Covariant phase space and the semi-classical Einstein equation
Abhirup Bhattacharya, Onkar Parrikar · 2025
Read Covariant phase space and the semi-classical Einstein equation by Abhirup Bhattacharya, Onkar Parrikar (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-19939.txt.
Introduction
Abhirup Bhattacharya and Onkar Parrikar generalize the covariant phase space formalism of general relativity to gravity coupled to quantum matter. In its classic form, the method builds the symplectic form, Hamiltonian, and conserved charges directly from a theory's solutions. For the semi-classical Einstein equation, where quantum matter sources classical gravity, no such construction existed.
The authors define a semi-classical symplectic form as the gravitational form plus the Berry curvature of the matter's quantum state. They show it does not depend on the choice of time slice. It also obeys a quantum version of the Hollands-Iyer-Wald identity. For small perturbations they extend the construction to spacetime subregions. In the AdS/CFT context, the form is dual to Berry curvature in the boundary theory.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Abhirup Bhattacharya, Onkar Parrikar |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 88 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-19939
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Covariant phase space and the semi-classical Einstein equation Abhirup Bhattacharya, Onkar Parrikar Abstract The covariant phase space formalism in general relativity is a covariant method for constructing the symplectic two-form, Hamiltonian and other conserved charges on the phase space of solutions to the Einstein equation with classical matter. In this note, we consider a generalization of this formalism to the semi-classical Einstein equation coupled to quantum matter. Given a family of solutions in semi-classical gravity, we define the semi-classical symplectic two-form – a natural generalization of the classical sympelctic two-form – as the sum of the gravitational symplectic form and the Berry curvature associated to the quantum state of matter. We show that the semi-classical symplectic two-form is independent of the Cauchy slice, and satisfies the quantum generalization of the classical Hollands-Iyer-Wald identity. For small perturbations, we also extend our discussion to gauge-invariantly defined subregions of spacetime, where the quantum contribution is replaced by the Berry curvature of certain special purifications involving the Connes cocycle. In the AdS/CFT context, the semi-classical symplectic form defined here is naturally dual to the Berry curvature in the boundary CFT. 1 Introduction The covariant phase space formalism crnkovic1987covariant provides a manifestly covariant way ( i.e. , without picking a time coordinate) to think about the classical phase space of solutions to the Einstein equation with its associated symplectic structure, Hamiltonian and other conserved charges. The formalism has found many important applications – two significant examples include Iyer and Wald’s generalization of the the Bekenstein-Hawking area formula for black hole entropy to higher derivative theories of gravity Wald:1993nt ; Iyer:1994ys ; Iyer:1995kg , and Wald and Zoupas’ general formulation of the notion of conserved charges in general relativity Wald:1999wa . More recent developments have used the formalism to study the stability of black hole solutions under perturbations Hollands:2012sf , and to propose new definitions of dynamical black hole entropy Hollands:2024vbe ; Wall:2015raa . The formalism has also found a wide variety of applications in the context of the AdS/CFT correspondence, such as the proof of the equality of bulk and boundary relative entropies Jafferis:2015del , derivations of Einstein’s equation from entanglement in the boundary CFT Faulkner:2013ica ; Faulkner:2017tkh ; Haehl:2017sot ; Dong:2017xht ; Lewkowycz:2018sgn ; Haehl:2019fjz , proofs of gravitational positive energy theorems from CFT entropic inequalities Lashkari:2016idm , and the derivation of the bulk dual of boundary Berry curvature at large- N Belin:2018fxe ; Belin:2018bpg . Beyond AdS/CFT, the covariant phase space formalism has been used to investigate near horizon symmetries of black holes Flanagan:2015pxa ; Hawking:2016msc ; Hawking:2016sgy ; Haco:2018ske , asymptotic symmetries and surface charges in general relativity Chandrasekaran:2021hxc ; Chandrasekaran:2021vyu ; Ciambelli:2021nmv ; Ciambelli:2022cfr ; Ciambelli:2022vot , soft theorems He:2020ifr ; He:2023bvv , and entanglement edge modes in gauge theories Donnelly:2016auv ; Balasubramanian:2018axm . Many of the results mentioned above work in the context of classical general relativity coupled to classical matter. In particular, the matter contributes to the symplectic two-form on phase space, and the total (gravity plus matter) symplectic form can be defined without choice of a Cauchy surface. It is natural to wonder whether this formalism finds a natural generalization to semi-classical gravity. In semi-classical gravity, one treats matter quantum mechanically and finds the metric by solving the semi-classical Einstein equation: R_{ab}-\frac{1}{2}R\,g_{ab}+\Lambda\,g_{ab}=8\pi G_{N}\langle\psi|T_{ab}|\psi\rangle, (1) where the right hand side involves the expectation value of the matter stress tensor. It is usually inconsistent to treat a physical system part classically and part quantum mechanically, so what is really being said here is that to a good approximation in the G_{N}\to 0 limit, the metric can be taken to be in a coherent state, while the matter can be in some more general quantum state. In order to have significant backreaction in this limit, a standard trick Flanagan:1996gw is to introduce a large matter central charge c , so that back-reaction is controlled by the parameter \epsilon=c\,G_{N} . The semi-classical approximation has found a large number of applications; some recent applications include Page curve calculations for evaporating black holes Fiola:1994ir ; Engelhardt:2014gca ; Almheiri:2019psf ; Penington:2019npb , constructing endpoints of the super-radiant instabilities of rotating and charged black holes Kim:2023sig ; Choi:2024xnv , bulk reconstruction Levine:2020upy ; Soni:2024oim , singularity theorems Bousso:2025xyc etc. The purpose of this note is to generalize the covariant phase space formalism to semi-classical gravity. We imagine that we are given a family \mathcal{P}_{\text{q}} of solutions (g_{ab}(\lambda^{i}),\psi(\lambda^{i})) to the semi-classical Einstein equation, where \lambda^{i} are some parameters, which we can think of as coordinates on the space of these solutions. A concrete setting to have in mind is asymptotically AdS spacetimes, where the role of the parameters \lambda^{i} is played by the sources for various single/multi-trace operators in the boundary CFT; this is the setting we will focus on through most of this paper. We propose that the space \mathcal{P}_{\text{q}} also admits a natural, closed two form, which we call the semi-classical symplectic form , given by \mathsf{F}=\Omega_{\text{grav.}}+\mathsf{f}, (2) where \Omega_{\text{grav.}} is the symplectic 2-form associated with classical metric deformations, while \mathsf{f} is the Berry curvature associated with the quantum matter: \mathsf{f}=\delta\mathsf{a},\;\;\;\mathsf{a}=-i\langle\psi|\delta\psi\rangle, (3) where \delta=\sum_{i}d\lambda^{i}\frac{\partial}{\partial\lambda^{i}} is the exterior derivative on \mathcal{P}_{\text{q}} . We will show that the semi-classical symplectic form \mathsf{F} defined in this way is indepdendent of the choice of Cauchy slice, and indeed reduces to the classical matter symplectic form when the matter is taken to be in a coherent state. Furthermore, given some asymptotically Killing vector field \zeta , we show that the semi-classical symplectic form is invariant under the corresponding diffeomorphism. We show how to construct a corresponding charge H_{\zeta} (including classical plus the appropriate quantum corrections coming from matter) which satisfies -I_{V_{\zeta}}\mathsf{F}=\delta H_{\zeta}. (4) This is essentially the statement that the charge H_{\zeta} generates the action of the diffeomorphism \zeta on phase space. This identity is sometimes referred to as the Hollands-Iyer-Wald identity in the classical gravity context, and here we generalize it to semi-classical gravity. For small perturbations around a background metric and state, we also extend our discussion to the case of gauge-invariantly defined subregions in gravity, where the role of the matter contribution is played by the Berry curvature of a certain purification of the subregion state involving the Connes cocycle. In the AdS/CFT context, it was argued in Belin:2018fxe ; Belin:2018bpg that in the large- N limit, if we take the parameters \lambda^{i} to be O(N^{2}) classical sources for single-trace operators, then the Berry curvature of the boundary CFT is dual to the symplectic form of the corresponding bulk matter fields. It is natural to try to extend this to more general sources, including O(1) sources for multi-trace operators. In this context, the bulk is more appropriately described within the realm of semi-classical gravity with quantum matter. We argue that our semi-classical symplectic form is the natural bulk dual to the boundary Berry curvature within the semi-classical gravity approximation, i.e., not including corrections from quantum gravity and non-perturbative effects. Thus, the semi-classical symplectic form that we define fits naturally within the AdS/CFT dictionary. The rest of the paper is organized as follows: in section 2 , we review the covariant phase space formalism for gravity coupled to classical matter. In section 3 , we construct and study