Background solutions to the Hubble tension in f ⁡ ( Q ) f(Q) gravity and consistency with BAO measurements

José Antonio Nájera, Indranil Banik, Harry Desmond, Vasileios Kalaitzidis · 2025

Read Background solutions to the Hubble tension in f ⁡ ( Q ) f(Q) gravity and consistency with BAO measurements by José Antonio Nájera, Indranil Banik, Harry Desmond, Vasileios Kalaitzidis (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-20964.txt.

Introduction

José Antonio Nájera leads three co-authors on whether f(Q) gravity theories can ease the Hubble tension while fitting new baryon sound based data from DESI. The tension pits local expansion measures against early universe readings, and modified gravity is a popular candidate fix.

Three functional forms face the data, log based, fast growth, and hyperbolic tangent, each also extended with a cosmological constant, alongside flexible additions to the standard model. Tests join DESI, cosmic background, local expansion, and cosmic chronometer data. The log based and tangent forms fail to solve the tension adequately, while the fast growth form fares better in the reported comparison, narrowing the viable modified gravity space.

Catalog record

CREATORJosé Antonio Nájera, Indranil Banik, Harry Desmond, Vasileios Kalaitzidis
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE69 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-20964

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Background solutions to the Hubble tension in f ⁡ ( Q ) f(Q) gravity and consistency with BAO measurements José Antonio Nájera, Indranil Banik, Harry Desmond, Vasileios Kalaitzidis Abstract We test whether f ⁡ ( Q ) f(Q) symmetric teleparallel theories of gravity are capable of solving the Hubble tension while producing consistency with DESI DR2 BAO. We consider three different forms for the f ⁡ ( Q ) f(Q) function: logarithmic, exponential, and hyperbolic tangent. We also consider extensions of these models by adding the Cosmological constant, and compare to phenomenological models with a flexible double exponential addition to the standard Λ \Lambda CDM H ⁡ ( z ) H(z) . We test these models against DESI DR2 BAO, Planck 2018, Local H 0 H_{0} , and Cosmic Chronometers data. The logarithmic and hyperbolic tangent models do not provide an adequate solution, while the exponential model gives a reasonable solution, though it faces mild tension with the BAO data. The models assisted by the cosmological constant perform slightly better than the exponential, at the cost of reduced theoretical motivation. This highlights the difficulties of finding a theoretically motivated solution to the Hubble tension while producing BAO consistency. The phenomenological models are able to achieve a good fit to all data, giving guidelines for what a background solution to the Hubble tension would look like in general. I Introduction If General Relativity ( Einstein_1915 , GR;) is valid on cosmological scales, the matter content of the Universe must be dominated by non-baryonic cold dark matter (CDM) particles outside the standard model of particle physics, while the matter-energy content must be dominated by a cosmological constant ( \Lambda ), leading to the well-known \Lambda CDM paradigm ( Efstathiou_1990 ; Ostriker_1995 ) . Its free parameters can be calibrated using the observed anisotropies in the power spectrum of the cosmic microwave background (CMB), relic radiation from redshift z=1090 ( Planck_2020 ) . One of the model parameters is H_{0} , the present value of the Hubble parameter H\equiv\dot{a}/a , where a is the cosmic scale factor normalised to unity today, 0 subscripts denote present values, and an overdot denotes a time derivative. The \Lambda CDM prediction for H_{0} based on the CMB anisotropies measured by the Planck satellite, the Atacama Cosmology Telescope (ACT), and the South Pole Telescope (SPT) is 67.24\pm 0.35 km/s/Mpc ( Planck_2020 ; Calabrese_2025 ; Camphuis_2025 ) . This can be tested by measuring z^{\prime}\equiv dz/dr , the local gradient of redshift with respect to distance. In a homogeneously expanding universe, we expect that cz^{\prime}=H_{0} ( Mazurenko_2025 , section 1 of) . However, local measurements of cz^{\prime} by several different teams using a wide variety of techniques, instruments, and tracers consistently indicate a value around 9% above that expected in \Lambda CDM ( Valentino_2025 , and references therein) . \Lambda CDM also faces another tension from the observed angular scale and redshift depth of the baryon acoustic oscillation (BAO) ruler. This is a feature in the large-scale correlation function of galaxies that was imprinted at early times, essentially corresponding to the first angular peak in the CMB power spectrum ( Eisenstein_1998 ) . The comoving length r_{d} of the BAO ruler should have remained constant for z\lesssim 1060 . Starting with the seminal works of Cole_2005 and Eisenstein_2005 , the BAO feature has been detected at increasingly higher precision, most recently by the Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument (DESI) Collaboration in their Data Release 2 (DR2) ( DESI_2025 ) . The measurements are in \approx 3\sigma tension with \Lambda CDM expectations ( Calabrese_2025 ) . However, a look at all available BAO measurements over the last 20 years shows that the actual level of tension is more like 3.8\sigma , highlighting that the BAO ‘anomaly’ has to be taken seriously ( Banik_2025_BAO , table 2 of) . These difficulties with \Lambda CDM might suggest a problem with our understanding of the \mathcal{O}\left(10^{-5}\right) CMB anisotropies. However, we can infer H_{0} using only the CMB monopole temperature in combination with the primordial light element abundances, relying on the well-established theory of Big Bang nucleosynthesis ( Cyburt_2016 , BBN;) . This BAO + BBN route to H_{0} gives 68.51\pm 0.58 km/s/Mpc ( DESI_2025 ) , far below local measurements of cz^{\prime} . Thus, problems with measurements of the subtle CMB anisotropies cannot account for the Hubble tension. The above argument relies on \Lambda CDM applying prior to recombination, but if there are actually significant deviations from it, then we may be able to fit the CMB anisotropies and BBN with a higher H_{0} consistent with the local cz^{\prime} . There have been several proposals along these lines, for instance using primordial magnetic fields modifying the redshift of recombination ( Mirpoorian_2025 ) . However, there are at least seven serious difficulties faced by such early-time solutions to the Hubble tension ( Vagnozzi_2023 ) . One such difficulty is that the age of the Universe would be reduced by a higher expansion rate than the Planck cosmology for nearly the entirety of cosmic history. However, this prediction is in significant tension with observations of the oldest Galactic stars and globular clusters ( Cimatti_2023 ; Valcin_2025 ) , which are more in line with the Planck H_{0} given the constraint on the matter density parameter \Omega_{\mathrm{M}} from uncalibrated BAO data ( Banik_2025 ) . Another issue is that the CMB contains a wealth of detail beyond merely the angular scale of the first acoustic peak. This makes it challenging to understand the excellent fit to the CMB power spectrum in \Lambda CDM if there were indeed substantial deviations from it in the pre-recombination Universe ( Calabrese_2025 ; Camphuis_2025 ) . Another issue is that the BAO anomaly is not present at high z but grows as we get to lower z\lesssim 1 . This trend cannot be understood through a simple recalibration of r_{d} , which would uniformly scale the BAO angular scale and redshift depth at any z by the same factor at all z . These difficulties faced by \Lambda CDM and modifications to it at early times motivate us to consider other theories with a different late-time expansion history. Sticking to \Lambda CDM behaviour in the early universe would preserve the excellent fit to the CMB anisotropies in \Lambda CDM, provided the comoving matter density and the comoving distance to recombination remain the same as in the Planck cosmology. However, this leaves significant flexibility in the late-time expansion history, possibly allowing us to solve the Hubble and BAO tensions. To modify the expansion history, we need to alter either the matter-energy content of the universe or the law of gravity. In the former approach, we can introduce dynamical dark energy, where we let the dark energy Equation of State (EoS) change with redshift. However, this proposal does not explain what dark energy is, so it just provides a phenomenological approach without theoretical grounds. The latter approach is through modified theories of gravity. In this context, the late time accelerated expansion of the Universe is described via its geometry. This provides a compelling explanation for the nature of dark energy. In this paper, we focus on this latter approach, i.e., the modified gravity formalism.

Read the complete text