Discovery of 79 δ \delta Scuti Stars in NGC 3532 Suggests a Decrease of Pulsator Occurrence with Age
Ian Berry, Daniel Huber, Yaguang Li, Daniel Hey, Timothy R. Bedding, Simon J. Murphy · 2025
Read Discovery of 79 δ \delta Scuti Stars in NGC 3532 Suggests a Decrease of Pulsator Occurrence with Age by Ian Berry, Daniel Huber, Yaguang Li, Daniel Hey, Timothy R. Bedding, Simon J. Murphy (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-20048.txt.
Introduction
Ian Berry and five co-authors report the discovery of seventy-nine pulsating delta Scuti stars in the open cluster NGC 3532 using data from the TESS mission. Open clusters are useful here because their stars share one age and one chemical makeup. At three hundred million years old, the cluster holds the largest such group found in a single cluster so far.
About half of the eligible stars in the cluster pulsate, a share well below that in younger populations such as the Pleiades. After correcting for missed stars, the true share is higher but still points to a decline with age. The pulsating stars also spin much faster, which suggests rapid rotation helps keep the pulsations alive.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ian Berry, Daniel Huber, Yaguang Li, Daniel Hey, Timothy R. Bedding, Simon J. Murphy |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 50 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-20048
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Discovery of 79 δ \delta Scuti Stars in NGC 3532 Suggests a Decrease of Pulsator Occurrence with Age Ian Berry, Daniel Huber, Yaguang Li, Daniel Hey, Timothy R. Bedding, Simon J. Murphy Abstract Many A–F type stars do not display δ \delta Scuti pulsations, despite being located within the instability strip. Open clusters provide a unique opportunity to study δ \delta Scuti pulsations among coeval populations with uniform chemical composition. Here we use data from the TESS Mission to discover 79 δ \delta Scuti pulsators in the 300 Myr old open cluster NGC 3532, the largest number found within a single open cluster to-date. We report a 50 ± \pm 5% pulsator fraction in NGC 3532, considerably lower than in younger stellar populations, such the Pleiades (110 Myr), NGC 2516 (100 Myr), and the Cep-Her Complex ( ≤ \leq\, 80 Myr), and similar to the pulsator fraction found among field star samples. We introduce the concept of pulsator occurrence, which corrects for incompleteness, and find it to be 63 ± 6 % \pm 6\% . For the stars that do pulsate, we find that the hotter stars occupy a distinct branch in the color-magnitude diagram (CMD) due to faster rotation ( > >\, 150 km/s) than their non-pulsating counterparts. These results suggest that pulsator occurrence decreases with age and that rapid rotation is important in maintaining δ \delta Scuti pulsations over time. We also investigate the Period-Luminosity (P-L) relation and the ν max \nu_{\rm max} – T eff T_{\rm eff} relation of δ \delta Scuti stars in NGC 3532. We find much scatter in the P-L relation of the dominant mode and two distinct branches in the ν max \nu_{\rm max} – T eff T_{\rm eff} relation, similar to the Cep-Her Complex. I Introduction The \delta Scuti pulsators are spectral type A0-F5 stars on or near the main sequence within the classical Cepheid instability strip, spanning effective temperatures ( T_{\rm eff} ) between \sim 7500 - 9500 K. These stars are known to display high-frequency pressure (p) modes due to internal helium ionization zones, which drive pulsations through cyclical changes in opacity known as the \kappa mechanism ( Dupret et al. 2004 ) . Some instability strip stars are hybrid pulsators, displaying both \delta Scuti pulsations and low-frequency gravity (g) modes associated with the \gamma Doradus pulsators ( Grigahcène et al. 2010 ; Hareter et al. 2010 ; Kurtz et al. 2014 ; Balona 2018 ) . The physics of the driving mechanism of pulsations in \delta Scuti stars remains incompletely understood despite the decades of observations and modeling since the discovery of the prototype ( Campbell & Wright 1900 ) . One lingering issue is that some stars that lie within the instability strip seem not to pulsate at all, contrary to theoretical expectations ( Dupret et al. 2004 ; Dupret et al. 2005 ) . The opposite scenario also seems to be true in certain cases, i.e. stars that appear to fall outside the bounds of the instability strip can show \delta Scuti pulsations ( Uytterhoeven et al. 2011 ; Balona 2018 ; Murphy et al. 2019 ; Gaia Collaboration et al. 2023 , e.g.) . Figure 1: Example amplitude spectra of three \delta Scuti stars in NGC 3532, from aperture photometry (black) and PSF photometry (red). The stars are ordered by Gaia vbroad , and the TIC IDs and Gaia G_{\rm BP}-G_{\rm RP} are provided. This has led to much work in the determination of a \delta Scuti “pulsator fraction”, the ratio of pulsators to the total number of stars in a sample, which appears to vary between different stellar populations/samples. Among field stars, Murphy et al. 2019 used Kepler to measure a maximum 70% pulsator fraction. Read et al. 2024 used the Transiting Exoplanet Survey Satellite ( Ricker et al. 2015 , TESS;) to observe a large sample of field \delta Scuti stars within a narrow color range, and found a higher pulsator fraction among brighter stars compared to fainter stars. This drop in pulsator fraction suggested that detection capabilites/biases may play some part in whether an instability strip star shows \delta Scuti pulsations. Similar results were found by Mani et al. 2025 using a sample of bright TESS stars spanning the width of the instability strip. Physical factors must also govern whether a star within the instability strip pulsates, and these may vary with age. \delta Scuti pulsations require the presence of a helium ionization zone at a specific depth and temperature ( \sim 10,000\,{\rm K} ) in the star in order to drive pulsations through the \kappa mechanism. In slowly rotating stars, helium can sink out of the ionization zone over time ( Baglin et al. 1973 ) , stopping pulsations from the \kappa mechanism. For a 1.6 {\rm M_{\odot}} star with a stellar wind, 50% of helium will be depleted from the ionization zone by 100 Myr, and up to 80% by 500 Myr ( Théado et al. 2005 ; Deal et al. 2016 ) . Therefore, the youngest instability strip stars should still have the necessary helium in the ionization zone to drive pulsations, regardless of other stellar parameters. Figure 2: Stacked amplitude spectra of all 79 \delta Scuti stars in NGC 3532. Darker colors denote larger amplitudes. Stars are ordered by Gaia G_{\rm BP}-G_{\rm RP} , with bluest stars on top. The dashed red line marks 5 {\rm d^{-1}} , which is commonly used as the boundary between \delta Scuti pulsations and other sources of low frequency variability ( Handler & Shobbrook 2002 ; Hareter et al. 2010 ; Murphy et al. 2019 , e.g) . Each amplitude spectrum is labeled with its corresponding star and color (without dereddening). Another astrophysical process affecting the driving of pulsations is rotation. Gravitational diffusion of helium can be easily disrupted by rotational mixing through rapid rotation ( Huang 2004 ) . Recently, Gootkin et al. 2024 found a clear increase in pulsator fraction with increasing rotation rate using a large sample of \delta Scuti pulsators. Similar results were found by Murphy et al. 2024 with \delta Scuti stars in the Cep-Her Complex. Therefore, we may expect to see a relatively high pulsator fraction even in older stellar populations, but we would also expect to see such pulsators as rapid rotators. Such a scenario could be possible as stars above the Kraft Break ( T_{\rm eff}\gtrsim 6200 K) typically do not spin-down significantly during the main sequence ( Kraft 1967 ) . Finally, chemical composition can affect pulsator occurrence. Chemically peculiar Am stars, for example, display strong metal absorption lines. These stars are known to generally be slow rotators, which is thought to allow helium to gravitationally diffuse out of the ionization zone, while allowing for metals to rise to the surface through radiation pressure ( Pamjatnykh 1974 ; Dziembowski 1980 ; Ouazzani et al. 2015 ) . At the same time, these stars appear to have lower pulsation fractions than their non-metallic-lined counterparts ( Breger 1970 ; Guzik et al. 2021 ) . Am stars with \delta Scuti pulsations are known to exist, and the pulsator fraction is indeed low ( Dürfeldt-Pedros et al. 2024 , \sim 13.5\% ;) . Open clusters offer an