After 54 years of bar instability studies: a fresh surprise

J. A. Sellwood, Victor P. Debattista, R. G. Carlberg · 2025

Read After 54 years of bar instability studies: a fresh surprise by J. A. Sellwood, Victor P. Debattista, R. G. Carlberg (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-20574.txt.

Introduction

J. A. Sellwood, Victor P. Debattista, and R. G. Carlberg report a surprise in the fifty-four-year study of bar instability in disk galaxy models. Widely cited criteria predict that certain disks embedded in rigid halos should grow a bar, yet their simulations of such disks appeared robustly stable. The explanation is that other instabilities with higher angular symmetry saturated first and changed the disk enough to suppress the bar mode.

That suppression might look like a solution to the long-standing puzzle of stable real disk galaxies, but the authors show it is not. When the rigid halo is replaced by a live population of particles, instability returns and the usual stability conditions apply again. The study covers a narrow model range, leaving other cases open.

Catalog record

CREATORJ. A. Sellwood, Victor P. Debattista, R. G. Carlberg
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE35 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-20574

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

After 54 years of bar instability studies: a fresh surprise J. A. Sellwood, Victor P. Debattista, R. G. Carlberg Abstract The well-known bar instability of rotationally-supported disk galaxy models has been studied extensively since its first discovery over mvhalf a century ago. We were therefore very surprised to find cases of disks embedded in rigid halos, which on the basis of widely-cited criteria should be unstable, that appeared to be robustly stable. Here we show that the unstable bar mode in such simulations was being suppressed by changes to the disk caused by other instabilities having higher angular symmetry that were the first to saturate. Although this may seem like a promising solution to the long-standing puzzle presented by the apparent stability of real disk galaxies, we also show that instability is restored in the same models when the rigid halo is replaced by a live population of particles, where the usual stability conditions apply. Our study has been confined to a narrow range of models, and we cannot therefore exclude the possibility that mode interference may be able to prevent bar formation in other models having live halos. To appear in ApJ I Introduction Hohl 1971 presented perhaps the first careful simulations that revealed the tendency for disk galaxy models to undergo a global instability that rearranged a rotationally-supported disk of stars into a strongly barred configuration. Soon thereafter Ostriker & Peebles 1973 suggested that the survival of nearly axisymmetric disk galaxies may require them to be embedded in a halo of dark matter, provoking many follow up studies in both theory ( e.g. Zang 1976 , Kalnajs 1978 , Toomre 1981 ) and numerical work ( e.g. Combes & Sanders 1981 , Christodoulou et al. 1995 , Athanassoula & Misiriotis 2002 , Debattista et al. 2004 ) that has continued to this day ( Sellwood & Carlberg 2023 , e.g. ) . Despite all these studies, we still lack a widely-accepted explanation for the apparent stability of isolated disk galaxies. It is to be hoped that we may one day identify the explanation for which galaxies do or do not host bars from galaxy formation simulations. These massive experiments (see Feldmann & Bieri 2026 , for a review) , that mimic many physical processes, are increasingly able to synthesize somewhat realistic model disk galaxies, especially those of Milky Way mass, but the fraction of these models that support bars, and their properties, vary widely between the different codes that are employed ( Algorry et al. 2017 ; Zhao et al. 2020 ; Rosas-Guevara et al. 2022 ; Reddish et al. 2022 ; Anderson et al. 2023 ; Fragkoudi et al. 2025 ; Ansar et al. 2024 ; Lu et al. 2025 , e.g. ) . Though studies of isolated galaxies have provided helpful guidance on the evolution of bars ( Ansar et al. 2024 , e.g. ) , the very complexity of the physical processes in the cosmological context have thus far left the experimenters ( Zhou et al. 2020 ; Ansar et al. 2024 , e.g. ) conceding that they are unable to identify the mechanism or properties – star formation and feed back, disk/halo mass fractions, tidal encounters, mergers, etc. – that caused a particular galaxy model to host a bar. Both the algorithms and computer power continue to improve, which it is hoped will eventually enable this question to be answered. In the meantime we pursue a parallel investigation using idealized models in which we have some hope of developing deeper insight into this complicated question of disk dynamics. Efstathiou et al. 1982 undertook a systematic study of a family of galaxy models having an exponential disk of mass M_{d} and radial scale length R_{d} embedded in various rigid halos, and reached the widely-cited conclusion that the disk could avoid forming a bar only if the maximum rotational velocity of the disk material, V_{m}\gtrsim 1.1(GM_{d}/R_{d})^{1/2} . Since the maximum circular speed due to the disk alone is \sim 0.62(GM_{d}/R_{d})^{1/2} ( Freeman 1970 ) , they argued that stable galaxies must be embedded in massive halos to make up the required circular speed. The surprise we report here (§2) is counter examples that violate their stability criterion for a reason that, to our knowledge, has not previously been identified: changes to the equilibrium disk caused by saturation of faster growing spiral modes that disturbed the incipient bar-forming mode halting its linear growth at an early stage. The apparently stable models were reruns of some of those simulated by Sellwood & Carlberg 2023 , but which included force terms from multiple sectoral harmonics. As a result of our discovery, we were greatly concerned that the principal finding from SC23, that all their models were bar unstable, suddenly appeared to be incorrect because it had been based on simulations that were restricted to m=2 only disturbance forces. Suppression of bars by prior saturation of competing modes may seem like a promising solution to the bar-instability problem highlighted by Ostriker & Peebles 1973 and by Efstathiou et al. 1982 . However, we further report here that the apparent stability of our particular disk galaxy models is a numerical artifact resulting from employing rigid halos. Replacing the rigid halo by a similar one composed of mobile particles allowed the disk to form a strong bar, as expected. While this finding suggests that almost all the models studied by SC23 were indeed unstable, as they had claimed, it does not rule out the possibility that disks in other live halo models could be stabilized by similar non-linear changes by faster growing modes. II Models and methods II.1 Rigid halo models The two galaxy models we employ in this section were selected from the set used by SC23. The exponential disk has the surface density profile \Sigma(R)=\Sigma_{0}e^{-R/R_{d}}\quad\hbox{with}\quad\Sigma_{0}={M_{d}\over 2\pi R_{d}^{2}}, (1) where R_{d} is the disk scale length and M_{d} is the nominal mass of the infinite disk. We limit its radial extent using a cubic function to taper the surface density from \Sigma(5R_{d}) to zero at R=6R_{d} . The rotation curve is that of a cored isothermal sphere V_{c}(R)=V_{0}\left[{R^{2}\over R^{2}+r_{c}^{2}}\right]^{1/2}, (2) with r_{c} being the core radius. The implied halo density is whatever is required, when combined with the disk attraction, to achieve this rotation curve in the disk plane ( Fall & Efstathiou 1980 ) . We relate the rotation curve to the disk properties by setting V_{0}=0.9(GM_{d}/R_{d})^{1/2} , and choose r_{c}=R_{d}/2 for model A, as the baseline model of SC23, and r_{c}=R_{d} for model B. Though quite heavy, the disk has less than the required mass to account for the central attraction at all radii. SC23 reported that these two, and nearly all other models in their study, possessed vigorous, global bar instabilities. As usual, we adopt units that G=M_{d}=R_{d}=1 , so a dynamical time is (R_{d}^{3}/GM_{d})^{1/2} , etc. For those who prefer physical units, one possible scaling is to choose R_{d}=2.5\; kpc and the dynamical time to be 10 Myr, which implies M_{d}=3.47\times 10^{10}\; M ⊙ , and a velocity unit (GM_{d}/R_{d})^{1/2}=244.5\; km s -1 . SC23 employed the method proposed by Shu 1969 , with numerical details given in Sellwood 2014 , to create an equilibrium distribution function

Read the complete text