An accurate measure of the size of dark matter halos using the size of galaxies
Claudio Dalla Vecchia ,, Ignacio Trujillo · 2025
Read An accurate measure of the size of dark matter halos using the size of galaxies by Claudio Dalla Vecchia ,, Ignacio Trujillo (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-19926.txt.
Introduction
Claudio Dalla Vecchia and Ignacio Trujillo show that a galaxy's visible size can measure the size of its invisible dark matter halo far more accurately than before. The trick uses a physically motivated definition of galaxy size, tied to where in-place star formation reaches, which tightens the galaxy mass-size relation. Working with simulated galaxies from the EAGLE cosmological volumes, they reproduce the observed relation closely.
Relating galaxy size to halo size for central galaxies gives a correlation with half the scatter of the observed one when older size measures are used. The implied halo sizes carry errors under fifty percent, about six times better than estimates from effective radius. Deep imaging alone, the authors argue, can therefore weigh and size dark matter halos surprisingly well.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Claudio Dalla Vecchia ,, Ignacio Trujillo |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 44 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-19926
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
An accurate measure of the size of dark matter halos using the size of galaxies Claudio Dalla Vecchia ,, Ignacio Trujillo Abstract The physically motivated definition of galaxy size proposed recently, linked to the farther location of the in-situ star formation, considerably reduces the scatter of the galaxy mass–size relation, and provide a viable method to infer the galaxy stellar mass from its size. We provide a similar relation correlating the size of galaxies with the size of their dark matter haloes by leveraging the small scatter of the aforementioned relation. We analysed the simulated galaxies of the two main cosmological volumes of the EAGLE simulations, and computed the size of galaxies and their mass mimicking the observational analysis. For central galaxies, we computed the relation between galaxy size and halo size. We show that the simulated galaxies reproduce the observed stellar mass–size relation’s normalization and slope. The scatter of this relation, 0.06 dex 0.06\penalty\ \mathrm{dex} , matches the intrinsic scatter measured in observation. We then computed the correlation between galaxy size and halo size, and found that the relation is steeper than when using the half-mass radius as measure of size, with the scatter ( 0.1 dex ) (0.1\penalty\ \mathrm{dex}) a factor of two smaller than the observed relation. As well, the galaxy-to-halo mass relation derived from simulations provides a factor of two better scatter than observed. This opens the possibility of measuring the size of dark matter haloes with great accuracy (less than fifty percent, i.e. around six times better than using the effective radius) by using only deep imaging data. 1 Introduction A physically motivated definition of galaxy size, given by the farthest radial location where gas could efficiently collapse and turn into stars, was proposed by Trujillo et al. 2020 . As a proxy for measuring this position, these authors suggest using the radial location of a stellar mass density contour at 1\penalty\ \mathrm{M}_{\odot}\,\mathrm{pc}^{-2} , denoted R_{1} . This measure is consistent with the gas density threshold for star formation derived theoretically by Schaye 2004 . The use of 1\penalty\ \mathrm{M}_{\odot}\,\mathrm{pc}^{-2} was calibrated using deep observations of Milky Way-sized galaxies at z\sim 0 , and provides a more representative boundary for galaxies than traditional metrics such as the effective radius, R_{\mathrm{e}} ( Sérsic 1968 ) . Using this definition over a wide range of stellar masses (from 10^{7} to 10^{12}\penalty\ \text{M}_{\odot} ) significantly reduces the scatter in the stellar mass–size relation to about 0.06 dex, outperforming conventional measures such as R_{\mathrm{e}} and the Holmberg radius, R_{\mathrm{H}} ( Holmberg 1958 ) . Even though R_{1} is only a proxy to characterize the physical radius where in-situ star formation is or has been taking place, the enormous reduction in the scatter of the stellar mass–size relation underscores the robustness of R_{1} as a galaxy size metric. The results of using R_{1} also reveal clear trends within the stellar mass–size relation. Galaxies with stellar masses between 10^{7} and 10^{11}\penalty\ \text{M}_{\odot} follow a consistent power-law relationship with a slope of around 1/3. Across the range of galaxy stellar masses studied, the scatter is consistently small ( \sim 0.06 dex), providing an accurate measure of the galaxy’s stellar mass by knowing only its physical size. Observed disc galaxies follow the relation R_{1}\propto M_{\star}^{1/3} over several order of magnitudes in stellar mass. A similar relation has been proposed for neutral hydrogen by Broeils & Rhee 1997 : the mass–size relation for neutral hydrogen is M_{\text{H\,{i}}}\propto D_{\text{H}\,\textsc{i}}^{2} , where D_{\text{H}\,\textsc{i}} is the diameter of the neutral hydrogen disc of spiral galaxies. Wang et al. 2016 , using the observations of 500 galaxies, showed that this correlation holds tight irrespectively of galaxy luminosity, fraction of neutral gas and morphology, with a scatter of also 0.06\penalty\ \mathrm{dex} . This points to the non-trivial interplay of gas accretion, efficiency of star formation and stellar feedback in maintaining the two mass–size relations over several orders of magnitude in stellar mass. Chamba et al. 2022 tested the validity of the hypothesis of using R_{1} as an indicator of the radius up to which in-situ star formation has occurred. To do this, they identified the position of the stellar edge of galaxies, R_{\mathrm{edge}} , as the outermost cut-off or truncation in their stellar mass radial profile, using deep multi-band optical imaging, verified that it corresponds to a change in the radial colour profile and surface brightness profile, and measured what stellar mass surface density it corresponds to. Chamba et al. 2022 find that for galaxies with masses similar to the Milky Way, R_{\mathrm{edge}}\sim R_{1} ( Golini et al. 2025 , see also) . For lower-mass galaxies (dwarfs) or more massive galaxies (ellipticals), the surface mass density of the galaxy edge is slightly different from 1\penalty\ \mathrm{M}_{\odot}\,\mathrm{pc}^{-2} . It is smaller by a factor of about two for low-mass galaxies and larger by a factor of about three for massive elliptical galaxies. Be that as it may, within a range of five orders of magnitude in stellar mass, the approximation of using R_{1} as an indicator of galaxy size is quite good, and its practical implementation is straightforward. One of the main results of Trujillo et al. 2020 is that as long as the definition of galaxy size includes most of the stellar mass, the mass–size relation should have a small scatter ( Miller et al. 2019 , e.g.) . Sánchez Almeida 2020 has shown that, for a fixed stellar mass, stellar profiles with different Sérsic index all cross at similar stellar mass surface density, and concluded that this explains the small scatter when using R_{1} as size. In a subsequent paper, Buitrago & Trujillo 2024 studied the evolution of the stellar mass–size relation with redshift for a sample of Milky Way-like galaxies, directly measuring R_{\mathrm{edge}} (instead of R_{1} ) of galaxies up to z=1 . They showed that the edge is located at higher stellar surface densities at higher redshift, and that disc galaxies of the same stellar mass are smaller with increasing redshift, with their size inversely proportional to (1+z) . This shows that using R_{1} as a proxy for galaxy size is only a valid option at z\sim 0 . The dependence of galaxy size on redshift reveals the connection between the growth of the dark matter halo and the galaxy disc, the former growing in size with the same redshift scaling ( Navarro et al. 1997 ) . In a companion paper, Arjona-Gálvez et al. 2025 show that, using R_{1} as definition of size, galaxies extracted from a variety of zoom-in simulations performed with different models for galaxy formation, all share the same mass–size relation. When studying its evolution in simulations, the relation does not change with redshift, rather galaxies move on the relations as they grow in mass and size. The difference between this and the observations of Buitrago & Trujillo 2024 is that the stellar surface density threshold is kept fixed with redshift in the analysis, whilst observations show that the stellar surface density at which disc truncation is observed is larger at higher redshift. What the simulations have in common is that their star formation models all try to reproduce the observed (local) Kennicutt-Schmidt law and its surface density threshold for