The chemodynamical memory of a major merger in a NIHAO-UHD Milky Way analogue II: Were Splash stars heated or already born hot

Sven Buder, Tobias Buck, Ása Skúladóttir, Melissa Ness, Madeleine McKenzie, andStephanie Monty · 2025

Read The chemodynamical memory of a major merger in a NIHAO-UHD Milky Way analogue II: Were Splash stars heated or already born hot by Sven Buder, Tobias Buck, Ása Skúladóttir, Melissa Ness, Madeleine McKenzie, andStephanie Monty (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-20233.txt.

Introduction

Sven Buder and five co-authors ask whether the Milky Way Splash population was heated by the galaxy last major merger or was already born on hot orbits. Splash stars have disc-like chemistry but halo-like motion, often read as proof of violent heating of an early disc. Using a high-resolution simulation of a Milky Way analogue, they trace birth positions, ages, and present-day orbits of the stars.

The protodisc stars in the simulation were already born moving on dynamically hot orbits, with only limited extra splashing despite a major merger. A subset near the solar neighborhood shows merger-driven redistribution of angular momentum, but the overall pattern changes little. The authors suggest the Splash mainly reflects a turbulent early disc.

Catalog record

CREATORSven Buder, Tobias Buck, Ása Skúladóttir, Melissa Ness, Madeleine McKenzie, andStephanie Monty
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE41 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-20233

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The chemodynamical memory of a major merger in a NIHAO-UHD Milky Way analogue II: Were Splash stars heated or already born hot? Thanks: NIHAO-UHD is the Ultra High Definition re-run of a Milky Way analogue from the Numerical Investigation of a Hundred Astronomical Objects (NIHAO) suite ( Wang et al. 2015 ) . 2026 The chemodynamical memory of a major merger in a NIHAO-UHD Milky Way analogue II: Were Splash stars heated or already born hot? – References Sven Buder, Tobias Buck, Ása Skúladóttir, Melissa Ness, Madeleine McKenzie, andStephanie Monty Abstract One of the most debated consequences of the Milky Way’s last major merger is the so-called Splash : stars with disc-like chemistry but halo-like kinematics, often interpreted as evidence for the violent heating of an early protodisc. Using the same high-resolution NIHAO-UHD cosmological simulation analysed in Buder et al. 2025b , we test whether, and if so how, a Splash-like population arises in the Milky Way analogue. By tracing stellar birth positions, ages, and present-day orbits, we find that protodisc stars were already born on dynamically hot orbits, with no evidence for significant additional dynamical splashing of these particular in-situ stars despite a 1:5 stellar mass merger. The observed Splash may therefore reflect the already turbulent early disc, subsequently intermixed with accreted stars and those formed from merger-driven gas inflows, rather than a distinct merger-heated population. When selecting stars with similar chemistry and age as the Splash-like ones, we find their azimuthal velocity distribution to be broad and positively skewed, with V φ = 73 − 59 + 74 ​ km ​ s − 1 V_{\varphi}=73_{-59}^{+74}\,\mathrm{km\,s^{-1}} . The transition to a rotation-supported disc with large azimuthal velocities occurs only during or after the merger. Our results suggest an alternative to the proposed splashing scenario and highlight the need to disentangle the relative contributions of merger-induced heating and intrinsically hot disc formation to clarify the nature of Splash-like stars and their role in shaping the early Milky Way. 1 Introduction A long-standing goal of Galactic archaeology is to reconstruct how mergers shaped the early Milky Way. Thanks to Gaia astrometry ( Brown 2021 ) and large spectroscopic surveys ( Jofré et al. 2019 ) , it is now clear that our Galaxy experienced at least one major accretion event about 8–10 Gyr ago, commonly referred to as the GSE merger ( Haywood et al. 2018 ; Belokurov et al. 2018 ; Helmi et al. 2018 ; Naidu et al. 2020 ) . This event left an imprint in the stellar halo, and growing evidence suggests that it also influenced a pre-existing disc, dynamically mixing the earliest in-situ populations with accreted debris ( Helmi 2020 ) . One of the most debated signatures of this process is the so-called Splash population ( Belokurov et al. 2020 ; Belokurov & Kravtsov 2022 ) . These stars appear chemically similar to the old, \upalpha -enhanced thick disc, but occupy hotter, halo-like orbits. Their dual nature has made them central to arguments about whether the GSE merger violently heated the protodisc, or whether some old stars were already born on dynamically hot orbits in our Galaxy’s turbulent youth. Observational studies first pointed to an in-situ halo component overlapping with the disc in chemistry. Bonaca et al. 2017 identified metal-rich, prograde halo stars consistent with a heated thick disc origin. Expanding on this, Bonaca et al. 2020 used Gaia DR2 and H3 survey data to argue that disc-like chemistry but halo-like kinematics reflect merger-driven heating, providing a timeline for disc perturbation shortly after GSE . Similarly, Di Matteo et al. 2019 ; Di Matteo et al. 2020 interpreted metal-rich, eccentric stars as evidence that the GSE merger dynamically heated pre-existing disc stars into the halo, strengthening the case that Splash stars trace this violent epoch. Other studies have argued for alternative or complementary origins. In a hydrodynamical simulation of an isolated clumpy disc, Amarante et al. 2020 showed that a Splash-like component can form without mergers: stars scattered by giant clumps during early, turbulent disc phases naturally occupy low-angular-momentum, halo-like orbits, yet remain chemically continuous with the thick disc. More recently, cosmological simulations have broadened the picture. Dillamore et al. 2022 found that Splash-like stars could be a generic feature of Milky Way analogues, while Dillamore et al. 2023 showed that bar resonances can also create halo-like substructures. Extending this, Dillamore & Sanders 2025 demonstrated that secular evolution can reshape integral-of-motion space, complicating attempts to uniquely attribute Splash stars to merger heating. Observationally, Kisku et al. 2025 showed that Splash stars occupy the high- \alpha , high-[Al,K/Fe], low-[Mn/Fe] extension of the thick disc sequence, and, in combination with ARTEMIS simulations ( Font et al. 2020 ) , argued that both major and minor mergers can produce Splash-like signatures, in agreement with the conclusions from the HESTIA simulation by Khoperskov et al. 2023b . A complementary, physically explicit pathway is feedback-driven baryon sloshing in gas-rich discs, which isotropically heats newly formed stars and builds a thick disc without requiring a contemporaneous major heating event ( Bland-Hawthorn et al. 2025 ) Taken together, these studies highlight that Splash stars remain a crucial but unresolved tracer of the Milky Way’s formative history. They may represent violently heated disc stars, stars born hot in a turbulent proto-disc, or a mixture of both, possibly reshaped by subsequent secular evolution. The distinction matters: if Splash stars are heated, they provide a dynamical clock for the last major merger; if they are born hot, they instead reflect the conditions of the early disc, independent of mergers. In Buder et al. 2025b , we used a NIHAO-UHD cosmological simulation of a Milky Way analogue ( Buck 2020 ; Buck et al. 2021 ) to examine the chemodynamical memory of a major merger. 22 focused on the efficiency of recovering accreted stars in integral-of-motion space, the preservation of their birth radii, and chemical evolution. Building on this framework, this work (Paper II) asks whether a Splash-like population emerges in a fully cosmological Milky Way analogue, and if so, whether these stars were heated by the merger or already born hot . Our guiding questions are: 1. Does a distinct Splash population emerge in a high-resolution cosmological simulation? 2. Is this population born in the Milky Way analogue or also/only the GSE -like galaxy that merged with it around 8.6\,\mathrm{Gyr} ago? 3. Are Splash-like stars dynamically heated, or do they form already hot in the turbulent early disc? 4. What does the simulated Splash imply for interpreting the Milky Way’s merger-driven history? 2 Simulation data We use the same high-resolution cosmological zoom-in simulation analysed in 22 , namely the NIHAO-UHD Milky Way analogue g8.26e11 ( Wang et al. 2015 ; Buck et al. 2019 ; Buck et al. 2020 ; Buck et al. 2021 ) . The simulation was performed with the smoothed-particle hydrodynamics code Gasoline2 ( Wadsley et al. 2017 ) , following the NIHAO feedback and enrichment framework ( Stinson et al. 2006 ; Stinson et al. 2013 ; Wang et al. 2015 ) . It adopts a \Lambda CDM cosmology as inferred by Planck Collaboration et al. 2014 and includes metal-line cooling, star formation, and stellar feedback with chemical enrichment from asymptotic

Read the complete text