Determining the Hubble Constant through Cross-Correlation of Galaxies and Gravitational Waves
Jiaming Pan, Dragan Huterer, Camille Avestruz, Damon H. T. Cheung, Emery Trott, Neal Dalal, Donghui Jeong · 2025
Read Determining the Hubble Constant through Cross-Correlation of Galaxies and Gravitational Waves by Jiaming Pan, Dragan Huterer, Camille Avestruz, Damon H. T. Cheung, Emery Trott, Neal Dalal, Donghui Jeong (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-19931.txt.
Introduction
Jiaming Pan and six co-authors quantify how well cross-correlating gravitational wave sources with galaxies could measure the Hubble constant. Standard sirens promise a distance-ladder-free route to the expansion rate, but most events have no identified light counterpart and hence no redshift. For these dark sirens, statisticians can still correlate their sky distribution with galaxy catalogs to recover redshift information.
The study asks what it will take to reach percent-level precision on the Hubble constant. The answer: distance uncertainties near ten percent, a catalog of at least about five thousand dark sirens, and accurate sky localization in the tomographic analysis. Constraints will be limited mainly by the quantity and quality of gravitational wave data, the authors find.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jiaming Pan, Dragan Huterer, Camille Avestruz, Damon H. T. Cheung, Emery Trott, Neal Dalal, Donghui Jeong |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 67 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-19931
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Determining the Hubble Constant through Cross-Correlation of Galaxies and Gravitational Waves Preprint: APS/123-QED Jiaming Pan, Dragan Huterer, Camille Avestruz, Damon H. T. Cheung, Emery Trott, Neal Dalal, Donghui Jeong Abstract Gravitational wave (GW) standard sirens have the potential to measure the Hubble constant H 0 H_{0} in the local universe independently of the distance ladder, and thus offer unique new insights into the Hubble tension. A key challenge with standard sirens is detecting their electromagnetic counterparts, and therefore assigning redshifts to the measured distances. One promising way to proceed is to utilize GW ‘dark sirens’ – events without an identified electromagnetic counterpart – and cross-correlate their angular distribution with that of galaxies. We present a quantitative study of how precisely the Hubble constant can be measured using tomographic cross-correlation between galaxies and GW sources. Overall, we find that the constraints on H 0 H_{0} will be limited by the quality and quantity of GW data. We find that percent-level constraints on H 0 H_{0} will primarily depend on achieving small distance uncertainties ( σ d L = 0.1 d L \sigma_{d_{L}}=0.1\,d_{L} ), obtaining a large number of GW dark sirens ( ≳ \gtrsim 5,000 5{,}000 ), and accurate sky localization in the tomographic analysis. I Introduction Precise measurements of cosmological parameters from an impressive array of probes have significantly refined our understanding of the Universe’s expansion. Despite these successes, accurately determining the Hubble constant ( H_{0} ) remains a central task in cosmology. Measurements based on nearby type Ia supernovae ”anchored” by absolute distances coming from Cepheid variables yield H_{0} with nearly a percent-level uncertainty Riess et al. 2021 . Conversely, multiple cosmological measurements at higher redshifts, including analyses of the cosmic microwave background ( CMB), big bang nucleosynthesis, and baryon acoustic oscillations, provide a much lower value of H_{0} , with measurements that are mutually consistent Alam et al. 2021 ; Aghanim et al. 2020 ; Abdul Karim et al. 2025 ; Louis et al. 2025 and robust with respect to frequently studied extensions of the cosmological models beyond \Lambda CDM Calabrese et al. 2025 ; Abdul Karim et al. 2025 . This disagreement between local and global measurements constitutes the so-called “Hubble tension”, whose statistical significance reaches or exceeds 5\sigma Freedman 2017 ; Verde et al. 2019 ; Knox and Millea 2020 ; Di Valentino et al. 2021 . While the global measurements come from a variety of cosmological probes with different physical dependencies on H_{0} , the local measurements are uniquely based on nearby distance indicators. This implies an urgent need for alternate measurements at low redshift that could confirm or refute the higher value of H_{0} presently inferred from the distance ladder. Given that the difference between the distance ladder and global measurements is about 6\,\mathrm{km\,s^{-1}\,Mpc^{-1}} or \sim 10% of the Hubble constant, it has become clear that a percent-level independent measurement of H_{0} will be required to decisively weigh in on the Hubble tension. Gravitational wave (GW) standard sirens have recently emerged as a promising alternative for directly inferring cosmological parameters Schutz 1986 ; Holz and Hughes 2005 . GW events, primarily from binary black hole (BBH) mergers Abbott et al. 2023a , provide direct measurements of luminosity distances inferred from gravitational waveform. After assigning redshifts to GW observations by observing their respective electromagnetic (EM) counterparts, the value of H_{0} can be inferred Nissanke et al. 2013 ; Abbott et al. 2017 . However, most GW events do not have a corresponding detection of an EM counterpart; these events are commonly referred to as “dark sirens” Finn 1994 ; MacLeod and Hogan 2008 ; Messenger and Read 2012 ; Del Pozzo 2012 . It is nevertheless possible in principle to extract H_{0} from dark sirens by statistically matching the location of each GW event to a number of galaxies that reside in the corresponding localization region on the sky. Conventionally, such dark siren analyses employ a Bayesian framework to integrate likelihoods from both EM observations and GW events Chen et al. 2018 ; Soares-Santos et al. 2019 ; Palmese et al. 2020 ; Palmese et al. 2023 ; Alfradique et al. 2024 ; Gair et al. 2023 . This approach relies on statistically matching up potential host galaxies for each GW event, but may be biased unless an extremely precise localization of dark sirens is available Trott and Huterer 2023 ; Hanselman et al. 2025 ; Alfradique et al. 2025 ; Zazzera et al. 2025 . Another approach is the so-called “spectral siren” method, which infers redshifts distribution from features in the compact binary mass spectrum rather than from host galaxies Chernoff and Finn 1993 ; Taylor and Gair 2012 ; Farr et al. 2019 ; You et al. 2021 ; Mastrogiovanni et al. 2021 ; Ezquiaga and Holz 2022 ; Mali and Essick 2025 . While promising in principle, this method can become strongly degenerate with H_{0} if the those spectral features in the source evolve with redshift. In such cases, the nuisance evolution can mimic the H_{0} response, inflating \sigma(H_{0}) and erasing the H_{0} information in the fully degenerate limit. We illustrate this behavior with a simple toy model in Appendix A . This limitation motivates the alternative we pursue in this paper. The most promising known alternative to standard candles is to use the standard sirens to constrain the Hubble constant. While this is much more straightforward for the bright sirens than for the dark ones, a good way to proceed in the latter case is to cross-correlate these GW events with a population of galaxies. This has the major advantage that it does not require matching up GW events with their potential host galaxies (and letting the galaxies “vote”, as in the standard dark-siren approach described above). This approach exploits the fact that both populations, GW and galaxies, trace the same underlying matter density field, so they are guaranteed to correlate, and this correlation is expected to be simple on sufficiently large scales where biases of tracers of the large-scale structure are linear. Therefore spatial cross-correlation between the GW events and galaxies can directly measure H_{0} Ferri et al. 2025 ; Oguri 2016 ; Bera et al. 2020 ; Mukherjee et al. 2024 ; Ghosh et al. 2025 ; Diaz and Mukherjee 2022 ; Pedrotti et al. 2025 ; Beltrame et al. 2024 ; Scelfo et al. 2018 . Additionally, systematics of how each GW event corresponds to EM galaxies in the standard dark-siren analysis are treated much more simply in the cross-correlation approach than in the standard per-event analysis which employs various astrophysical efficiency and correction factors (e.g., Abbott et al. 2021 ). Therefore, the cross-correlation approach has the potential to simplify and make more robust the determination of H_{0} from dark sirens. In this paper we systematically explore the efficacy of the galaxy–GW cross-correlation method to constrain H_{0} . Our analysis investigates the impact on the forecasted H_{0} precision of a variety of observational and modeling assumptions, including the choice of tomographic binning, the uncertainty in GW distance measurements, the number density of dark siren events, their redshift range and distribution, and the angular localization errors—on the statistical errors. A detailed discussion of these assumptions and their implementation