The swinging counterweight trebuchet On internal friction
E Horsdal · 2025
Read The swinging counterweight trebuchet On internal friction by E Horsdal (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-21869.txt.
Introduction
E Horsdal studies energy lost to friction inside a swinging counterweight trebuchet, the medieval siege engine whose hanging weight swings as the arm throws. Builders and historians modeling these machines need honest loss figures, since a shot's range depends on how much energy survives the moving joints.
Horsdal derives the drag effects of sliding friction at the arm's bearings and at the counterweight hinge, plus air resistance on the sling. Folds them into the equations for the machine's internal motion. Solutions come from perturbation methods, a way of layering small corrections onto a simpler answer. The calculated losses are checked against shots from a small experimental engine, and the paper closes by asking how the effects scale up to full-size machines.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | E Horsdal |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 43 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-21869
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The swinging counterweight trebuchet On internal friction E Horsdal Abstract Mechanical energy is lost to friction during a shot with a trebuchet. The losses are mainly due to sliding friction at the bearings for the throwing arm and at the hinge for the swinging counterweight, but the aerodynamic force on the sling also contributes. Generalized forces for these sliding and aerodynamic frictions are derived and included in the equations for the internal movement of the engine. The equations are solved by the use of perturbation theory and calculated losses are compared with results from an experimental engine of small dimensions. Scaling to full-size trebuchets is discussed. 1 Introduction A swinging counterweight trebuchet is powered solely by gravity, but internal forces to constrain the internal movement are also present. Gravity is a conservative force and the constraining forces do no work, so total mechanical energy is conserved. However, mechanical energy is lost in practice due to frictional forces on rotating shafts and air drag on the rapidly moving sling carrying the projectile. Although experiments have shown small losses by friction [ 1 ] , these cannot be ignored in a detailed analysis. The generalized form of each frictional force is derived by the use of dissipation functions and added to the equations for the internal movement. The forces from sliding friction prevents the equations from being solved directly by standard numerical methods, but for small losses, such as those found in well-designed trebuchets, this problem can be overcome by perturbation theory and a few iterative solutions to ensure self consistency. The experimental results [ 1 ] were obtained by the use of a smaller engine equipped with motion sensors that make it possible to determine mechanical energies and losses. Calculated losses underestimate the experimental results [ 1 ] , and degrees of freedom not included in the analysis are believed to be the explanation for this. The results are extrapolated by scaling to large trebuchets inspired by historical renderings. The experimental throwing arm, however, has an unusual mass distributions due to the sensors and their mountings so it was redesigned, but very capable engines of large dimensions followed after this amendment. 2 The trebuchet and friction A detailed description of a trebuchet with swinging counterweight can be found in [ 2 ] . Here, we give only a short summery for convenience based on figure 1 , which shows four schematic diagrams of the same trebuchet. The various moving parts of the engine are identified in the diagram to the left. The next shows the long L_{1} and short L_{2} segments of the throwing arm, the arm for the counterweight L_{3} , and the length of the sling L_{4} . Terms used for the masses of projectile, counterweight and beam are given in the third, and generalized angular coordinates are seen at last for a particular instant of time after the projectile has been lifted from the trough. These coordinates describe the movement of throwing arm \theta , counterweight \psi , and sling \phi . The initial values are (\theta,\psi,\phi)_{i}=(\theta_{i},0,0) . Figure 1: Trebuchet. Height of pivot is H=L_{1}\cos\theta_{i} . A shot runs through three phases. In phase I, the projectile slides in a trough at the base of the engine, but is eventually lifted and this marks the start of phase II. This lasts until the projectile is released from the sling and flies towards the target, which is located to the left. The engine comes to rest during phase III. A pouch with two ropes forms a sling that carries the projectile, and a release mechanism comprising a ring and a spigot, often in the form of a hook, controls the opening of the pouch. One rope is tied to the ring, which is hung on the spigot from which it can slide off. The other is permanently tied to the throwing arm next to the spigot. The position of the projectile in phase II is \displaystyle\textbf{r}=H\textbf{e}_{y}+L_{1}(\sin\theta\textbf{e}_{x}-\cos\theta\textbf{e}_{y})-L_{4}(\cos\phi\textbf{e}_{x}+\sin\phi\textbf{e}_{y}) where \textbf{e}_{x} and \textbf{e}_{y} are unit vectors in horizontal and vertical directions, respectively. Similar expressions exist for the centers of mass of counterweight and pivoting beam, and for phase I. This allows all potential energies to be written as functions of the generalized coordinates (\theta,\psi,\phi) , and the sum is U . Velocities follow from positions by differentiation with respect to time, and this allows all kinetic energies to be written as functions of (\theta,\psi,\phi) and the derivatives (\dot{\theta},\dot{\psi},\dot{\phi}) . The sum is T . The three equations for the internal movement are derived from the generating Euler-Lagrange equations \displaystyle\frac{d}{dt}\frac{\partial\mathcal{L}}{\partial\dot{q}}-\frac{\partial\mathcal{L}}{\partial q}=0, (1) where q represents \theta , \psi or \phi and \mathcal{L}=T-U is the Lagrange function. Mechanical energy is lost to friction during the internal movement and this is not taken into account in ( 1 ). Non-conservative friction forces can be included in the analysis when they are expressed as generalized forces \mathcal{R} that depend on the generalized coordinates and their derivatives. These forces are added on the right hand side of ( 1 ). The calculation of the generalized forces is facilitated by dissipation functions \mathcal{F} introduced in section 3 , and in terms of these they are \displaystyle\mathcal{R}_{q}=-\frac{\partial\mathcal{F}}{\partial\dot{q}}\penalty\ . (2) 3 Dissipation functions \mathcal{F} and generalized forces \mathcal{R} The sliding friction losses at the bearings are most often significantly larger than the aerodynamic loss relating to the motion of the sling. The dominant sliding friction is discussed first and then air drag. 3.1 Sliding friction The magnitudes of the time-dependent reaction forces at the bearings for the beam and counterweight shafts are F_{R}=|\textbf{F}_{R}| and F_{H}=|\textbf{F}_{H}| , respectively, and the sliding speeds are R_{R}\dot{\theta} and R_{H}(\dot{\theta}-\dot{\psi}) , where R_{R} and R_{H} are radii of the shafts. Two bearings, each carrying half weight, and the standard model for friction give the rate of heat generation \displaystyle P_{f}=\mu_{R}F_{R}R_{R}|\dot{\theta}|+\mu_{H}F_{H}R_{H}|\dot{\theta}-\dot{\psi}|, (3) where \mu_{R} and \mu_{H} are empirical friction coefficients. The internal forces in ( 3 ) were discussed in [ 3 ] . The model assumes two flat surfaces that slide against each other with a certain area of contact, and this is problematic for two cylinders of not exactly the same radii. However, wood is elastic so a finite area of contact forms, and what is more important, Equation ( 3 ) is independent of this area. The model is therefore assumed to be applicable. Each term in ( 3 ) is proportional to the appropriate radius, so this should be as small as possible to limit losses, but large enough for the shaft to carry the dynamic weight of the moving counterpoise or throwing arm. 1. Generalized forces at bearings for beam shaft. The force \textbf{F}_{R} has the form -h\textbf{v}/v , where v=|\textbf{v}| is the speed at contact and h=\mu_{R}F_{R} is positive and constant. The dissipation function for a friction force of this form is given by \displaystyle\mathcal{F}=\int_{0}^{v}h(v^{\prime})dv^{\prime} so \displaystyle\mathcal{F}=\mu_{R}F_{R}v=\mu_{R}F_{R}R_{R}|\dot{\theta}|. The generalized force follows from ( 2 ), and with the sign function sng it reads \displaystyle\mathcal{R}_{\theta 1}=-\mu_{R}F_{R}R_{R}\cdot\left\{\begin{array}[]{rcl}-1&\mathrm{for}&\dot{\theta}<0\\ 0&\mathrm{for}&\dot{\theta}=0\\ 1&\mathrm{for}&\dot{\theta}>0\end{array}\right.\quad=-\mu_{R}F_{R}R_{R}\cdot\mathrm{sgn}(\dot{\theta}). 2. Generalized forces at hinge. The dissipation function is in this case \displaystyle\mathcal{F}=\mu_{H}F_{H}v=\mu_{H}F_{H}R_{H}|\dot{\theta}-\dot{\psi}|, so one finds two generalized forces \displaystyle\mathcal{R}_{\theta 2}=-\mu_{H}F_{H}R_{H}\cdot\mathrm{sgn}(\dot{\theta}-\dot{\psi}) and \displaystyle\mathcal{R}_{\psi}=-\mu_{H}F_{H}R_{H}\cdot\mathrm{sgn}(\dot{\psi}-\dot{\theta}). 3.2 Aerodynamic friction The aerodynamic force on the sling is modeled by the standard form \displaystyle\textbf{F}=-\frac{1}{2}\rho_{a}CAv^{2}\frac{\textbf{v}}{v}, (8) where \rho_{a}