The long-term effects of gas removal from hydrodynamic simulations of star formation The long-term effects of gas removal from hydrodynamic simulations of star formation – References 2025
Aleksandra Ćalović, Katerina S. Klos, Robert B. Hudson, James E. Dale, Richard J. Parker · 2025
Read The long-term effects of gas removal from hydrodynamic simulations of star formation The long-term effects of gas removal from hydrodynamic simulations of star formation – References 2025 by Aleksandra Ćalović, Katerina S. Klos, Robert B. Hudson, James E. Dale, Richard J. Parker (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-19903.txt.
Introduction
Aleksandra Calovic and four co-authors revisit a standard story about young star clusters. The story says feedback from massive stars blows the leftover gas away. The sudden loss of gravity then makes the cluster fly apart within ten million years. Earlier studies mostly modeled this with simplified background potentials. Here the stars instead inherit their motions directly from hydrodynamic star formation simulations, with and without feedback.
Evolving those end states as N-body systems, the team found the clusters behave much like systems in virial equilibrium. They do not show the expected supervirial expansion. Rescaling stellar velocities, to mimic faster or slower gas removal, changed little. Gas removal, they conclude, does not by itself drive rapid dispersal beyond ordinary dynamical relaxation.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Aleksandra Ćalović, Katerina S. Klos, Robert B. Hudson, James E. Dale, Richard J. Parker |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 65 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-19903
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The long-term effects of gas removal from hydrodynamic simulations of star formation The long-term effects of gas removal from hydrodynamic simulations of star formation – References 2025 Aleksandra Ćalović, Katerina S. Klos, Robert B. Hudson, James E. Dale, Richard J. Parker Abstract The removal of gas left over from star formation has long been thought to dominate the dynamical evolution, and dissolution of star-forming regions. Feedback from massive stars from their stellar winds, photoionising radiation and supernovae is postulated to expel significant amounts of gas, altering the gravitational potential energy of the star-forming region and causing a supervirial expansion, which disperses the stars into the Galaxy on rapid timescales ( < < 10 Myr). The majority of previous work has utilised N N -body simulations with a background potential to model the effects of gas removal. Here, we adopt a different approach where we take the end point of hydrodynamic simulations of star formation in which stars form with and without feedback from massive stars and then evolve the stars as N N -body simulations. We also scale the velocities of the stars to various virial ratios, to mimic slower or faster removal of gas, and evolve these as additional N N -body simulations. We find that the simulations where the stars inherit the velocities of the sink particles from the hydrodynamic simulations predominantly evolve more like a simulation in virial equilibrium, rather than the supervirial behaviour we would expect after gas removal. We see no significant differences in the dynamical evolution between the simulations where the stars inherit velocities directly from the hydrodynamical simulations and the simulations with (sub)virial velocities. This strongly suggests that gas removal by feedback processes does not lead to rapid expansion of star-forming regions, beyond the expansion caused by dynamical relaxation in star-forming regions. 1 Introduction Stars do not form in isolation, but rather in groups containing tens, to tens of thousands of stars ( Lada & Lada 2003 ; Bressert et al. 2010 ) , and the stellar density in these groups exceeds that in the Galactic disc by several orders of magnitude ( Korchagin et al. 2003 ) . Depending on the environmental conditions, these groups may coalesce into larger structures that are either gravitationally bound ( Portegies Zwart et al. 2010 ; Kruijssen 2012 ; Longmore et al. 2014 , often referred to as ‘star clusters’, e.g.) , or unbound ( Blaauw 1964 ; Wright 2020 ; Wright et al. 2022 , often referred to as ‘associations’, e.g.) . In spite of this, star formation is an inherently inefficient process, with only a fraction of the gas in a Giant Molecular Cloud being converted into stars. This means that a significant constituent of the gravitational potential is the leftover gas. Many authors have posited that feedback (stellar winds, photoionising radiation, supernovae) will disperse the remaining gas, which changes the dynamical equilibrium of the stars, causing the star-forming region to expand and disperse ( Tutukov 1978 ; Whitworth 1979 ; Lada et al. 1984 ; Goodwin 1997 ; Kroupa et al. 2001 ; Baumgardt & Kroupa 2007 ; Pfalzner et al. 2015 ; Shukirgaliyev et al. 2018 , e.g.) . The efficacy of gas removal/expulsion is the subject of intense debate in the literature. Bastian & Goodwin 2006 and Goodwin & Bastian 2006 demonstrated that the velocity dispersions in star clusters are consistent with a supervirial state, i.e. they appear to be in the process of dynamical destruction from the gas removal. However, Gieles et al. 2010 pointed out that these supervirial velocity dispersions are likely to be inflated due to hidden binaries, and Kruijssen et al. 2012 demonstrated that the local star formation efficiency in simulations is close to 100 per cent, so any residual gas expulsion does not affect the virial state of the stellar groups. With the advent of Gaia observations and complementary ground-based spectroscopic surveys, further studies have suggested that some star-forming regions appear to be undergoing expansion ( Bravi et al. 2018 ; Kounkel et al. 2018 ) , and these authors attribute this expansion to feedback from the massive stars. A major problem with theoretical studies of the effects of gas removal on star-forming regions is that hydrodynamic simulations only follow the first few Myr of a GMC’s evolution ( Dale et al. 2012 ; Dale et al. 2014 ; Bate 2014 , e.g.) and cannot follow the long-term effects of gas removal on the later dynamical evolution of the region, unless the sink particles/stars are extracted and run as an N -body or hybrid N -body/hydrodynamic simulation. Some simulations ( Hubber et al. 2013 ; Sills et al. 2018 ; Karam & Sills 2023 ; Karam et al. 2025 ) couple low-resolution SPH and N -body simulations to achieve a more self-consistent view of star formation, but these simulations do not yet model very massive star formation from the gas. An alternative approach is to take the output of hydrodynamical simulations in which feedback is present and then evolve the stars as an N -body simulation ( Moeckel & Bate 2010 ; Parker & Dale 2013 ; Torniamenti et al. 2022 ; Farias et al. 2024 ; Bernard et al. 2025 ). The drawback of this approach is that the leftover gas is usually removed immediately prior to the N -body evolution (as in Moeckel & Bate 2010 and Parker & Dale 2013 ; however another approach ( Farias et al. 2024 , e.g.) is to replace the gas from the hydrodynamic simulation with a background potential in the subsequent N -body evolution). In principle, this should have a similar effect to the removal of a static background gas potential in N -body simulations ( Goodwin & Bastian 2006 ; Adams et al. 2006 ; Baumgardt & Kroupa 2007 ) , whereby the clusters immediately undergo a rapid expansion phase ( Pfalzner & Kaczmarek 2013 ; Pfalzner et al. 2015 ) . A possible difference between the approaches of including the gas as a background potential in an N -body simulation ( Goodwin & Bastian 2006 ; Baumgardt & Kroupa 2007 ; Pfalzner & Kaczmarek 2013 ) or modelling the later N -body evolution of stars formed in an SPH simulation ( Moeckel & Bate 2010 ; Parker & Dale 2013 ; Parker & Dale 2017 ) is that the stars in the latter type of simulation were not fully decoupled from the gas during their formation. This is especially important if the stars form under the influence of feedback, as the stars’ velocities may symbiotically react to the removal of gas due to this feedback, rather than the stars’ velocities reacting to the removal of the decoupled gas potential, which in the N -body simulation is modelled as an additional massive particle (though see Dinnbier & Walch 2020 , for an alternative approach) . Therefore, removing the gas potential in the N -body simulation usually results in a drastic change in the dynamical evolution of the star particles ( Lada et al. 1984 ; Goodwin 1997 ; Proszkow et al. 2009 , e.g.) . In this paper, we take the sink particles from five SPH simulations ( Dale et al. 2012 ; Dale et al.