Metallicity regulates planet formation across all masses In this work we used the Python language and several scientific packages: SciPy P. Virtanen et al. 2020 , Matplotlib J. D. Hunter 2007 , Statsmodels S. Seabold & J. Perktold 2010 , Pandas W. McKinney et al. 2010 , Seaborn M. L. Waskom 2021 . T

Max Nguyen, Vardan Adibekyan · 2025

Read Metallicity regulates planet formation across all masses In this work we used the Python language and several scientific packages: SciPy P. Virtanen et al. 2020 , Matplotlib J. D. Hunter 2007 , Statsmodels S. Seabold & J. Perktold 2010 , Pandas W. McKinney et al. 2010 , Seaborn M. L. Waskom 2021 . T by Max Nguyen, Vardan Adibekyan (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-21863.txt.

Introduction

Max Nguyen and Vardan Adibekyan ask how the metal content of a star shapes the planets that form around it. The standard core accretion picture explains small and mid-sized planets well. The heaviest planets are often credited to a different route, gravitational collapse, which might not care about metals at all.

Using the total heavy-element share of each star as a stand-in for the raw material in its planet-forming disk, the pair find that even the most massive planets favor metal-rich homes. Metal content also tracks with how many planets a system holds and their combined mass, though the clear link to individual planet mass appears at the top of the mass range. Disk chemistry, they conclude, steers planet formation at every size.

Catalog record

CREATORMax Nguyen, Vardan Adibekyan
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE40 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-21863

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Metallicity regulates planet formation across all masses In this work we used the Python language and several scientific packages: SciPy P. Virtanen et al. 2020 , Matplotlib J. D. Hunter 2007 , Statsmodels S. Seabold & J. Perktold 2010 , Pandas W. McKinney et al. 2010 , Seaborn M. L. Waskom 2021 . To determine the summed mass fraction of heavy elements, we used the publicly available code at https://github.com/vadibekyan/planet_building_blocks Max Nguyen, Vardan Adibekyan Abstract The role of stellar metallicity in shaping planetary systems is central to our understanding of planet formation. While the core accretion paradigm is widely accepted as the dominant mechanism for forming low- and intermediate-mass planets, the origin of the most massive planets remains debated, with gravitational instability often invoked to explain their existence. In this study, we analyze the dependence of planet formation on metallicity using the total heavy-element mass fraction ( Z Z ), which is a proxy for the composition of the protoplanetary disk inferred from stellar photospheres. We show that even the most massive planets form preferentially in metal-rich environments. Z Z correlates not only with the presence of planets, but also with planetary system multiplicity and total planetary mass. The most massive planets are found in the most metal-rich environments, and, in agreement with core-accretion theory, only the upper end of the planetary mass distribution shows a clear positive correlation with metallicity. These findings suggest that the chemical enrichment of protoplanetary disks plays a central role in shaping the full spectrum of planetary masses. show][email protected] I Introduction Exoplanet research is fundamentally intertwined with stellar astrophysics. The key physical properties of exoplanets, such as radius and mass, are typically derived relative to their host stars ( V. Adibekyan et al. 2018 ) . Moreover, because protoplanetary disks dissipate within a few million years, most known exoplanets are no longer embedded in their original formation environments. As stars and planets originate from the same molecular cloud material, stellar atmospheres serve as the primary fossil record of the conditions present during planet formation ( L. Grossman 1972 ; V. Adibekyan et al. 2021 ) . A powerful approach for understanding how planets form and evolve is to investigate correlations between planetary occurrence rates and properties and the characteristics of their host stars ( V. Van Eylen et al. 2018 ; G. D. Mulders 2018 ; V. Adibekyan et al. 2021 ; B. Banerjee et al. 2024 ; A. Weeks et al. 2025 ) . In particular, stellar metallicity has proven valuable as a tracer of planet formation efficiency and architecture ( N. C. Santos et al. 2004 ; D. A. Fischer & J. Valenti 2005 ; S. G. Sousa et al. 2011 ; L. A. Buchhave et al. 2012 ; V. Z. Adibekyan et al. 2013 ; L. A. Buchhave et al. 2014 ) . Observations show that the occurrence rate of low-mass planets appears largely independent of stellar metallicity ( S. G. Sousa et al. 2011 ; L. A. Buchhave et al. 2012 ; T. Kutra et al. 2021 ) . However, this relation is not uniform for hot and warm planets, a positive correlation with metallicity has been observed for hot low-mass planets ( G. D. Mulders et al. 2016 ; E. A. Petigura et al. 2018 ; R. F. Wilson et al. 2022 ; J. K. Zink et al. 2023 , e.g.,) . In contrast, Jupiter-mass planets are much more common around metal-rich stars ( N. C. Santos et al. 2004 ; D. A. Fischer & J. Valenti 2005 ) . Overall, these trends are consistent with predictions from the core-accretion (CA) model, where higher metallicity promotes the rapid formation of solid cores necessary for gas giant formation. However, the formation of the most massive planets, super-Jupiters with masses greater than about 4 M_{\mathrm{J}} , remains uncertain. Some studies have reported that these planets tend to orbit stars with lower metallicities than those hosting Jupiter-mass planets ( N. C. Santos et al. 2017a ; J. Maldonado et al. 2019 ; R. Matsukoba et al. 2023 ) , suggesting that gravitational instability (GI) may dominate in that mass regime. Most previous studies have relied on stellar iron abundance ([Fe/H]) as a proxy for the total metallicity of the protoplanetary disk. While this approximation may be adequate for near-solar metallicities, it becomes increasingly inaccurate at lower metallicities, where significant \alpha -element enhancement is observed ( V. Z. Adibekyan et al. 2012 ; B. Ratcliffe et al. 2023 ) . Furthermore, different metals contribute differently to planet formation. Thus, a physically more meaningful metric is the summed mass fraction of heavy elements ( Z ), which captures the abundance of elements that are most relevant to planet formation ( N. C. Santos et al. 2017b ) . Recently, M. Nguyen & V. Adibekyan 2024 using the heavy-element fraction Z instead of [Fe/H] showed that super-Jupiters form in environments as metal-rich as those hosting Jupiter-mass planets, contradicting earlier claims and potentially lending support to the CA scenario. This is particularly relevant given that the role of metallicity in GI models remains poorly understood ( R. Helled et al. 2014 ; E. Vorobyov & C. Schoenhacker 2025 ) . In this study, we investigate how the presence of planets in different mass regimes depends on the summed mass fraction of heavy elements in planet-building blocks, inferred from host star atmospheric abundances. Additionally, we examine whether Z influences planetary system multiplicity, total planetary mass, and the mass of the heaviest planet in each system. Ultimately, our analysis aims to clarify the role of metallicity in shaping the formation and architecture of planetary systems across the full spectrum of planetary masses, from Earth-mass planets to brown dwarfs. II Sample selection We began our sample selection from the NASA Exoplanet Archive ( NASA Exoplanet Science Institute 2020 , NEA,) . At the time of retrieval 1 1 1 The data were retrieved on 18/12/2024 , the NEA listed 5,806 confirmed exoplanets orbiting 4,069 stars. Of these planets, 2,593 had measured masses below the brown dwarf limit of 13 M_{\mathrm{J}} ( D. S. Spiegel et al. 2011 ) , and about 84% of these mass measurements had relative uncertainties below 50%. We used the parameter pl_bmassj from the NEA, which provides the best available planet mass estimates, prioritizing direct mass measurements, M\sin(i)/\sin(i) , or M\sin(i) , depending on availability. However, many of these mass estimates were derived indirectly from mass-radius relationships. To ensure reliable and uniform mass measurements, we restricted our analysis to planets detected via the radial velocity (RV) method and with relative mass uncertainties below 50%. This criterion yielded a sample of 959 planets orbiting 715 host stars (about 97% of all RV-detected planets). Next, we cross-matched the planet-hosting stars with the Hypatia Catalog ( N. R. Hinkel et al. 2014 ) to retrieve stellar elemental abundances. The Hypatia Catalog is a carefully curated compilation of abundance measurements for nearby stars within 500 pc of the Sun, as well as all known exoplanet host stars regardless of distance, although it is not fully homogeneous. We first restricted the sample to stars with elemental abundances [X/H]<0.6 dex, since the Galaxy has not enriched beyond this metallicity threshold ( B.

Read the complete text