Gravitational collapse and singularity avoidance of a homogeneous dust fluid on a brane with timelike extra dimension
Rikpratik Sengupta, Chiranjeeb Singha · 2025
Read Gravitational collapse and singularity avoidance of a homogeneous dust fluid on a brane with timelike extra dimension by Rikpratik Sengupta, Chiranjeeb Singha (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-20874.txt.
Introduction
Rikpratik Sengupta and one co-author study the collapse of a uniform dust cloud in a braneworld model with an extra timelike dimension. Braneworld gravity changes the usual rules, including the theorem that makes standard collapse matching clean, so whether collapse must end in a singularity is open again.
The cloud interior follows an expanding universe style metric run in reverse, while the outside is a radiation envelope settling toward a charged static form with positive tidal charge. While brane effects stay strong, the brane tension stays finite and curvature scalars stay controlled, hinting at singularity avoidance in this setting. The work maps one path by which extra dimensions could soften the end state of collapse.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Rikpratik Sengupta, Chiranjeeb Singha |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 67 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-20874
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Gravitational collapse and singularity avoidance of a homogeneous dust fluid on a brane with timelike extra dimension Rikpratik Sengupta, Chiranjeeb Singha Abstract We investigate the gravitational collapse of a homogeneous dust fluid in the Shtanov-Sahni model consisting of a braneworld possessing an extra time-like dimension. A Friedmann-Lemaître spacetime models the interior of the collapsing cloud, while the exterior consists of a Vaidya radiation envelope, which eventually transitions to a static vacuum described by the Reissner–Nordström (RN) solution with a positive tidal charge. Although a smooth matching between the interior and the static vacuum is not possible due to the breakdown of Birkhoff’s theorem in the braneworld context, we demonstrate that as long as braneworld effects remain significant, the brane tension remains finite, ensuring the scalar curvature to be bounded, thus avoiding the formation of a singularity. I Introduction Gravitational collapse is a fundamental process in astrophysics that determines the final fate of massive stars once their nuclear fuel is exhausted. When the internal pressure is no longer sufficient to counterbalance gravitational attraction, the star undergoes a dramatic contraction. Depending on the star’s mass, this collapse can lead to the formation of compact remnants such as white dwarfs, neutron stars, or black holes. Within the framework of general relativity, gravitational collapse is not merely a dynamical process; it signifies a deep geometrical restructuring of spacetime, potentially giving rise to horizons and singularities where classical descriptions of physics break down. Oppenheimer and Snyder carried out the first exact relativistic analysis of such a collapse in 1939 [ 1 ] . Their model, now known as the Oppenheimer-Snyder (OS) solution, considers the idealized scenario of a spherically symmetric, homogeneous dust cloud undergoing collapse. Assuming vanishing pressure and perfect spherical symmetry, they employed a closed Friedmann–Lemaître–Robertson-Walker (FLRW) metric to describe the cloud’s interior evolution under its own gravity. The exterior region was matched to the Schwarzschild vacuum solution at the boundary of the collapsing matter. Their work showed that such a collapse inevitably leads to the formation of an event horizon and a central singularity, thereby providing a compelling description of black hole formation. Despite its idealized nature, the OS model remains a cornerstone in gravitational physics due to its analytical simplicity and its clear demonstration of relativistic collapse. Adopting an FLRW interior is well-motivated: the assumptions of homogeneity and isotropy naturally lead to an FLRW geometry as a solution to Einstein’s field equations with pressureless matter. Moreover, the spherical symmetry and lack of pressure ensure that Birkhoff’s theorem applies, justifying the use of the Schwarzschild metric in the exterior. The closed (positively curved) FLRW model is particularly suitable, as it represents a spatially finite spherical region, consistent with the physical configuration of the collapsing dust cloud. Nevertheless, the OS model relies on strong idealizations, particularly the assumption of a uniform matter distribution, which is unlikely to be realized in realistic astrophysical conditions. A more general family of solutions, known as the Lemaître–Tolman–Bondi (LTB) models, relaxes the condition of homogeneity while preserving spherical symmetry and zero pressure [ 2 , 3 ] . In these models, the matter density is allowed to vary with the radial coordinates, leading to an inhomogeneous collapse in which different shells contract at different rates. This inhomogeneity introduces a richer causal structure and allows for more intricate singularity formation, including the possibility of naked singularities under certain initial configurations. As a result, LTB models have become essential tools for exploring the cosmic censorship conjecture and the nonlinear behavior of gravitational collapse. The OS and LTB models provide profound insight into the end-states of massive stars and the geometry of a dynamical spacetime. Though based on simplifying assumptions, they successfully capture key qualitative features of general relativistic collapse and continue to serve as critical benchmarks for more sophisticated scenarios involving pressures, angular momentum, or quantum effects. Several recent works have explored extensions of the classical Oppenheimer-Snyder collapse to incorporate quantum gravitational effects and model nonsingular, bouncing compact objects. In [ 4 ] , a thin-shell approach is used to generalize the collapse scenario without committing to a specific mechanism for singularity resolution. The analysis demonstrates that a bounce must occur at or below the horizon formation threshold, thus avoiding the formation of trapped regions under minimal assumptions. This implies that consistent black-to-white hole bounce models may necessitate additional structure, such as an inner horizon. Building on this idea, [ 5 ] employs effective dynamics from loop quantum cosmology (LQC) to model the bounce, matching it to an exterior Schwarzschild geometry with minimal junction conditions. The resulting model features no trapped region and describes a pulsating compact object with both UV and IR cutoffs. While it does not model black-to-white hole transitions, it offers a consistent framework for Planck-scale relics, excluding macroscopic stellar bounces. A more general, model-independent perspective is provided in [ 6 ] , which derives kinematical constraints showing that a bounce must occur in an untrapped region or along a trapping horizon. The work identifies additional dynamical conditions required for effective bounce models and introduces a family of solutions characterized by both classical and quantum parameters. These include bouncing stars, bouncing black holes, and hybrid objects, with an explicit black-to-white hole bounce constructed using spatially closed LQC. Despite differences in their formulations, the three models in [ 4 , 5 , 6 ] converge on several key insights. At their core, each replaces the classical singularity of gravitational collapse with a bounce, allowing for a non-singular evolution of the collapsing matter. A notable consequence shared across these models is the absence of a permanently trapped region; if such a region forms at all, it is only transient or marginal, occurring at most on a trapping horizon. This precludes the development of a classical black hole interior and suggests alternative end states for collapse. The models employ minimal matching conditions, typically connecting a modified (quantum or effective) interior to a classical Schwarzschild exterior via the continuity of the metric across a timelike surface. While a simple bounce scenario is broadly compatible with these assumptions, the realization of a full black-to-white hole transition requires additional structural elements, such as an inner horizon or more detailed quantum corrections, to maintain consistency. Importantly, the physical behavior and interpretation of the bounce depend on several key parameters. These include standard classical quantities, such as mass and radius, as well as quantum parameters introduced through ultraviolet completions, which determine whether the outcome resembles a pulsating object, a bounce near or beyond the Schwarzschild radius, or a transition between black hole and white hole phases. Some constraints, particularly those governing the location of the bounce relative to the formation of trapped regions, emerge as model-independent results, arising directly from geometric and junction conditions. Collectively, these models offer versatile frameworks that not only deepen our theoretical understanding of non-singular collapse but also provide a foundation for future investigations into the phenomenology of quantum gravity in astrophysical contexts. These shared conclusions point toward a coherent picture where quantum gravity-inspired corrections to gravitational collapse lead to non-singular, horizonless (or horizon-marginal) outcomes with potentially observable phenomenology. Braneworld scenarios have attracted significant attention in recent years. A particularly influential model was introduced by Randall and Sundrum (RS) in 1999 [