Quantum Coherence as a Thermodynamic Resource Beyond the Classical Uncertainty Bound
Shanhe Su 1, Cong Fu 1, Ousi Pan 1, Shihao Xia 1, Fei Liu 2, Jincan Chen 1 · 2025
Read Quantum Coherence as a Thermodynamic Resource Beyond the Classical Uncertainty Bound by Shanhe Su 1, Cong Fu 1, Ousi Pan 1, Shihao Xia 1, Fei Liu 2, Jincan Chen 1 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-20873.txt.
Introduction
Shanhe Su leads five co-authors on how quantum togetherness changes heat based doubt bounds, which trade current precision against entropy output in driven systems. Whether genuine quantum effects can loosen or reshape those classical bounds has stayed unsettled.
Their framework folds togetherness into the bounds for open quantum systems with memoryless dynamics, joining a quantum estimation limit with an expansion of the deformed dynamics. The resulting bound carries a togetherness sensitive correction drawn from the off diagonal parts of the state, cleanly split from classical terms. The split shows where quantumness helps precision at a given dissipation cost, a guide for tiny engines and sensors.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Shanhe Su 1, Cong Fu 1, Ousi Pan 1, Shihao Xia 1, Fei Liu 2, Jincan Chen 1 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 23 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-20873
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Quantum Coherence as a Thermodynamic Resource Beyond the Classical Uncertainty Bound Shanhe Su 1, Cong Fu 1, Ousi Pan 1, Shihao Xia 1, Fei Liu 2, Jincan Chen 1 Abstract The precision of nonequilibrium thermodynamic systems is fundamentally limited, yet how quantum coherence shapes these limits remains largely unexplored. A general theoretical framework is introduced that explicitly links quantum coherence to thermodynamic uncertainty relations. By defining a coherence-sensitive measure, it is shown that quantum effects can relax the classical trade-off between the entropy production and the current fluctuations, enabling the precision beyond classical bounds. Application to a three-level quantum maser illustrates the framework in a concrete setting. These results establish quantum coherence as a genuine thermodynamic resource and provide a unified perspective connecting classical and quantum approaches to nonequilibrium thermodynamics. Introduction. —The thermodynamic uncertainty relation (TUR) stands as a key principle of modern thermodynamics, unifying dissipation, fluctuations, and precision in small-scale systems far from equilibrium Barato2015 ; Horowitz2020 ; Miller2021 ; Koyuk2020 ; Macieszczak2018 ; Hasegawa2021 . It formalizes a fundamental trade-off in which achieving high precision in physical currents, such as particle transport, heat conduction, or work extraction, requires a correspondingly large rate of entropy production, reflecting the irreversibility inherent in nonequilibrium processes. In its classical steady-state formulation Barato2015 ; Pietzonka17 ; Koyuk2022 ; Chun2019 ; Koyuk2021 , the TUR is expressed as \frac{D}{J^{2}}\geq\frac{2}{\sigma}, (1) where J denotes the mean current, D characterizes the fluctuations of the current, and \sigma represents the entropy production rate. Throughout this work, we adopt natural units with \hbar=k_{B}=1 . This inequality implies that the relative uncertainty of any current cannot be made arbitrarily small without incurring a thermodynamic cost. In practice, the TUR imposes stringent limits on the energetic efficiency of biomolecular machines, nanoscale electronic devices, and artificial molecular engines, making it a key principle for understanding the operation of systems at the mesoscale Koyuk2021 ; Brandner2025 ; Tajima2021 ; Dieball2023 ; Yoshimura2021 ; Hasegawa2019 ; Hasegawa2021-1 ; Pietzonka2022 ; Hartich2021 . Despite their broad applicability, existing TURs are largely restricted to classical or incoherent quantum regimes, leaving a fundamental question unresolved: what role do genuinely quantum effects play in the cost–precision trade-off? In particular, coherence—a uniquely quantum resource absent in classical systems—can strongly influence energy and charge transport Dong2012 ; Li2015 ; Rodrigues2019 ; Kwon2018 ; Su2018 ; Su2016 . Its precise impact, however, remains unclear: does coherence merely introduce additional noise, tightening the uncertainty bound, or can it be leveraged to surpass classical precision limits without incurring extra thermodynamic cost? Addressing this question is crucial not only for developing a comprehensive framework of quantum thermodynamics but also for guiding the design of quantum devices that harness coherence to achieve enhanced performance. Explicit quantum models, such as the thermoelectric generators Ptaszy=000144ski2018 and three-level masers Kalaee2021 ; Singh2023 , reveal that quantum coherence can overcome the constraints imposed by the power, fluctuations, and entropy production. This insight has motivated a broad search for general quantum extensions of thermodynamic bounds Rignon-Bret2021 ; Cangemi2020 ; Menczel2021 . A quantum thermodynamic uncertainty relation for arbitrary continuous measurements has been derived from the quantum Cramér–Rao inequality, in which the quantum Fisher information is naturally separated into contributions from dynamical activity and coherent dynamics Hasegawa2020 . Finite-time uncertainty bounds, applicable to arbitrary initial states and operation durations, reveal that quantum coherence fundamentally limits precision by amplifying the trade-off between the fluctuations and the energetic cost in generic dissipative systems Vu2022 . A fundamental link has recently been established between the kinetic uncertainty relation and the quantum coherence, where the coherence factor quantifies the incompatibility between the steady-state density matrix and the system Hamiltonian, and the quantum Fisher information scales directly with the dynamical activity Prech2025 . Although quantum coherence can be characterized by various measures Vu2022-1 ; Francica2020 ; Shiraishi2025 ; Camati2016 , the absence of a transparent and physically intuitive quantifier that connects coherence to TURs remains a major unresolved problem. In contrast, within the framework of kinetic uncertainty relation, the role of coherence has been explicitly identified and quantitatively characterized, revealing how quantum superpositions can tighten or relax classical kinetic uncertainty relation Prech2025 . For TURs, however, such a clear correspondence is still missing. Establishing a coherence-based measure that directly captures the quantum contribution to TURs would not only deepen our understanding of how coherence alters the trade-off among the precision, dissipation, and entropy production, but also clarify whether coherence can be regarded as a fundamental thermodynamic resource. Such a development could ultimately lead to a unified picture of uncertainty relations across classical and quantum regimes, where coherence plays a central role in determining the achievable limits of nonequilibrium performance. In this Letter, we present a general theoretical framework that explicitly links quantum coherence to the TUR. Building on recent advances in quantum thermodynamics and information geometry, we introduce a coherence-based quantifier that captures the intrinsic quantum contribution to the trade-off among the precision, dissipation, and entropy production. We demonstrate that quantum coherence can qualitatively reshape—and, in certain regimes, even relax—the classical TUR bound. These results establish the coherence as a fundamental thermodynamic resource that sets the ultimate limits of precision in nonequilibrium quantum systems, offering a unified perspective that bridges classical and quantum uncertainty relations. Thermodynamic uncertainty relation with quantum coherence —To make these ideas concrete, we now formulate the TUR in the presence of quantum coherence. By explicitly incorporating coherence contributions, we demonstrate that coherence can fundamentally reshape the trade-off between the current precision and the thermodynamic cost. In particular, we derive the generalized bound \frac{D}{J^{2}}\geq\frac{2(1+\psi)^{2}}{\sigma}. (2) Following Ref. Prech2025 , we introduce \psi\propto\left[H,\rho_{s}\right] , which characterizes the non-commutativity between the steady-state density matrix \rho_{s} and the system Hamiltonian H . A vanishing commutator implies that the steady state is diagonal in the energy eigenbasis and thus contains no energetic coherence, while a finite \psi directly quantifies the coherence sustained in the steady state. For incoherent processes \psi=0 , the generalized relation reduces to the classical TUR [c.f. Eq. (1)]. However, when coherence is present \left(\psi\neq 0\right) , violations of the classical TUR become possible. In particular, for \psi=-1 , the relation reduces to D/J^{2}\geq 0 , meaning that the lower bound of the TUR completely vanishes. In this extreme case, quantum coherence relaxes the constraint to its weakest form, and the fluctuation–dissipation trade-off is no longer subject to a nontrivial bound. Equation (2) therefore reveals the possibility of surpassing the classical TUR. Because the right-hand side depends on \psi and \sigma , high entropy production is no longer required in order to decrease the fluctuation D . In other words, coherence enables either higher accuracy at a fixed thermodynamic cost or lower entropy production for a given level of precision. These findings highlight the constructive role of coherence in nonequilibrium quantum thermodynamics and provide a general framework for quantifying how quantum features modify fluctuation–dissipation trade-offs. General model —We consider a Markovian open quantum system that is simultaneously coupled to multiple thermal reservoirs maintained at different temperatures. The dynamics of the system are described by the time-dependent density matrix \rho , which evolves according to the Lindblad master equation Breuer2001 ; Rivas2012 ; Alicki2010 ; Liu2018 ; Lindblad1976 ; Alicki1979 : \frac{d}{dt}\rho=\mathcal{L}\rho=-i\left[H,\rho\right]+\sum_{k}\mathcal{D}\left(L_{k},\rho\right). (3) Here,