the spherical body with an axisymmetric distribution of mass, the “rubber Routh sphere”. ]). The geometry of the first Chaplygin reduction (or compression) for this example is described in section 4.1 of [ 6 ] . Historical note. According to [ 7 ] the rubber rolling appeared already in two notes by Hadamard in the end of a book by Appell [ 14 ] 2 2 2 https://gallica.bnf.fr/view3if/ga/ark:/12148/bpt6k82007h/f2 , see also Hadamard, 1895 [ 15 ] . The theme was developed in Beghin, 1929 [ 16 ] . There appears the result that in rubber rolling corresponding curves have equal geodesic curvatures There are many ancient and modern references in [ 12 ] and [ 17 ] . 1.1 Rubber rolling by the RCD school Kilin gently summarized for me their perspective. Following a tradition going back to Chaplygin, the equations and reduction are done in Lagrangian representation, with redundant variables using the body frame. One directly searches a Hamiltonian/Poisson structure, or at least conformally Hamiltonian (usually after a reduction). Here, to be conformally Hamiltonian means here that there is an almost symplectic or almost Poisson structure, that becomes symplectic (or Poisson) when multiplied by a function of a reduced coordinate, which is equivalent to a time change. See for instance [ 18 ] . This notion of “conformality” contrasts with [ 19 ] . The configuration space for rolling over the plane is Q=\{(P,e_{1},e_{2},e_{3})\}=\mathbb{R}^{2}\times SO(3) where P is the contact point in the plane. One can find reduced equations for (\gamma,\dot{\gamma})\in TS^{2} where \gamma is the unit vector e_{z} in the space frame seen in the body frame. \gamma is usually called the Poisson vector . To achieve this reduction, one takes quasi-velocities v and \Omega - the velocity of the center of mass and the angular velocity, respectively, referred to the body. Using the method of undetermined multipliers, one writes the (Lagrangian) equations of motion on TM using these quasi-velocities. By construction, these equations preserve the constraint equations. Also, they are invariant under the action of SE(2) . More precisely, v and \Omega are obviously invariant under SE(2) , so the corresponding reduction is trivial, and moreover the equations for v,\Omega and \gamma decouple. In more detail, it goes as follows: i) Thanks to the SE(2 )-symmetry, the equations for \Omega and \gamma are decoupled from the equation for v (which expresses the no-slip constraint). ii) Using the no-slip constraint, one drops the equation for v obtaining a system for (\Omega,\gamma)\in\mathbb{R}^{3}\times\mathbb{R}^{3} . The evolution equation for \gamma is kinematical (Poisson equation \dot{\gamma}=\gamma\times\Omega ) whereas the evolution equation for \Omega is dynamical (Newton’s law). These equations have the geometric integral F_{0}=||\gamma||^{2} and also, by construction (appropriately considering D’Alembert’s principle), the ‘rubber constraint’ integral F_{1}=\gamma\cdot\Omega . The restriction of the equations to the physical invariant set \Sigma=\{(\Omega,\gamma)\in\mathbb{R}^{3}\times\mathbb{R}^{3}:F_{0}=1,F_{1}=0\} defines the SE(2) -reduced equations of motion. It is clear that \Sigma is diffeomorphic to TS^{2} . iii) Using the rubber constraint \gamma\cdot\Omega=0 , one may write \Omega=\dot{\gamma}\times\gamma along \Sigma (take cross product with \gamma on both sides of the Poisson equation and use