Quality of Coverage (QoC): A New Paradigm for Quantifying Cellular Network Coverage Quality, Usability and Stability
Varshika Srinivasavaradhan, Morgan Vigil-Hayes, Ellen Zegura, Elizabeth Belding · 2025
Read Quality of Coverage (QoC): A New Paradigm for Quantifying Cellular Network Coverage Quality, Usability and Stability by Varshika Srinivasavaradhan, Morgan Vigil-Hayes, Ellen Zegura, Elizabeth Belding (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-21162.txt.
Introduction
Varshika Srinivasavaradhan leads three co-authors on Quality of Coverage, a multi part measure of mobile network reach that goes beyond the bare speed floors shown on provider and regulator maps. A map that promises a minimum rate says nothing about ease of use or steadiness across place and time.
Their indicator set captures measured performance quality, ease of use, and steadiness in space and time from real measurements. Fine grained characterization exposes neighborhoods where nominal reach hides unusable service. Better reach truth supports consumer choice, infrastructure funding decisions, and honest public accountability for carriers nationwide.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Varshika Srinivasavaradhan, Morgan Vigil-Hayes, Ellen Zegura, Elizabeth Belding |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 84 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-21162
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Quality of Coverage (QoC): A New Paradigm for Quantifying Cellular Network Coverage Quality, Usability and Stability Varshika Srinivasavaradhan, Morgan Vigil-Hayes, Ellen Zegura, Elizabeth Belding Abstract . Current representations of cellular coverage are overly simplistic; they state only the minimal level of available bandwidth (i.e., 35/3Mbps download/upload speed for 5G) and fail to incorporate a critical component of usability: network stability over space and time. Cellular coverage quality is complex given wireless propagation characteristics and relationships between network load and (often limited) network capacity. A more fine-grained characterization is essential. We introduce Quality of Coverage (QoC), a novel multi-dimensional set of key performance indicators (KPIs) that reflect actual measured performance quality, usability and stability. This representation of the coverage of the cellular network more fully captures temporal and spatial usability and resilience. We motivate and define a set of QoC KPIs and use three distinct datasets to analyze the ability of the KPIs to characterize network behavior, demonstrating the ability of QoC to offer a more fine-grained and useful representation of cellular coverage than possible with current metrics. 1. Introduction Traditional representations of cellular coverage over-simplify network behavior. For instance, characterizations of mobile broadband access, such as those released by the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) in the National Broadband Map ( FCC 2025 ) , indicate whether a location is provided a minimum speed (e.g. 35 Mbps download/3 Mbps upload speed for 5G) by a particular cellular provider. While this provides slightly more information than the historical binary representation of cellular coverage (i.e., does a location have access from a specific provider-yes or no), such a simplistic characterization of networked services over cellular networks is insufficient ( Adarsh et al. 2021b ; Mangla et al. 2022 ; Rural Wireless Association 2019 ; Government Accountability Office 2018 ) . While “coverage” may exist in a given location, the service quality can be so routinely poor as to be unusable. This can be true due to poor signal quality and/or insufficient network provisioning. As an example of the former, cellular holes, e.g. areas that lack usable signal quality, can be common in urban and suburban regions ( Bai et al. 2014b ; Shayea et al. 2021 ) . In rural or tribal regions, where base station coverage areas are greater and weaker signals are more common, cellular coverage is typically less reliable ( Mangla et al. 2022 ; Adarsh et al. 2021a ; FCC 2019 ) . On the other hand, a region may experience strong signal quality, yet performance can be unpredictable when utilization outpaces infrastructure capacity ( Marinova et al. 2020 ; Adarsh et al. 2021a ; Pew Research Center 2019 ) . Hence, in modern networks where application requirements can place significant demand on a network, it is critical to characterize not only whether coverage exists and "should" meet some minimal threshold, but whether that coverage is actually of sufficient quality over space and time to support the types of applications desired, or needed, by users ( Nielsen Insights 2020 ; Samms 2020 ; Holpuch 13 ) . Within this context, our goal is to break away from simplistic coverage representations and introduce Quality of Coverage (QoC), a novel means of more accurately characterizing cellular network quality that focuses on the usability and performance stability of the coverage. Like quality of service (QoS) and quality of experience (QoE), we define QoC as a set of key performance indicators (KPIs) that reflect network performance. However, in defining QoC, we pay careful attention to the unique characteristics of the cellular transmission medium. While modern wired networks have communication media properties that offer stable maximum bandwidths, cellular networks are inherently unstable due to wireless propagation ( Zhou et al. 2004 ) . In fact, 5G networks that incorporate mmWave can have greater performance instability than their predecessors due to the short, easily obstructable wavelengths ( Srinivasavaradhan et al. 2025 ; Narayanan et al. 2022 ; Bai et al. 2014a ; Busari et al. 2018 ; Hassan et al. 2020 ) . To this end, we define five KPIs to characterize the quality and stability of a cellular network: Usability, Persistence, Usable Performance Mean, Variability, and Resilience. Together, these five KPIs provide an in-depth profile of the QoC offered by a cellular network. Crucially, we do not need to measure each of these KPIs independently; each KPI is a function of network performance (e.g., download speed, latency) at a location over a period time. We offer the QoC framework as a robust starting point that we do not claim is, nor do we want to be, immutable. Similar to the evolution of QoS and QoE with the development of network and application-layer technologies, we anticipate that QoC, too, will evolve. Our goal is to enable network researchers and practitioners to more meaningfully characterize cellular networks. By addressing the shortcomings of existing mobile network evaluation methods and introducing a multi-dimensional framework for characterizing QoC, this paper sets a new standard in the field of mobile network characterization and assessment. We believe our approach aligns more closely with the complexities of modern cellular network usage than more simplistic representations. By accounting for spatial and temporal fluctuations in coverage and performance, QoC could provide stakeholders with the insight needed to improve network design and management and enhance user satisfaction. For instance, QoC could help network planners and local governments make more informed decisions about where new infrastructure is needed. QoC could also help users make decisions about which provider offers the best local service. Further, as new, hyper-local cellular technologies, such as mmWave 5G and 6G, are designed to support throughput- and latency-sensitive applications, QoC could offer benchmarking opportunities tailored to the dynamic nature of technologies. In summary, our contributions are the following: (1) Definition of Quality of Coverage (QoC) : We formalize Quality of Coverage as a multi - dimensional framework to quantify quality, usability and stability of cellular network coverage. We define five KPIs as a starting point for this framework. (2) Spatial aggregation of QoC profiles: We introduce a multi-dimensional aggregation approach that uses scalar averages with fast and mergeable DDSketches to produce spatial region-level QoC profiles that preserve both central tendencies and distributional detail. (3) Multi-step characterization: We analyze the ability of QoC KPIs to characterize a broad spectrum of network behaviors and examine KPI interdependence using both synthetic and real-world measurements. We demonstrate how QoC provides fine-grained characterizations of cellular performance that are impossible with current cellular benchmarking standards. 2. The Need for QoC We begin by illustrating the inadequacy of the minimum download speed representation of cellular coverage currently used by the FCC. We examine the coverage offered by AT&T, T-Mobile and Verizon at 52 locations within our community. Based on the FCC National Broadband Map ( FCC 2025 ) and each provider’s coverage map, all three providers offer download speeds at a minimum of 35 Mbps at each location. We utilize 6,000 Ookla Speedtest measurements to analyze the actual availability of coverage at these locations (measurement details provided in Section 4.2.2 ). (a) Mean download speeds (b) Download speed variability (c) Example time series Figure 1 . Actual measured download speeds at 52 locations claimed to be covered at 35