Rapid, out of equilibrium metal enrichment indicated by a flat mass-metallicity relation at z ∼ 6 z\sim 6 from NIRCam grism spectroscopy

Gauri Kotiwale ,, Jorryt Matthee, Daichi Kashino, Aswin P. Vijayan, Alberto Torralba, Claudia Di Cesare, Edoardo Iani, Rongmon Bordoloi, Joel Leja, Michael V. Maseda, Sandro Tacchella, Irene Shivaei, Kasper E. Heintz, A. Lola Danhaive, Sara Mascia, Ivan Kramarenko, Benjamín Navarrete, Ruari Mackenzi · 2025

Read Rapid, out of equilibrium metal enrichment indicated by a flat mass-metallicity relation at z ∼ 6 z\sim 6 from NIRCam grism spectroscopy by Gauri Kotiwale ,, Jorryt Matthee, Daichi Kashino, Aswin P. Vijayan, Alberto Torralba, Claudia Di Cesare, Edoardo Iani, Rongmon Bordoloi, Joel Leja, Michael V. Maseda, Sandro Tacchella, Irene Shivaei, Kasper E. Heintz, A. Lola Danhaive, Sara Mascia, Ivan Kramarenko, Benjamín Navarrete, Ruari Mackenzi (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-19959.txt.

Introduction

Gauri Kotiwale and nineteen co-authors measure how metal content scales with galaxy mass when the universe was under a billion years old. They use about eight hundred galaxies picked by their oxygen emission in James Webb Space Telescope grism data. Direct temperature-based metallicities from stacked spectra land between a tenth and a fifth of the Sun's metal content. That holds across the mass range studied, and it agrees with other recent Webb results.

The surprise is the relation's flatness. Low-mass galaxies are more enriched than leading simulations predict, and selection effects cannot explain the difference. Simple modeling suggests metallicity at fixed mass barely depends on star formation rate. That implies enrichment runs out of equilibrium at these epochs, with metals building up rapidly in small galaxies. Larger samples with single-galaxy measurements are needed to confirm the picture.

Catalog record

CREATORGauri Kotiwale ,, Jorryt Matthee, Daichi Kashino, Aswin P. Vijayan, Alberto Torralba, Claudia Di Cesare, Edoardo Iani, Rongmon Bordoloi, Joel Leja, Michael V. Maseda, Sandro Tacchella, Irene Shivaei, Kasper E. Heintz, A. Lola Danhaive, Sara Mascia, Ivan Kramarenko, Benjamín Navarrete, Ruari Mackenzi
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE87 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-19959

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Rapid, out of equilibrium metal enrichment indicated by a flat mass-metallicity relation at z ∼ 6 z\sim 6 from NIRCam grism spectroscopy Gauri Kotiwale ,, Jorryt Matthee, Daichi Kashino, Aswin P. Vijayan, Alberto Torralba, Claudia Di Cesare, Edoardo Iani, Rongmon Bordoloi, Joel Leja, Michael V. Maseda, Sandro Tacchella, Irene Shivaei, Kasper E. Heintz, A. Lola Danhaive, Sara Mascia, Ivan Kramarenko, Benjamín Navarrete, Ruari Mackenzie, Rohan P. Naidu, David Sobral Abstract We aim to characterise the mass-metallicity relation (MZR) and the 3D correlation between stellar mass, metallicity and star-formation rate (SFR) known as the fundamental metallicity relation (FMR) for galaxies at 5 < z < 7 5<z<7 . Using ∼ 800 \sim 800 [O iii ] selected galaxies from deep NIRCam grism surveys, we present our stacked measurements of direct- T e T\rm_{e} metallicities, which we use to test recent strong-line metallicity calibrations. Our measured direct- T e T\rm_{e} metallicities ( 0.1 0.1 – 0.2 ​ Z ⊙ 0.2\,\rm Z_{\odot} for M ⋆ ≈ 5 × 10 7 − 9 \approx 5\times 10^{7-9} M ⊙ , respectively) match recent JWST/NIRSpec-based results. However, there are significant inconsistencies between observations and hydrodynamical simulations. We observe a flatter MZR slope than the SPHINX 20 and FLARES simulations, which cannot be attributed to selection effects. With simple models, we show that the effect of an [O iii ] flux-limited sample on the observed shape of the MZR is strongly dependent on the FMR. If the FMR is similar to the one in the local Universe, the intrinsic high-redshift MZR should be even flatter than observed. In turn, a 3D relation where SFR correlates positively with metallicity at fixed mass would imply an intrinsically steeper MZR. Our measurements indicate that metallicity variations at fixed mass show little dependence on the SFR, suggesting a flat intrinsic MZR. This could indicate that the low-mass galaxies at these redshifts are out of equilibrium and that metal enrichment occurs rapidly in low-mass galaxies. However, being limited by our stacking analysis, we are yet to probe the scatter in the MZR and its dependence on SFR. Large carefully selected samples of galaxies with robust metallicity measurements can put tight constraints on the high-redshift FMR and, help to understand the interplay between gas flows, star formation and feedback in early galaxies. 1 Introduction The gas-phase metallicity of the interstellar medium of galaxies reflects the interplay of gas inflows, feedback, and star formation ( Finlator & Davé 2008 ; Lilly et al. 2013 ; Maiolino & Mannucci 2019 ; Curti 2025 ) . Usually, the gas-phase metallicity is expressed in terms of the oxygen abundance (relative to the hydrogen abundance) as it is the most abundant metal in the Universe. It is most easily observed through strong lines in star-forming regions of galaxies, such as [O ii ] \lambda\lambda 3726,3729 and [O iii ] \lambda\lambda 4960,5008 . Studying the evolution of the gas-phase metallicities of galaxies through cosmic time can tell us about the baryonic mass assembly in the Universe. The relation between gas-phase metallicity ( Z_{\rm gas} ) and stellar mass (M ⋆ ), known as the mass-metallicity relation (MZR), has been extensively studied, spanning from galaxies in the local Universe ( Tremonti et al. 2004 ; Ellison et al. 2008 ; Moustakas et al. 2011 ; Andrews & Martini 2013 ; Curti et al. 2020 ; Scholte et al. 2024 , at z\sim 0 , e.g.) , to those at the peak of cosmic star formation activity (up to z\sim 3 ) ( Shapley et al. 2005 ; Maiolino et al. 2008 ; Mannucci et al. 2009 ; Wuyts et al. 2014 ; Topping et al. 2021 ; Sanders et al. 2021 , e.g.) , and well into to epoch of reionisation using JWST ( Heintz et al. 2023 ; Matthee et al. 2023 ; Nakajima et al. 2023 ; Chemerynska et al. 2024 ; Laseter et al. 2024 ; Curti et al. 2024 ; Sanders et al. 2024 ; Sarkar et al. 2025 ; Chakraborty et al. 2025 ; Morishita et al. 2024 ; Cullen et al. 2025 ; Li et al. 2025 ; Pollock et al. 2025 , e.g. ) . It has been observed that the gas-phase metallicity of galaxies increases with increasing stellar mass, and for z<4 the slope of this trend becomes shallower at higher masses. This trend is explained through gas regulation in galaxies ( Finlator & Davé 2008 ; Peeples & Shankar 2011a ; Davé et al. 2012 ; Lilly et al. 2013 ) . Due to higher stellar masses, the galaxies have a deeper potential well, making the outflow of metal-enriched gas from the galaxy difficult. The metallicity also decreases at fixed stellar mass with increasing redshift. The redshift evolution of the MZR could be due to inflow of metal-poor gas, or outflow of metal-rich gas due to stronger feedback mechanisms at higher redshifts ( Lara-López et al. 2010 ; Bothwell et al. 2013 ; Bothwell et al. 2016 ; Scholte et al. 2024 ) . This evolution has also been studied in terms of the 3D relation between gas-phase metallicity, stellar mass and star-formation rate ( Mannucci et al. 2010 ; Lara-López et al. 2010 ; Andrews & Martini 2013 ; Curti et al. 2020 ) . The scatter in the MZR in the local Universe can be reduced by accounting for variations in the star formation rates (SFR) of galaxies. Galaxies in the local Universe are found to reside on a 2D plane in the M ⋆ - Z_{\rm gas} -SFR space with <0.1 dex scatter. This relation is known as the fundamental metallicity relation (FMR). Multiple studies find that the FMR remains invariant up to z\sim 3 ( Cresci et al. 2012 ; Maier et al. 2015 ; Yabe et al. 2015 ; Topping et al. 2021 ; Sanders et al. 2021 ) . Nakajima et al. 2023 and Sarkar et al. 2025 find no redshift evolution for their sample between 4<z<8 compared to the z=0 FMR, but observe significant deviations at z>8 . Various theoretical models and simulations also explore the FMR in terms of SFR on different spatial scales ( Wang & Lilly 2021a ) and temporal scales ( Torrey et al. 2018a ; Ma et al. 2024 ) , the impact of different feedback mechanisms ( De Rossi et al. 2017 ) , and variations in gas flows and gas fraction ( Dayal et al. 2013 ; Torrey et al. 2019 ) . There are several arguments about whether the FMR exists out to high-redshifts ( Zahid et al. 2014 ; Heintz et al. 2023 ; Curti et al. 2024 ; Scholte et al. 2025 ; Cullen et al. 2025 , e.g.) . If truly fundamental, the shape of the FMR plane does not evolve – only the relative positions of the galaxy population on the plane shifts. Simulations suggest that the existence of the plane depends on the time-scales of SFR variability ( Torrey et al. 2018a ; Ma et al. 2024 , e.g.) . Given that the star formation histories of high- z galaxies appear more bursty ( Topping et al. 2022 ; Endsley et al. 2023 ; Looser et al. 2025 , e.g.) ,

Read the complete text