An H α \alpha Transit of HD 189733b to Assess Stellar Activity Across the Transit Chord Close to JWST Observations
Kingsley E. Ehrich, Jason A. Dittmann, Samuel P. Halverson, Alejandro Camazón-Pinilla · 2025
Read An H α \alpha Transit of HD 189733b to Assess Stellar Activity Across the Transit Chord Close to JWST Observations by Kingsley E. Ehrich, Jason A. Dittmann, Samuel P. Halverson, Alejandro Camazón-Pinilla (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-21703.txt.
Introduction
Kingsley E. Ehrich and three co-authors catch a starspot crossing in front of a famous hot Jupiter, timing the observation to support the James Webb Space Telescope. When a planet transits its star, astronomers read its atmosphere from starlight filtering through it. But blotches on the star itself can forge fake atmospheric signals, and this system has heavy Webb time booked.
Using a high-resolution spectrograph on a ten-meter telescope in the Canary Islands, they watch a hydrogen line during one transit of HD 189733b. The line grows shallower mid-transit by a small, precisely measured amount, the signature of the planet hiding an active region. The spot's inferred size could shift the transit depth at a key carbon dioxide wavelength by about seventeen parts per million, close to Webb's noise floor. So the team urges simultaneous ground monitoring of stellar activity alongside space observations.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Kingsley E. Ehrich, Jason A. Dittmann, Samuel P. Halverson, Alejandro Camazón-Pinilla |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 43 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-21703
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
An H α \alpha Transit of HD 189733b to Assess Stellar Activity Across the Transit Chord Close to JWST Observations Kingsley E. Ehrich, Jason A. Dittmann, Samuel P. Halverson, Alejandro Camazón-Pinilla Abstract Transmission spectroscopy allows us to detect molecules in planetary atmospheres, but is subject to contamination from inhomogeneities on the stellar surface. Quantifying the extent of this contamination is essential for accurate measurements of atmospheric composition, as stellar activity can manifest as false atmospheric signals in planetary transmission spectra. We present a study of hot Jupiter HD 189733b, which has over 50 hours of JWST observations scheduled or taken, to measure the activity level of the host star at the current epoch. We utilize high-resolution spectra of the H α \alpha line from the MEGARA spectrograph on the 10-m GTC to examine the activity level of HD 189733 during a transit. We measure H α \alpha becoming shallower mid-transit by an H α \alpha index of δ = 0.00156 ± 0.00026 \delta=0.00156\pm 0.00026 , which suggests that HD 189733b crosses an active region as it transits. We posit this deviation is likely caused by a spot along the transit chord with an approximate radius of R spot = 3.47 ± 0.30 R ⊕ R_{\mathrm{spot}}=3.47\pm 0.30R_{\oplus} becoming occulted during transit. Including an approximation for unocculted spots, we estimate that this spot could result in transit depth variations of ∼ \sim 17 ppm at the 4.3 micron CO 2 feature. Since this is comparable to JWST NIRCam Grism mode’s noise floor of ∼ \sim 20 ppm, it could bias atmospheric studies by altering the inferred depths of the planet’s features. Thus, we suggest ground-based high-resolution monitoring of activity indicator species concurrently taken with JWST data when feasible to disentangle stellar activity signals from planetary atmospheric signals during transit. I Introduction Transmission spectroscopy allows for characterization of planetary and atmospheric composition. However, challenges associated with ground-based observations, such as variable telluric contamination, changing observing conditions, and thermal background, can place limits on the systematics floor for exoplanet atmospheric measurements. Because of this, space-based spectroscopic studies of exoplanets are appealing. The tradeoff with space-based spectroscopy is that although it is impervious to several of these issues, resolution and/or collecting area is sacrificed due to practical constraints of space-based observatories. An issue with spectroscopy, however, is that the planet being studied is typically unresolved. As a result, stellar signals from the host star become inevitably entangled with the planetary signals, systematically contaminating the exoplanet’s transmission spectrum ( Pont et al. 2008 ) . There is a wavelength-dependent source of contamination called the Transit Light Source Effect. This arises because the assumed light source during transit is the pre-transit observable stellar disk. However, stellar inhomogeneities along the surface create a different spectral signature due to different contributions of spots and faculae to the transmission spectra ( Rackham et al. 2018 ) . Thus, the disk-averaged spectrum of the star mid-transit is different than it was pre-transit, since the planet covers different parts of the star along the transit chord, preferentially weighting different areas of the inhomogeneous stellar surface. The composition of star spots themselves can also present its own issue. Since spots are cooler regions of the star than the disk-averaged photosphere, molecules can form and exist in them ( Wöhl 1971 ; Neff et al. 1995 ; Berdyugina et al. 2003 ). If there is a molecule present in the planet’s atmosphere that is also present in a spot on its host star, unocculted spots can deepen absorption features in the planet’s transmission spectrum ( Thompson et al. 2024 ) . In some cases, the stellar signal from inhomogeneities on the stellar surface can overpower the signal from the planet, and temporal variation on the stellar surface can cause stellar lines to evolve over time ( Rackham et al. 2023 ) . Where heavy stellar contamination is present, neglecting to account for stellar activity can lead to an underestimation of H 2 O abundance by over 2 orders of magnitude ( Thompson et al. 2024 ) . Unocculted spots can be approximated as static during a transit, since the transit timescale is on the order of hours, while the spot evolution timescale can be much longer than that (weeks to months) ( Giles et al. 2017 ) . With this in mind, a general correction for the wavelength-dependent contribution to the transmission spectrum may be sufficient ( Sing et al. 2011 ) . These unocculted spots cause an overall dimming effect. Unocculted spots can also introduce a slope to the inferred transmission spectrum, even in the absence of planetary haze, further complicating atmospheric retrievals and analysis of mixed stellar and planetary transmission spectra. HD 189733b has a strongly sloped transmission spectrum, which could be due to unocculted spots alone if their covering fraction were only \sim 5.6 percent ( McCullough et al. 2014 ) . The inferred unocculted spot covering fraction is estimated to be \sim 1-1.7 percent based on rotational variability monitoring ( Pont et al. 2008 ; Pont et al. 2013 ; Sing et al. 2009 ; Sing et al. 2011 ). Furthermore, underestimating spot contribution can lead to inaccurate measurements of hazes within planetary atmospheres. Thus, corrections for spot contributions based on stellar variability should be treated as a lower limit, and may lead to underestimated corrections in transmission spectra. Occulted spots, however, typically have opposite effects compared to unocculted spots. Komori et al. 2025 and Wallace et al. 2005 show that in general, unocculted spots can either cause absorption lines to become deeper or shallower than they are in the photosphere. Therefore, both outcomes are also possible in case of occulted spots. Section 4.2.5 of Murphy et al. 2025 shows that occulted spots can have varying effects on transmission spectrum features, as they can cause them to become both deeper and shallower depending on the species, temperatures, and latitudes involved. Deming et al. 2025 note that while larger spot-crossing events are relatively easily noticeable, smaller spot-crossing events may be nearly undetectable in broad photometric bandpasses but can have a non-negligible effect on molecular detections. These effects are exacerbated when multiple transit visits are averaged together to increase signal. Deming et al. 2025 suggest that high-resolution spectroscopy and cross-correlation techniques are potential methods to diagnose what kind of stellar activity is present, and the nature of its spectra. Furthermore, Deming et al. 2025 performed analysis to examine the effects of unocculted spots on spectra. They compared spectra of a modeled spotted M-dwarf surface to that of the same M-dwarf with the spots rotated off the stellar surface by taking a ratio of the spectrum from the spotted surface divided by the spectrum of the non-spotted surface. They found that some molecular species have stronger absorption in the spot versus quiet photosphere, whereas other lines present the opposite result. It is not obvious which effect will dominate for a crossing event for bright or dark active regions viewed in the H \alpha line center, so we perform an empirical test using solar H \alpha data in Section V . Both occulted and unocculted spots are relevant to this work. While we measure the activity level along the transit chord, the scale